5 ms·
Let's not be completely shocked by capable, ingenious ancestors. Even in the ~190K years before we settled down, those people had brains identical to yours and
by wolverine876 5y ago
Let's not be completely shocked by capable, ingenious ancestors. Even in the ~190K years before we settled down, those people had brains identical to yours and mine.
And on the other hand, if you read some pre-Enlightenment things, it's apparent just how powerful (actual, accurate) knowledge and reason are. Imagine that nobody figured out the truth about gravity until Newton. Imagine that the very basics of what we know and how we think today were out there, and we had the brains, but the knowledge was mostly undeveloped for ~199,000 of the 200,000 years of humanity's existence.
So it takes more than brains. (Yes, I'm simplifying a very great deal.)
- MrBuddyCasino 5y ago> Even in the ~190K years before we settled down, those people had brains identical to yours and mine. Humans had larger brains in hunter & gatherer times. Similar to domesticated animals, it got smaller once we settled down and started agriculture.
- Ma8ee 5y agoI don’t think the correlation between brain size and general intelligence is that strong. Maybe the hunter gatherer used a bigger part of his brain to quickly and accurately interpret impressions, to find the food and not become food himself. The domestic man might have been better at tasks like figuring out how much of his seeds he could eat and how much he must save to plant next spring, even with a slightly smaller brain.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- david927 5y ago> Imagine that nobody figured out the truth about gravity until Newton. It was only one hundred or so years between Copernicus and Newton. And it looks like in that time Hooke and possibly others figured out that the movement of the new planetary model was because of gravity but it was Newton who mathematically proved it. That's pretty fast, really.
- mensetmanusman 5y agoThey were too busy not dying of starvation to think about gravity.
- wolverine876 5y ago> That's pretty fast, really. Pretty fast if you start the clock at Copernicus, not so fast if you start it 200,000 years ago when our first ancestors had the brains to figure it out.
- david927 5y agoYou know that Newton didn't "discover gravity," right? He discovered how it explained planetary motion. And it's not fair to start the clock before we got the heliocentric theory (although Aristarchus of Samos gets an honorable mention).
- wolverine876 5y agoAs I said, I'm simplifying a great deal. I imagine people before Newton noticed that if you don't hold things up, they fall.
- david927 5y ago> Our ancestors 200,000 years ago when our first ancestors had the brains to figure it out. Newton had to invent calculus to make the proof. You're not simplifying anything; you just got confused. And that's ok, honestly. There is literally not a person on this planet, now or ever, who didn't have holes in their knowledge or had something confused. It happens.
- hutzlibu 5y agoCome on, you know what he meant. Newton was the first to discover the laws of gravity, even though we still do not understand how gravity works and even though primitive animals can "discover" gravity.
- ardit33 5y agoWut... This guy is from the 14th century, which is a relatively modern era, where gun powder was starting to being used. This is just a century before the start of the renaissance, and we are not talking about thousands of years ago.
- MichaelZuo 5y agoAnatomically modern vocal chords only developed sometime between ~80000 to ~40000 BCE. So although that’s still quite a lot of time, it’s less than what is implied with cranial structure. It’s actually surprising how late and relatively sudden vocal chords developed compared to the rest of the body, as what ‘humans’ had prior was totally incapable of modern speech. It’s an unresolved mystery I believe.
- redwood 5y agoWow we must have been brilliant in other ways that we can't even imagine
- AlotOfReading 5y agoWhere did you get that range from? Anatomically modern humans are generally considered to predate at least 200kya and most of the synthetic literature I've read considers speech likely in archaic humans (otherwise a huge, unwieldy tongue doesn't make much sense). It's also pretty hard to get morphology timelines as restricted as 40k years, especially with soft tissues and the inherent preservation issues.
- malaya_zemlya 5y agoit is possible to speak without vocal cords, for example: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Whistled_language https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Whistled_language
- RedBeetDeadpool 5y agoVery cool. Also there are click languages. Given how much harder clicks are to regular vocalization, I wonder if they could be the remainders of some earlier languages before human vocalizations fully developed.
- streamofdigits 5y ago> So it takes more than brains. yep, it takes society. Newton's law is not Newton's law, its a mental state of a bunch of communicating homo sapiens. Had he died of a pandemic somebody else would have "discovered" it in a decade or two.
- wolverine876 5y agoI broadly agree and many discoveries are made independently at the same time, after that ~199,000ky delay (including some of Newton's, such as calculus). But what is "society"? What are you proposing as the mechanism?
- streamofdigits 5y agoit is the quality of the communication channels (the signal to noise ratio) between individuals. Diffusion of high quality information (from any early age) is what enables individuals to both internalize state-of-the-art collective mental models and incrementally contribute their own bit. in theory with the use of digital networks we should have a quantum leap forward but I am not sure we have seen yet any dividend of that. our collective (digitally intermediated) brain has been hijacked by less noble objectives
- wolverine876 5y agoVery interesting ideas, thanks. At least today, your theory played out. >in theory with the use of digital networks we should have a quantum leap forward but I am not sure we have seen yet any dividend of that. our collective (digitally intermediated) brain has been hijacked by less noble objectives It's not just less noble objectives. With high quality information available, people still choose poor info or mis/disinfo. Nobody I know is interested in quality information, even very educated people. Even here on HN, most sources are Wikipedia.
- redis_mlc 5y agoBronze worked well for weapons, but was rare. Iron democratized the making of weapons, available almost everywhere on Earth except Japan. But watch modern people try to smelt iron on Youtube in their backyard. Very difficult and time-consuming, and very toxic. Iron smelter staff around 1900 only lived to maybe age 30 before their lungs gave out.