3 ms·
That's only really true if you also support antitrust laws, though (i.e. don't support laissez-faire capitalism). If you end up in a situation with entrenched w
by _delirium 15y ago
That's only really true if you also support antitrust laws, though (i.e. don't support laissez-faire capitalism). If you end up in a situation with entrenched whole-sector monopolies and high barriers to entry, it becomes much harder to buy an alternative, so the owns-all-computer-manufacturing HP could get away with shitty management for years or decades, and buy up or drive out of business (e.g. through temporary dumping) any nascent competitors.
- mwsherman 15y agoI don't disagree, but monopolies are generally unstable. HP and Microsoft are hardly dictating terms anymore. Their ability to erect barriers to entry is weak, unless they are getting help from the gov't. See telecoms & utilities. Antitrust is often ineffective in practice. Sounds great in theory, but it is also a form of central planning. The best the gov't can do, in my opinion, is reduce the barriers to entry that it itself erects. Highly regulated environments, for example, usually protect incumbents.
- _delirium 15y agoI agree when it comes to the headline enforcement actions (breakups, etc.), which are done in a pretty haphazard way with questionable effectiveness. But I think the existence of the body of law does discourage the most egregious types of monopoly-protection activities. For example, few companies will do things that look too much like outright dumping, stuff like giving your product away for free for 12 months in order to crush your new startup competitor who's secured 12 months of funding.
- mwsherman 15y agoThat example doesn't bother me too much, though there are plenty of smart folks who would disagree. I don't like IE's dominance, which dates back to exactly what you describe (vs Netscape). But the outcome is that the Internet became a mass phenomenon. I don't think it would obviously have been so if Netscape and MS charged for browsers. Heck, companies used to charge for TCP/IP stacks. Dumping looks pro-consumer in this context.
- yummyfajitas 15y agoIn theory, that is indeed an issue with natural monopolies. In practice, however, the only areas I can think of where actual monopolies exist are areas with government granted monopolies, e.g. telco/cable or patent trolls. I'm sure there are a few natural ones, however. But you did catch me - I'm not a laissez-faire capitalism purist. I just think it's a pretty good first approximation.