3 ms·
Maybe less known is a parallel conflict between the EU and the German Constitution Court that is an ongoing head-scratcher for the German government. It's eeri
by Tomte 5y ago
Maybe less known is a parallel conflict between the EU and the German Constitution Court that is an ongoing head-scratcher for the German government.
It's eerily similar to the Polish situation: the German court has always held that it would hold ultimate judicial power in conflicts between EU law and the German constitution (the two landmark decisions from 1974 and 1984 are even called "Solange" I and II - meaning "as long as [EU law and jurisprudence stays sane]").
With all those bond buying and financial emergency policies the Constitution Court started probing decisions by the EU court. The EU court shot back, the Constitution Court escalated further… it's still completely open and unresolved.
But also less spectacular than firing politically inconvenient judges, so mostly Poland is in the news.
- chalst 5y agoIt's very different constitutionally: the German situation is that the supreme court holds that EU constitutional supremacy is valid, but must not contradict the basic law. The Polish situation is that the supreme court was pushed to one side in a constitutionally dubious gambit in order to declare constitutional supremacy invalid. The German situation is weird, but it's not essentially different that a government might agree to an international treaty and then take its time over passing legislation to conform to it that isn't unambiguously identical to what it agreed it would do.
- Woodi 5y ago> It's very different constitutionally: the German situation is that the supreme court holds that EU constitutional supremacy is valid, but must not contradict the basic law. So you are saying, in that description, that German internal law is not superior ? Looks quite opposite to me, German juries can over-decide EU juries :> > The Polish situation is [...] So Germans do PR bla bla bla but override when convenient but Poland in same situation is "different" ?? Check your logic mate.
- chalst 5y agoI'm British, with the snippet of legal training appropriate to a one-time would-be chartered accountant, and I'm acutely aware that the German legal tradition is hugely different to the British one, so while i have taken care to understand what follows, I am not an expert and may be mistaken. There is no error in my logic, but the subtleties are tricky. Constitutions are two different things: they are literal agreements, with a semantics, and they are a state of affairs, that enforces the agreement. In countries where the supreme authority is a court that has a high level of public trust, as in Germany, it's common to forget about the latter part of the arrangement and take the constitution to be the literal agreement. Some other countries, like Britain which does not even have a single document that codifies the agreement, this is not forgotten. My understanding of the matter is that the German supreme court is essentially saying that it accepts the state of affairs has changed, i.e. it is not the only court that gets to decide matters because of constitutional supremacy, without saying that it will agree with EU law if it is asked to decide on matters. What is being called #polexit is that a body that the Polish government claims has constitutionl authority has effectively rejected the state-of-affairs part of the constitution. In fact, the situation is constitutionally dubious: the body the government formed to do this does not appear to have the power the governement claims it does according to Poland's constitutional law. This is a quite different situation. My guess is that the Polish government will not succeed in their strategy, but they have undoubtedly created a huge crisis, both in Poland and the EU.
- Woodi 5y agoListen, you keep to arguing that Germans can decide that EU law is sometimes insane - they are overriding so their law have more power. Pretty clear. Literal law can be and usually is missinterpreted. Also, what Poland just do was: in 2005 our juries decided superiority of our Constitution and we only continue what was said earlier Period. No some imaginary #polexit or "dubious claims" as you judge yourself. Or maybe you are brainwashed that way or wishes this to be true. And polish jury that do exactly this in 2005 is in EU jury institution now. An that is already centuries old problem in Poland: our people, usually for personal gain, decide to harm Poland. Check history, if you like. And crisis ? Mate, "stop drinking Cool-Aid" or how they say that things. EU trying to harm few member countries and that is a problem. Not sticking to country sovereignty. And if EU want federation and others do not want this (yet) then that also not a crisis but putting assholes into place. Becouse they do not work for common all european member states good. Funny note: you yourself ACKed that EU sometimes make INSANE law, full agree on that :) But why only Germans and nobody else is qualified to state obvious insanity of EU (law in that case) ? You somehow belive in well-disproved Germans superiority ? :) Looks like kinda lack in humor abilities is rather a problem then positive trait :)
- rsj_hn 5y ago> But also less spectacular than firing politically inconvenient judges, so mostly Poland is in the news. Poland had a problem with communist judges that were holdovers from the system where judges appointed other judges rather than being appointed by the executive and approved by the legislature. Of course Poland wanted to reform this system by having judges appointed by a commission and approved by parliament, and to replace these judges that were appointed by other judges. The resulting hysteria over this move in the western press was truly amazing -- "war on rule of law", "lack of judicial indepence", etc, all for trying to end a situation in which judges selected their own replacements. It was also an eye opener in terms of understanding what the EU -- an institution setup to bypass democratic pressure -- really means when it talks about "rule of law".
- chalst 5y agoGiving career politicians the power to exercise discretion in the process of selecting judges does end the rule of law, and that's true even if their are shell committees formed to hide this exercise of power from those who don't see what is happening. Purging corruption in legal institutions is a hard problem, but that doesn't mean there is any hysteria in using strong words when they are deserved.
- rsj_hn 5y agoAlmost every nation has judges appointed by politicians, including every nation in the EU and North America. Kakistocracy is not rule of law. The idea that only in Poland should judges appoint their own replacement creates a different yardstick for them versus everyone else. I get why the EU bureaucrats wouldn't want to give Polish politicians the same influence over judges as German or French politicians, as the EU views polish politicians as enemies, but no one with integrity or honesty would go along with that kind of doublespeak.
- chalst 5y agoThis is not quite true, but indeed it is typically true that there is some ability for certain politicians to veto the appointment of judges, and in some countries (esp. the US) this has led to politicisation of the whole process of appointments (which I do actually regard as a failure of the rule of law), so what I wrote was also not quite true. And of course in the US and Canada, the appointment to the Supreme Court is entirely political, although there are substantial checks on the executive. However, the context was talking about firing of judges. That is far more important. It is the difference between what is happening in the US (which leads to bad judicial activism, but not a complete breakdown of the rule of law) and Nazi Germany (apologies for violating Godwin's law, but since I live in Germany and my wife and kids are German, I feel I have the right to violate it once per year).