6 ms·
Github _is_ the embrace phase. It is sad that a lot of OSS projects do not see it. MS has through Github control over OSS. As someone noted in another post they
by hulitu 5y ago
Github _is_ the embrace phase. It is sad that a lot of OSS projects do not see it. MS has through Github control over OSS. As someone noted in another post they want admin access. This means that they can do what they want with your code even injecting malware.
I wonder if people wanting to deprecate FTP do not have a hidden agenda. Because with https you are at the mercy of an organization.
- 2fast4you 5y agoOh I think we’ve started the extend phase. Did you notice they put out their own GitHub specific git cli? And they removed ssh links and replaced them with links specific to their cli
- badsectoracula 5y agoAt least in a couple of projects i just checked the SSH link is still there, between the HTTPS and the GitHub CLI command.
- viccuad 5y agoOnly if you are logged in. It used to be there always.
- tkfu 5y agoAre you sure about that? I certainly don't recall that, and it seems like it would be a bad UX idea anyway: you can't clone a repo via SSH without having an account (and a pubkey registered), so showing the SSH string to people who aren't logged in seems counterproductive.
- DrewRWx 5y ago`gh`is great for handling pull requests and other GitHub specifics. I still use `git` for everything else, so I dunno how much it does, but it makes sense if `gh` overlaps with some `git` commands to round out the tool.
- muxator 5y agoYou've been lured by the "extend" phase.
- maccolgan 5y agoIsn't GH's PR some awful sugar around the concept of merging a patchset?
- kuschku 5y ago`hub` had the same functionality and could be used either standalone or integrated with git so `git hub` ran hub commands to e.g. manage a pull request. gh is just trying to get you to stop using git itself
- bewuethr 5y agoThe SSH links aren't replaced by the gh links, the gh links are just an additional option.
- bewuethr 5y agoOr actually, they aren't replaced everywhere: the "Code" tab still has HTTPS and SSH in addition to the GitHub CLI; the "Pull Request" tab has only the CLI.
- mathw 5y agoThe .NET Foundation wanting admin access to repos of projects under the .NET Foundation umbrella is very much not the same thing as how the people who run GitHub could backdoor any repo they like whenever they want, obviously they can they have the source code to the hosting platform. Except that's pretty hard to do without developers noticing because you'd need to engineer some hash collisions to get their local git clones to accept the code changes. So let's limit the paranoia to where it actually applies, shall we? The .NET Foundation has made a right mess of this, but it's not the same thing as Microsoft trying to backdoor all open source code on GitHub. I'm pretty sure the people there are smart enough to realise how much that would backfire.
- fgaltx 5y agoThe OSS projects don't see it because they are paid by Microsoft for not seeing it. Around 2014 Microsoft hired some of the most power hungry and not-particularly-technical OSS developers. They have subverted projects. Any criticism is deflected by the hired people (who might not have many alternatives).
- Macha 5y agoThe first time they did this with the hub tool, GitHub was only a few years old and many years away from any acquisition