3 ms·
>I do agree it’s going to be hard to make this profitable without trampling on the workforce is 15 minute delivery any more exploitative than 2-day or even "re
by gruez 5y ago
>I do agree it’s going to be hard to make this profitable without trampling on the workforce
is 15 minute delivery any more exploitative than 2-day or even "regular" delivery? seems like all the issues with delivery (eg. poor warehouse conditions, low pay, contractor classification, pressure to meet metrics) are there regardless of whether it's 15 minute delivery or not.
- adrianN 5y agoYou can bundle 2 day deliveries to increase efficiency. You don't need a delivery person with just one or two items do the trip between warehouse and your mailbox.
- gruez 5y agoDoes bundling 2-day deliveries make companies less willing to exploit workers or something? Is working as a gig economy food delivery worker better than working as an amazon delivery worker?
- kevincox 5y agoNo, but price affects demand. So 2-day delivery doesn't have to drive down costs quite as hard to meet the required price (which is probably a bit lower but similar to the 15min service). Of course the workers will be exploited anyways because lower costs means more profits but they don't need to be exploited quite as much. At the end of the day the workers will be exploited exactly up to the limit of what the company can get away with. For "disposable" and interchangeable untrained workers like delivery people that limit is pretty high.
- gruez 5y ago> No, but price affects demand. So 2-day delivery doesn't have to drive down costs quite as hard to meet the required price (which is probably a bit lower but similar to the 15min service). This argument only works if you consider 15-minute delivery as a different business unit as 2-day delivery, so they'll be fighting it out to gain market share. In reality, the same company is behind both options, so it doesn't really matter. They really don't care if you choose 15-minute or 2-day delivery, only that you bought it from them. If anything, they'll keep the 2-day delivery cost the same and charge a premium for 15-minute, because "how urgently you want it" is a pretty good price discriminator.
- DavidPeiffer 5y ago>Is working as a gig economy food delivery worker better than working as an amazon delivery worker? The physical work? No idea. From a risk and compensation standpoint, probably much better at Amazon. If you crash your car driving for Uber Eats, you're on the hook for it. If you're injured on the job, you simply don't earn money since you're an independent contractor. Not to mention health, life, and disability insurance and PTO all provided by most large companies, and having a point of contact who might care about you on a personal level as opposed to getting all your work assignments from an app optimizing profit not for you, but for the service company. My employer ships coolers of food to people. The fulfillment centers are cold, and it's really hard work. But if John's car breaks down, the team works together and figures it out. Mary agrees to swing by and pick John up on her way to work, and Mark will take him home after the shift until the car is fixed. The manager sometimes picks people up herself.
- adrianN 5y agoMaybe not, but if the business has higher margins, workers have a much better chance of demanding fair pay than if the business has negative margins even at exploitative wage levels.
- gruez 5y ago>Maybe not, but if the business has higher margins [...] does it? 15 minute delivery definitely costs more so you could argue that margin is lower, but at the same time you could argue that 15 minute delivery is a premium product that can command a higher margin.
- michaelt 5y agoMuch easier to give health insurance to 100 drivers working 8 hours a day than to 400 drivers working 2 hours a day.
- villasv 5y ago> Is 15 minute delivery any more exploitative than 2-day or even "regular" delivery? Not inevitably but probably, because a stricter SLO introduces higher logistic optimization constraints. Those constraints are targeted prioritizing low costs and don't care about higher human-labor inefficiency. For example, have more personnel more evenly distributed throughout the city, but they'll have more wait-times between deliveries. Is that wait-time paid for? Usually not. A more relaxed SLO gives more room to aim for efficiency (bundling deliveries, sequencing routes) and thus it's easier to justify hiring someone full-time and in a stable and predictable work relationship.