2 ms·
The aspect of this case that stands out to me is that copyright is claimed in clothing and fashions: "counterfeit retailers that sell knock-off dresses using t
by dredmorbius 5y ago
The aspect of this case that stands out to me is that copyright is claimed in clothing and fashions: "counterfeit retailers that sell knock-off dresses using the plaintiffs' copyrighted images", a claim traditionally well outside copyright, and at best quite grey. Copyright covers works of original authorship but not either ideas or functional aspects of design.
See the strong-IP case from the Copyright Alliance, who can at best muster an "it depends":
There are some mixed messages out there about whether fashion designs are eligible for copyright protection. Some experts would say “no,” others would say “yes,” and they’re both right it depends.
https://copyrightalliance.org/education/qa-headlines/copyright-fashion-designs/ https://copyrightalliance.org/education/qa-headlines/copyrig...
In the US, such protections are still only at the "being considered" stage as best I can tell:
The major amendment, of course, would be the extension of design protection to fashion designs, by amending § 1301(a) to provide that “A fashion design is subject to protection under this chapter” and by amending § 1302(b) to include “an article of apparel” in the definition of “useful articles” subject to protection.
https://www.copyright.gov/docs/regstat072706.html https://www.copyright.gov/docs/regstat072706.html
As the Copyright office's discussion notes, there are non-expressive protections in the specific case of ship hull designs (also in chip masks). But fashion itself has remained largely a copyright-free zone.
The proposed language did not enter into US law as evideced at Cornell's USC server:
https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/17/1301 https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/17/1301
Cloudflare has secured this round without challenging the copyrightability of the alleged infinged works themselves, but probably also has that arrow in their quivver should they need to invoke it. The court's decision here is actually a broader protection for Cloudflare (it would apply against any infringement claim), though it doesn't invalidate the plaintiff's IMO questionable fashion-based copyright claims.
- pessimizer 5y agoSuppressing knockoffs is often the reason behind (and something hidden within) laws and treaties against counterfeits. Clear knockoffs, whose buyers know they are knockoffs, are not counterfeits any more than Monopoly money is counterfeit currency.
- wmf 5y agoPutting aside fashion copyrights, it's a bad sign if a company is using somebody else's photos of somebody else's products to sell their knockoffs. They deserve to get nuked.
- dredmorbius 5y agoUse of photos is straight up old-fashioned (so to speak) copyright infringement. No need for design copyright.