5 ms·
Unequivocal? There is literally no doubt as to the “safety”? That is demonstratively not true. On several occasions, several of the vaccines have been halted
by colechristensen 5y ago
Unequivocal? There is literally no doubt as to the “safety”? That is demonstratively not true. On several occasions, several of the vaccines have been halted by several separate health authorities over safety concerns. That is not zero doubt. This story is about exactly that.
You have to come up with a definition of “experimental” that suits you, and “emergency authorization” doesn’t sound like very well tested and understood.
People don’t understand risks very well nor can they compare risks very well and that has been demonstrated over and over again.
Covid vs vaccine risks vary quite a lot depending on what kind of person you are.
If you are quite old or have significant health problems, it is pretty easy to demonstrate with high confidence that the vaccine risk is way smaller than the Covid risk (many orders of magnitude).
If you are very young (say a healthy teenager) the Covid risk is very low and the uncertainties of the vaccine risks start to compete where it is much harder to have confidence that for a population vaccinating is a better idea. People also can have different appetites for risk and different appetites for the good of the individual vs the good of the many.
The problems with vaccination are many people pretend they are perfect or evil who are either knowingly distorting the truth or repeating lies or dogma. Also many people desire authoritarian solutions for everyone to agree with them.
What is actually needed are attempts to accurately represent risks and unknowns, and comparisons of those risks and unknowns which update over time as the unknowns get smaller. There also needs to be the ability to acknowledge that a crossover point may exist where on one side one decision may be better than on the other.
People though are being used to turn any contentious issue into political dogma and opportunities to signal morality.
The situation is not as simple as you and many people make it.
- margalabargala 5y ago> You have to come up with a definition of “experimental” that suits you, and “emergency authorization” doesn’t sound like very well tested and understood. I think you may have misread my comment. I agree that "emergency authorization" constitutes "experimental". My point is that there is now a vaccine that is no longer experimental, i.e. is as fully FDA approved as any other, and the mandates in place were put there after that approval. To the rest of your comment, when dealing with a contagious disease which spreads throughout society, I think that the people participating in a society should be able to set prerequisites for participating in that society. One person's rights end where another's begin, and with contagious diseases, a given person's low risk of death does not prevent them from spreading it to someone with much higher risk.
- grillvogel 5y agothe "full approval" happened much faster than any other vaccine or medication in recent memory. also the approval was based on the exact same dataset that was used for the EUA, to me that does not inspire confidence
- colechristensen 5y agoIt’s not about inspiring confidence, it’s about measuring uncertainty. Presently the uncertainty margins are higher for this than other things in the past and other things available. Different standards of uncertainty seem to be used for this, and that’s not necessarily bad considering the scale of the problem being addressed. BUT the uncertainty is not being appropriately represented by the people acting as information authorities.
- colechristensen 5y ago> the people participating in a society should be able to set prerequisites for participating in that society This is exactly what I’m saying with a different emphasis. Some societies will want to lean more towards conformity and collective good, other societies will want to lean more on individual choice and individual good. In America there’s a tendency to split into 50:50 camps between each (and each camp seems to alternate between individual freedom and conformity depending on the topic) Why is it that the way one camp thinks needs to dominate the other? How do you decide between individual choice and authoritarianism? I.e. Abortions? Individual choice. Vaccines? Authoritarianism. (Reverse for opposite political allegiance) There isn’t just one political philosophy for all societies and there seems to be pretty big disagreements (and self contradictions) all around. Most people though act like their opinions are the only possible opinions, and have no respect for different ideas and little concept of the actual issues at hand.
- margalabargala 5y ago> I.e. Abortions? Individual choice. Vaccines? Authoritarianism. (Reverse for opposite political allegiance) I think these examples are really interesting, because on both political sides, the exact same values are being applied, to a different set of definitions. In both cases, the "authoritarian" option is supported by for the topic that a group believes impacts more than one person, and the "individual choice" option supported by the group that believes that topic affects only one person. A person who believes that a society should protect its vulnerable from contagious disease, while also believing that lie begins at conception, is likely to support the "authoritarian" option for both topics.
- OrvalWintermute 5y ago> If you are quite old or have significant health problems, it is pretty easy to demonstrate with high confidence that the vaccine risk is way smaller than the Covid risk (many orders of magnitude). This is correct, covid is very threatening to those with multiple co-morbidities but in particular the obese diabetics. > If you are very young (say a healthy teenager) the Covid risk is very low and the uncertainties of the vaccine risks start to compete where it is much harder to have confidence that for a population vaccinating is a better idea. People also can have different appetites for risk and different appetites for the good of the individual vs the good of the many. This is correct too, Do No Harm is violated by forcing people to get vaccines when they are the extreme low risk populations of young people e.g. 1 in 4.5M fatality rate. That is why many countries with younger populations are starting to halt vaccine deployments to their populations at lowest risk, for whom a vaccine is more dangerous than covid. > The problems with vaccination are many people pretend they are perfect or evil who are either knowingly distorting the truth or repeating lies or dogma. Also many people desire authoritarian solutions for everyone to agree with them. In general I agree with you. The vaccines are dangerous, but they do not violate Do No Harm for at-risk populations, particularly those with co-morbidities. Because, the cure is better than the disease. But, we need to be careful about deploying these vaccines to young healthy populations when we know it puts them in danger of pericarditis/myocarditis, or, blood clots in the case of AZN or J&J However, the science has already shown that the Spike Protein on its own, as produced by the vaccine, is cytotoxic.
- margalabargala 5y ago> However, the science has already shown that the Spike Protein on its own, as produced by the vaccine, is cytotoxic. This is a false statement. The spike protein has been shown to be cytotoxic in vitro, but not as produced by the vaccine. The cytotoxicity is at a spike protein concentration orders of magnitude above that produced by the vaccine.
- OrvalWintermute 5y agoThat is incorrect. However, I will let distinguished researchers argue with you. The S1 protein is cytotoxic on its own [1] even without the rest of the virus The S1 protein can be found in the vaccinated [2] The S1 protein, on its own, can cross blood-barrier into the brain [3] Now, I know you want to argue that there is a huge difference between vaccinated Spike protein, and wild Spike. The evidence argues otherwise [4] [1] https://www.ahajournals.org/doi/10.1161/CIRCRESAHA.121.318902 https://www.ahajournals.org/doi/10.1161/CIRCRESAHA.121.31890... [2] https://academic.oup.com/cid/advance-article/doi/10.1093/cid/ciab465/6279075 https://academic.oup.com/cid/advance-article/doi/10.1093/cid... [3] https://www.nature.com/articles/s41593-020-00771-8 https://www.nature.com/articles/s41593-020-00771-8 [4] https://www.news-medical.net/news/20210409/Oxford-AstraZeneca-COVID-vaccine-induces-cell-spikes-similar-to-SARS-CoV-2s.aspx https://www.news-medical.net/news/20210409/Oxford-AstraZenec...