5 ms·
Why would they adopt something as volatile as cryptocurrency as legal tender?
by asdff 5y ago
Why would they adopt something as volatile as cryptocurrency as legal tender?
- tombert 5y agoApparently, a fairly high percentage of El Salvador's economy is based on people outside the country sending currency in, so I think the idea was to use a currency that makes it relatively cheap and easy to send money from the US to El Salvador. That said, since they're on the US Dollar anyway, I think it might have made more sense to use a stablecoin like GUSD or DAI or something.
- asdff 5y agoIf its USD to USD in this case, why not mail a check? I wonder if you could even just scan a check and email it and use a mobile bank app to deposit a printed copy. Or even have the US relative log into the Salvadoran relatives bank account and do it all within the U.S.
- woah 5y agoYou should let the El Salvadoreans know about all these ideas, might save them a lot of trouble
- tombert 5y agoWell, I mean, mailing a check takes a long time, certainly longer than sending some bitcoin would take, even if it was free. Emailing a scan could work, but wouldn't that be completely trivial to abuse? If someone gets a Gmail password, they could just photoshop a the check to empty out your relative's account with very low effort. I think blockchain kind of solves these two particular problems; the money transfers are relatively quick (around 20 minutes for bitcoin), and you have all this cryptographic goodness to minimize the potential for fraud.
- asdff 5y agoIt shouldn't matter how long it takes to mail after the first check is mailed, right? If the relative in the US is sending money every biweekly pay check and it takes 9 days or whatever to mail a check, the relative in El Salvador is still getting a check every two weeks, just nine days later on the calendar than payday.
- hackingforfun 5y agoLightning network transactions occur in seconds, if not milliseconds [1]. https://lightning.network/ https://lightning.network/
- int_19h 5y agoChecks are not common outside of US and a few other countries. Checks from another country especially can be a hassle to cash, may take a long time (as in weeks!), and may require paying a percentage fee to the bank.
- tombert 5y agoThey're not terribly common even within the US. I refinanced my house recently, and and I had to order a new checkbook from my bank to do it, because I couldn't find the one they gave me four years ago. Every time I do have to write a check, I always have to "figure it out" again, which isn't exactly rocket science, but is a testament to how little I write checks. Like most of the world, I use credit cards or debit cards or a cash sending app.
- asdff 5y agoyet you can still cash a check and write a check even if its not popular.
- int_19h 5y agoThey're common enough for banks to universally support them. E.g. if you get compensation from some company (due to overpaid bill, legal settlement etc), it'll usually come as a check by default - and sometimes that's the only available option. I've also dealt with landlords and home repair providers that would only accept checks.
- gus_massa 5y agoAt least here in Argentina, if you have a check of a bank od USA, only a few banks accept it and they take a huge cut.
- xtracto 5y agoI think at some point I read that given the amount of the GDP that remittances are in El Salvador, and the % that Western Union and similar services charge for each transfer, they calculated that a good chunk of the GDP was being left in these transfer services. In the case of Mexico, remittances would be 3.8% of the GDP, and the WU fee is 8% [1], which means that 0.3% of the GDP is being left in the table. In El Salvador I think it is about 20%, which would mean that 1.6% of the GDP is being left in the WU and similar services. [1] https://www.westernunion.com/us/en/send-money/app/price-estimator https://www.westernunion.com/us/en/send-money/app/price-esti...
- zitterbewegung 5y agoThe only thing I can think of is monitoring of all transactions.
- anonporridge 5y agoYou can do that way more easily will centralized digital fiat.
- Apocryphon 5y agoHow are cryptocurrencies even "encrypted" and more anonymous than hard cash if all transactions are recorded in a ledger, the ledger that is the very basis of the currency? Isn't that the very antithesis of anonymity?
- freeflight 5y agoAfaik that claim to fame originally came from the fact how it's really difficult to track down the real owner of a wallet. With traditional bank accounts there's usually a whole circus of verifying your real identity involved that's directly tied to the account. While getting a BC wallet involves none of that, heck, it can probably be automated to such a degree that asking the question "Who actually owns the wallet created by a bot?" could become an interesting legal conundrum.
- kristjansson 5y agoBitcoin and its ilk are explicitly pseudonymous not anonymous. Others attempt to provide actual anonymity, but lack the usage and mindshare of bitcoin
- treebot 5y agoActual paper cash is more anonymous than most crypto, including Bitcoin.
- WJW 5y agoLack of imagination. Step 1: Buy a lot of bitcoin. Step 2: Convince/bribe the President of El Salvador to make bitcoin the legal tender. Step 3: Bitcoin goes up because "OMG legal tender status" even though it is in a super minor country that was de facto using the USD as currency anyway. Step 4: Sell your bitcoin at a profit due to the events of step 3. Step 5: Who cares about what happens after step 4.
- rattlesnakedave 5y agoFrom what I understand citizens are allowed to swap the government for USD. El Salvador’s current president seems keen on building a Bitcoin reserve.
- modeless 5y agoThe "local currency" is US dollars. And now Bitcoin.
- asdff 5y agoIn that case maybe their strategy might be to convert as much USD within the country into bitcoin as possible, wait for the inevitable next huge surge, sell at the peak and increase their central bank holdings of USD by a massive amount.
- colechristensen 5y agoI really doubt a central banks fiscal policy revolves around speculating in BTC.
- fleddr 5y agoAdmittedly, they are the first, but there's little to be surprised about. Bitcoin is the best performing asset with a 200% average YoY return for 12 years straight. Whilst still volatile, there's enough trust in long term value for institutional adaption, which is the phase we're in the middle of. 1 in 6 Americans own Bitcoin. Companies are holding it. Clearly, it no longer is an internet joke. It's accepted as an asset.
- asdff 5y agowhy? central banks make investments.
- javert 5y agoThey can continue to price things in US dollars without letting American elites steal from them through the Cantillon effect. If you didn't know, they were using US dollars before. Just my two cents. The real reason is probably so the El Salvador political powers can enrich themselves, either through simply holding bitcoin, or some form of corruption.
- arenaninja 5y agoIt's an attempt to attract foreign investment to reduce dependency on US remittances
- WJW 5y agoIt was also sold to the President of El Salvador by some rather savvy salesmen who may or may not have had a prior long position in bitcoin before the announcement was made.
- fleddr 5y agoWas this before or after the IMF party telling the country what is good for them, but never is?
- sremani 5y agoIt is an attempt to become 'panama' without the legal and political framework.
- randomhodler84 5y agoNot cryptocurrency, Bitcoin. “The central bank must be trusted not to debase the currency, but the history of fiat currencies is full of breaches of that trust." - SN Volatility is of far less concern than a 3rd party countries money printing.
- ceejayoz 5y ago> Volatility is of far less concern than a 3rd party countries money printing. Not when you get your weekly paycheck, it's not.
- thebean11 5y agoBoth seem like issues to me? Either your paychecks are being adjusted for inflation (in which case they could be adjusted to the Bitcoin price) or they are not adjusted for inflation and each check is smaller than the last.
- sonicggg 5y agoLet's start sending your weekly payment checks in Zimbabwean Dollars, and see how much of that matters.
- ceejayoz 5y agoZimbabwean dollars were highly volatile. Getting your paycheck and not knowing it'll be worth roughly the same amount next week when rent is due is a serious problem.
- stocknoob 5y agoDo you want your weekly paycheck in an inflationary or deflationary currency?
- postingawayonhn 5y agoEither, whichever is most stable.
- whiskyant 5y agoPretty much any fledging currency will be volatile. So you might as well be asking why anyone would adopt any new currency? As a currency gains adoption and value, its volatility naturally goes down. As far as what advantages bitcoin has over traditional existing currency? Numerous. Immutable, unseizable, uncensorable, fixed supply/non-inflationary/store of value, digitally transferrable without a 3rd party.
- jodrellblank 5y agoBitcoins have been seized, and stolen. Bitcoins have been banned in China. Not at all transferable without a majority of nodes on the network agreeing - unless you mean you can hand a flash drive to someone, and that’s not an advantage to a currency you can hand notes to someone. Why is “non inflationary” an advantage? It means less incentive to spend, more incentive to hoard, and anyone who comes later is necessarily poorer. It’s terrible, population increases and younger people fight for the scraps of the few bitcents left, so the pyramid early adopters can take advantage. That isn’t going to hold as a stable system.
- treebot 5y agoHow would a government seize Bitcoin? Stealing Bitcoin is not the same as seizing.
- dragonwriter 5y ago> How would a government seize Bitcoin? The same way it seizes anything else; have people with guns show up [0] to the person with control over it, and inform them they must turn it over or face dire consequences. Seizing money held in a personal wallet means doing that to the owner (whether its a physical or digital wallet), seizing money held in a third-party service (often the case with Bitcoin) means doing it to the service operator. > Stealing Bitcoin is not the same as seizing. True, in that “stealing” is what is called when someone seizes property from another without legal authority. But false in the senae that seems intended, in that the mechanics the government uses when seizing something are exactly mechanics that would constitute stealing if they weren't backed by law. [0] Or people without guns with the implicit backing of people with guns. Or just messages from an agency known to be backed by people with guns.
- dqpb 5y agoIn theory as you earn bitcoin, you can exchange it in a marketplace for other currencies if various risk levels, including stablecoins for low risk, or even for a few fiat currencies. In practice, I assume most El Salvadorians aren't on Binance or Coinbase Pro.
- I_am_tiberius 5y agoBecause it's great to have multiple options. As a consumer you don't have to use it.
- jcranmer 5y agoOstensibly, the purpose of adopting Bitcoin is to make possible remittances with lower fees. This immediately raises the question of why not establish or partner with another bank that would allow lower fee remittances, and instead partner with a shadow bank to do so. And the most reasonable answer, to me at least, is that by using a shadow banking mechanism, they'd evade (international) inspection, which would allow them to potentially skim money out of ordinary El Salvadoran bank accounts.