So in that case, wouldn’t the right way to handle it be to get a warrant to have Cloudflare give you the identity so that they can be prosecuted under copyright

So in that case, wouldn’t the right way to handle it be to get a warrant to have Cloudflare give you the identity so that they can be prosecuted under copyright law? And if there is no law being broken, Cloudflare doesn’t have a responsibility to do anything. You wouldn’t want a company to reveal your identity just because someone asked nicely. You’d want a judge to approve a warrant.