4 ms·
> why is it so important that businesses pay a high corporate tax rate? It's not a high rate; 15% is low - is there a lower income tax rate for any entity? It
by wolverine876 5y ago
> why is it so important that businesses pay a high corporate tax rate?
It's not a high rate; 15% is low - is there a lower income tax rate for any entity?
It's important because societies need money to operate, including many things on which businesses depend such infrastructure; a good legal system; a healthy, educated, and prosperous population; security; stable, well-regulated markets; etc. If they don't pay their share, then others must or societies lose valuable things.
- Aerroon 5y agoAre corporations people now? Do they have their own special set of rights and privileges like people do? Ultimately, corporations are groups of people. Why isn't it sufficient to tax the money when the owners of the corporation are trying to cash out through dividends or in some other way? Why does it have to be taxed every year like income? Why is it necessary to tax money that the corporation would otherwise invest in R&D?
- wolverine876 5y ago> Are corporations people now? Do they have their own special set of rights and privileges like people do? Yes, that is why the legal structure exists: They've always been 'fictional persons'. That's what a corporation is: A separate entity where money can be pooled and personal liability (and taxes) limited, with it its own rights and privileges. It's fundamental to a corporation. > Ultimately, corporations are groups of people. Why isn't it sufficient to tax the money when the owners of the corporation are trying to cash out through dividends or in some other way? Why does it have to be taxed every year like income? Why is it necessary to tax money that the corporation would otherwise invest in R&D? That's called a partnership, and you are free to setup your business in that way. I'd talk to a lawyer first; there might be a reason that every major business is setup as a corporation - there must be something they like about it. Why must I personally pay taxes on money I'd use to invest in other things? All money in the economy is productive, yet we must tax something. Why does the corporation get off free while, requiring me to pay more?
- kukx 5y agoYour last argument could be reduced to "if evil happens to me, why not make it happen to others". If taxing investment is bad let's agree not to do it, instead of perpetuating the abuse. And no, definitely not all money is productive and it can be easily wasted on worthless products and services. Taxing the tools to create value is not the same as taxing for example vodka.
- wolverine876 5y ago> Your last argument could be reduced to "if evil happens to me, why not make it happen to others". It's not evil. Taxes are not evil at all. I want a functioning government, including the services it provides. There's a trendy concept that all taxes are evil, but rationally that doesn't hold any water at all. > definitely not all money is productive and it can be easily wasted on worthless products and services. Taxing the tools to create value is not the same as taxing for example vodka. This undermines the free market, and basic freedom. I judge for myself, knowing my situation, the best place to spend my money. Sometimes vodka has the highest ROI, and don't forget that the money goes to the store which then spends it again. Macroeconomically, even if I gave the liquor store owner money for nothing, I haven't burnt the money. It's in new hands ready to be spent again (and the rate of transactions has a major impact on the economy). But yes, we still can make some judgments about what to tax, and investment in fact often gets a tax break.
- kukx 5y agoI did not say that taxes are evil per se, but bad taxes are bad. "This undermines the free market (...)" - yes taxes obviously affect the free market. They are often meant to skew (regulate) it, like tax that targets unhealthy products eg cigarrets. Also, the way we spend money is not neutral to the economy. By buying one product over another we send an important signal about what is valuable. If we, as a sociaty choose junk, we will get more junk, if we choose good products, we will get even better products in the future. I recommend you read about "the broken window fallacy", since it is related.
- dragonwriter 5y ago> Are corporations people now? Always have been, legally. That’s the defining feature of the corporate form, as opposed to classic partnerships. > Why isn’t it sufficient to tax the money when the owners of the corporation are trying to cash out through dividends or in some other way? Why does it have to be taxed every year like income? Its the insurance premium for the liability shield that comes with the corporate form.
- DangitBobby 5y agoThat's weird, I've never seen a corporation sent to jail for egregious crimes.
- wolverine876 5y agoThey can be charged criminally, as can their officers and board, but it rarely happens.
- BurningFrog 5y agoThis myth will never die. Corporations are treated the same as people in some legal contexts. This is more practical than having two parallel sets of laws to keep in sync. It does not mean corporations are people.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- ethbr0 5y ago> Why isn't it sufficient to tax the money when the owners of the corporation are trying to cash out through dividends or in some other way? Because failing to tax capital formation in situ leads to all sorts of abuses. Exhibit A: The entire security-based lending industry [0], which allows you to realize the benefit of appreciated stock price while retaining stock ownership and without triggering a taxable event [0] https://www.investopedia.com/terms/s/securitiesbased-lending.asp https://www.investopedia.com/terms/s/securitiesbased-lending...
- Aerroon 5y agoBut those same abuses will happen anyway because we tax the corporations themselves and when the money is paid out from the corporation. Ie we will still have to deal with that exact same problem. It's just slightly smaller in scale.
- ethbr0 5y agoTaxing something vs not taxing it (while shareholders still receive a benefit) is a pretty large difference.
- csomar 5y agoWell, the thing is, some countries don't have these corporations to begin with. You can't tax a corporation that doesn't exist; and thus some countries are happy with the employment and economic activity these corps provide even if they pay no taxes (the employees still pay taxes, so these corps indirectly pay taxes). That's why these countries offer a 0% tax rate. Because that's the only attraction they can provide. This is a law that benefit the big rich countries.
- hetspookjee 5y agoNot quite as a lot of African countries get their small startups wiped out by the likes of FAANG and their local economy sees nothing back from it as all the revenue made gets taxed in Ireland and or some other haven. The countries with a 0% tax rate are not that many as far as I am aware and neither is the corporate presence there, if any.
- wolverine876 5y agoWho can say what they are happy with, but perhaps they benefit from not being strong-armed by companies into not taxing them.
- csomar 5y agoQuite the other way. They are being strong-armed by other countries (especially the EU) into taxing companies.
- wolverine876 5y agoYou don't think companies strong-arm governments? I see it happen in the U.S. Imagine what they do in a small, poor country. The mining industry is an example.
- roenxi 5y ago> It's not a high rate; 15% is low - is there a lower income tax rate for any entity? Yes, there are plenty of entities that pay no tax. There'd be a great number of clubs for example. Churches, charity and trusts often get some sort of exemption too depending on country and circumstance. The only reason it might seem like all entities pay taxes is because once something is taxable it has to be given sharp, forceful boundaries otherwise it disappears and gets renamed. I don't actually mind a 15% global minimum, to me that seems like it can only hurt poor countries in theory so if they want to sign up for it that is their problem. But companies are part of the things societies need to operate. A society with no Apple had to wait another decade - maybe more - to see real smartphones. A country without an Amazon has measurably worse logistics & distribution than one that does. It is not at all obvious that companies should be taxed. All they do is work to benefit consumers (within a moral-less, economic understanding of the word benefit).
- omnimus 5y agoYes corporations are very much like churches and charities. We should exempt them from paying taxes.
- wolverine876 5y ago> There'd be a great number of clubs for example. Churches, charity and trusts often get some sort of exemption too depending on country and circumstance. Excellent point. > companies are part of the things societies need to operate Agreed, and so are individuals, and in fact individuals are what society exists for. Companies have no special place or status - they idea that they are somehow superior to rather inferior to real persons, is shocking. > All they do is work to benefit consumers The theory is that all they do is work to benefit their shareholders, to maximize profit. Certainly, they do many things that provide no benefit to their customers; as a simple example, Apple could charge much less, benefiting consumers, be just as effective (they don't need trillions of dollars of assets), but that would reduce profits for shareholders. Capitalism, for good or ill, benefits the capital-holders.
- roenxi 5y ago> Apple could charge much less, benefiting consumers, be just as effective (they don't need trillions of dollars of assets) If we ignored 2nd order effects yes. In practice, no. This is the only way for other phone companies to realise that their products are bad and that they need to improve. We can observe that when Apple came in to the market and started selling their phone at absurd volumes and profit margins, the other phone OEMs moved like lightening to catch up. The market for mobiles completely reformed in a few years. If Apple had charged razor thin margins, it would have been much less obvious how much value was being created, and Apple wouldn't have had the cash reserves to reshape the market as fundamentally as it did. Consumers would have been much worse off. Since nearly nobody is forced to buy an iPhone, all that money that Apple has represents at least value created in the past and that value probably wouldn't exist had Apple been forced to go slowly and work with slim profits. One of the fun observations of economics is while capitalists would like very high rates of profit they can't actually achieve them long term in a relatively free market. Other capitalists will figure out what is valuable, muscle in and bring the rates of profit down to a return consistent with the risk.