3 ms·

But part of the insight they are likely to have is that every case is different and that the differences matter, and that the legal judgments are best left to a

But part of the insight they are likely to have is that every case is different and that the differences matter, and that the legal judgments are best left to a lawyer. Would you post a question here asking for medical advice?

davidw 18y ago
This site isn't remotely about doctors or health, so obviously not. I don't believe every case is that different though, and there are some common threads, as can be seen in the recent advice-wanted article (LLC's are cheap and easy, definitely get a lawyer if there's more than one person). Would anyone here recommend that people use Cobol or Forth to make a web site with, unless the user has some really outlandish requirements? In other words, advice here may be good for getting the 'gist' of how things are or ought to be. Clearly, when you want to get serious, at that point you should consult a lawyer. For example, I think pretty much anyone can tell you that forming a partnership instead of an LLC or corporation is likely to be a bad idea, or that people aiming for investments are likely better off with a C corporation. Of course, there are lots of underlying details that need to be looked after by a professional. Furthermore, I like learning about this stuff, and it's not rocket science. Complex, in some cases, certainly, but this isn't a group of people that shys away from tough or complex things. The important thing is to keep in mind that we aren't experts in it, simply learners.
- michael_dorfman 18y ago
  I hear what you're saying, and I understand the desire to tackle complex and tough things-- but some things are best left to professionals, believe me. I can think of a few times where a lack of proper legal advice cost me more than a million dollars. Once burned, twice shy.
  - davidw 18y ago
    Look at it as a way to learn about what you're about to buy. Informed buyers are likely to get a better product for less money.
jgamman 18y ago
why? do you think there's something wrong with me?
mrtron 18y ago
The topic of mental health comes up regularly. I consider that to be a large portion of your overall health. People commonly discuss everything from depression to motivational issues.

davidw 18y ago

This site isn't remotely about doctors or health, so obviously not. I don't believe every case is that different though, and there are some common threads, as can be seen in the recent advice-wanted article (LLC's are cheap and easy, definitely get a lawyer if there's more than one person). Would anyone here recommend that people use Cobol or Forth to make a web site with, unless the user has some really outlandish requirements? In other words, advice here may be good for getting the 'gist' of how things are or ought to be. Clearly, when you want to get serious, at that point you should consult a lawyer. For example, I think pretty much anyone can tell you that forming a partnership instead of an LLC or corporation is likely to be a bad idea, or that people aiming for investments are likely better off with a C corporation. Of course, there are lots of underlying details that need to be looked after by a professional. Furthermore, I like learning about this stuff, and it's not rocket science. Complex, in some cases, certainly, but this isn't a group of people that shys away from tough or complex things. The important thing is to keep in mind that we aren't experts in it, simply learners.

michael_dorfman 18y ago
I hear what you're saying, and I understand the desire to tackle complex and tough things-- but some things are best left to professionals, believe me. I can think of a few times where a lack of proper legal advice cost me more than a million dollars. Once burned, twice shy.
- davidw 18y ago
  Look at it as a way to learn about what you're about to buy. Informed buyers are likely to get a better product for less money.

jgamman 18y ago

why? do you think there's something wrong with me?

mrtron 18y ago

The topic of mental health comes up regularly. I consider that to be a large portion of your overall health. People commonly discuss everything from depression to motivational issues.