3 ms·
> radical new derailleur that uses an electric current to heat up and move mouldable wires So, this is just for bicycles with massive batteries, which could as
by kazinator 5y ago
> radical new derailleur that uses an electric current to heat up and move mouldable wires
So, this is just for bicycles with massive batteries, which could as well use internal gearing of some sort.
Derailleurs are finnicky. You calibrate the shifter for sure-fire upshifting with the index clicker lever, which sacrifices downshifting. When you downshift, you have to overshoot: give an extra pull to get the thing to shift, which is then retracted to the index position.
Maybe this is fixed in some True Scotsman's derailleurs that cost hundreds of dollars; mine cost some $60 (which is three times more expensive already than what you see installed on the majority of bikes in the sub $1000 category). It's a road bike derailleur on a road cassette: which is going to be the best shifting combination, due to the differences in adjacent cog size being small. I'm downshifting from 12 teeth to 13, 14, 15, ...
The reason shifting is imprecise is because when you move the parallelogram of a derailleur, that moves the upper wheel, called the jockey wheel. This indirectly changes the gear by moving the chain. This has to overshoot the shift position in order to work; it cannot just move from being centered over one cog to being centered over the next. The farther this jockey wheel is from the cog set, the more overshoot it needs to get the chain to jump.
Whimsically speaking, we could say that shifting the chain is a bit like getting a dog to go left and right using nothing but the leash.
You can play with how far the jockey wheel is from each cog to some extent. There is a "B screw" adjustment which helps with it somewhat. Mainly, the screw helps the other way: if the jockey wheel is riding too close, the screw can help get it away, but if the jockey wheel is riding far from the cassette, the screw is often ineffective in bringing it closer.
Mainly, because the cogs are of different sizes, the parallelogram geometry of the derailleur has to match the cog set style; this is one reason why there are road derailleurs and others. Road bike gearing has less of a spread between high and low, so the jockey wheel tracks at a different angle from the steep spread of a mountain bike cassette. (Road bikes often have only two rings in the front also, and so there is less spread between the maximum and minimum chain length. For that reason, the derailleurs also have shorter cages. Some road derailleurs models come in two cage lengths: you choose wisely based on your system.)
In general you will get much crisper shifting on a road cassette with a road derailleur because the steps in cog size are smaller. To execute a downshift, the chain has to "climb" onto a larger cog. This happens more easily if the larger one just has one or two more teeth.
I think that to have an effective system that is fully electric, it would be best to control the whole relevant configuration: the frame (how exactly the derailleur is mounted), and the cassette it is used with, and probably the front derailleur also.
The system will have to be able to move the derailleur quickly, and implement the proper overshoot and return. Cyclists expect fast gear changes.