13 ms·
Why I'm donating $150/month (10% of my income) to the musl Libc project (2019)
- gremloni 5y agoWhere are you? You’re a poor man.
- ChrisArchitect 5y agoPrevious discussion from two years ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20268087 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20268087
- kristoff_it 5y agoI guess no better post than this to remind everyone that the Zig Software Foundation is half-way through the current donation goal, which would allow us to hire two more full-time developers. https://github.com/sponsors/ziglang https://github.com/sponsors/ziglang On a separate note, I'm learning a lot about how different software foundations operate and I'm very surprised to see that very few prioritize the goal of paying their core developers. I encourage everyone to check out the mission of the Zig Software Foundation and to compare it with how we're spending the money we're getting. Everything is available here: https://ziglang.org/zsf/ https://ziglang.org/zsf/
- tekknolagi 5y agoHow do you find your full-time developers and assign them projects?
- kristoff_it 5y agoContributors that can bill hours to the foundation are people that have been involved for a while and who have a history of quality contributions. The foundation doesn't assign projects, people tend to have an affinity for a specific topic usually, but they are free to use their billable time to contribute to any part of the codebase.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- barbegal 5y agoI've had a look and it's hard to see how the foundation's money is being spent. The accounts suggest most of the income is from donations from Andrew Kelley and most of the outgoings is Andrew's salary.
- GoodJokes 5y agothis person makes $1500 a month?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- minitech 5y agoThe literal first sentence of the article will explain this one for you!
- Kranar 5y agoThe literal first sentence is as follows: >One year ago, I quit my day job to work on Zig full time. So is it the case he only makes $1500 a month? I mean it's none of my business what he makes but he did bring it up and I am curious to know how much a prominent individual like him earns for working on his own open source passion project. I find it commendable that someone would work on their own project for such a low salary owing to a belief and desire to get their product out there. That said if he makes $15000 a month that's cool too and great for him, but it's not clear to me what the truth here is.
- robrenaud 5y agoAbove he wrote that he is now up to $4k/month.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- hutrdvnj 5y agoHe lives from donations to Zig, so that he can work full time in it.
- Rebelgecko 5y agoThe Zig foundation is super transparent about where their money goes, modulo a few months of delay. Technically he's drawing a salary of something like 12k/month but he donates most of it back to the foundation (initially 100% of it was being donated back, but he's scaled back gradually so it's more like 80% last I checked). I don't know if he has any other income but it seems like Zig is really a labor of love.
- sass12388 5y agowell then
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- adamgordonbell 5y agoYes, which is great! He's drawn attention to an important project and given it funding. > Now if I'm being honest about my motivations for this blog post, it's that I want to prove that open source funding is not a zero-sum game.
- hackcasual 5y agomusl is also key for the Emscripten project.
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 5y agoSomehow I loved this article and the response, even though it was admittedly a funding stunt. There was something very endearing about how straitforward and innocent the stunt was. Two very deserving projects got funding (musl and Zig). I have used musl, mainly through Alpine Linux. I have not used Zig, but it seems it is a very interesting answer to the question of what does a systems programming language that is not C or C++ look like. We have one recent answer in the form of Rust, and Zig is another answer with another set of priorities and tradeoffs. It is a very exciting time in terms of real-world language development. All the best to the open source contributors of all these languages and libraries!
- nomdep 5y agoMy ignorance is showing but, why Zig deserve to be funded?
- rStar 5y agothat’s my thought. i get people having pet projects, but i’m over the hard sales pitch for why i should care
- meheleventyone 5y agoI think you both are thinking deserved means something stronger and more like entitled than it does. In this context I just means the OP think the project mentioned merit their funding.
- coldtea 5y agoIf you're a founder or a developer you're more likely than not taking advantage (either your bussiness or the business you work for, or you for your personal projects) of tons of such "pet projects" from Python and Node, to Postgres and Zig. So, there's that...
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- 5y ago
- AndyKelley 5y ago2021 update: * The Zig Software Foundation now exists * My total income including ZSF Salary, GitHub Sponsors, Patreon is now about 4000 USD per month. Legally, my ZSF salary is 160K per year, but I have been consistently donating it back to the org since frankly we just don't have that much revenue at this point in time, and I've been prioritizing getting that money to other Zig contributors. * The $150/month to Rich Felker now comes from ZSF instead of my personal account. * Zig 0.5.0, 0.6.0, 0.7.0, 0.8.0 have all been released. 0.9.0 is coming soon. * I no longer really have an opinion about V; it's been two years since I paid any attention to it.
- 3pt14159 5y agoSorry, I'm not American so this may be a dumb question, but why set your salary to $160k instead of what it actually is? Does it have to do with US tax law or non-profit org law?
- infogulch 5y agoOne difference: you have control over when you give yourself a pay raise instead of having to go through the org chart/board. May not be the most efficient strategy with taxes though.
- pixelmonkey 5y agoThis is just me taking a guess, but one benefit to him setting a real salary and donating the money back is that for the purpose of credit checks and consumer loans (e.g. a home mortgage for a primary residence), he can qualify for appropriate amounts. It also appropriately models what's happening: he's paying himself a "market salary" (in quotes because his market value is probably much higher than that, but I'm speaking relatively to a "stipend salary" here) and he is working full-time on the project, but donating back the portion he doesn't need to spend on disposable income (due to his own personal frugality). Actually quite an admirable way to do it -- hopefully he has figured out some way to not suffer extra taxes from that setup.
- TAForObvReasons 5y ago
- yboris 5y agoConsider joining Giving What We Can - an international community of people who have pledged to give at least 10% of their income to causes that they think are most effective at eliminating what they think are the world's biggest problems. (I'm a proud member for 10 years). https://www.givingwhatwecan.org/ https://www.givingwhatwecan.org/
- funOtter 5y agoI'm interested: why join this when you can simply donate 10% to charities without joining this?
- Kranar 5y agoSense of community. I used to have the belief that being an anonymous donor, giving money to charities quietly, was the right and noble thing to do. Then there was the Ice Bucket Challenge and I realized that an individual donation is nothing compared to the multiplying effect that comes from having others within your community and network join in, and that requires finding creative ways of signaling your donations to others. Some find it distasteful to signal this, but the problem is that the end result of signaling donations is so much more effective that it's worth it. Joining a community of people who also pledge to participate in charity and promote charities to one another could be a way to eliminate the distasteful part of signaling to others that you donate to charities. It can also work as a way to integrate charities and donations as a routine part of your expenses and budgeting.
- 0des 5y agogiving as a group activity feels weird as if without an audience these folks might just not be interested.
- nearbuy 5y agoIf true, then that's exactly what makes it good. We can save lives for the small cost of giving donors some recognition and a sense of community. Edit: To add the above, the median annual donation amount for someone earning $60k-$80k in 2010 was $107. Roughly 0.15% of their income. It feels weird to criticize people donating 10% for having not-pure-enough motives while letting the majority who donate almost nothing escape criticism.
- benatkin 5y agoDeno currently requires glibc. Anyone have insight into it? Would getting musl more funding help make it so it can run on stock alpine?
- int_19h 5y agoDeno is built on V8, and V8 requires glibc. So it's down to Google supporting musl, and I don't think it's a money issue.
- hayd 5y ago> V8 requires glibc I don't _think_ this is true. https://github.com/denoland/deno/issues/3711#issuecomment-626108190 https://github.com/denoland/deno/issues/3711#issuecomment-62...
- benatkin 5y agoThe aunt of your comment applies here. If anyone has gotten Deno to work without glibc, it means V8 can be made to work without glibc. That doesn't mean it's properly supported.
- int_19h 5y agoPeople have been building V8 on musl for a while now, but it's not supported by upstream. Last time I've looked into it a couple years ago, such builds were also not particularly stable.
- benatkin 5y agoI see. I love Deno and using a Debian or Ubuntu image is a small compromise.
- hayd 5y agoA year and half ago kesor was able to get deno to build without glibc (so it would work on stock alpine). It seems to be gn args/configs that need fiddling. Unfortunately this work has never been brought into main (a couple of attempts have been made subsequently). https://github.com/denoland/deno/issues/3711#issuecomment-626108190 https://github.com/denoland/deno/issues/3711#issuecomment-62...
- 41209 5y agoAny good documentation on the language itself ? This looks like an easier Rust to me.
- pcein 5y agoAnother good resource: https://zig.news/ https://zig.news/
- lkey 5y agohttps://ziglang.org/documentation/master/ https://ziglang.org/documentation/master/ Is a place to get a feel for things. There's also a generated doc set that is similar to rust's, but I just recommend looking at the source if you are curious about something, it's concise and readable. If you have more questions you can pop into irc or the discord, they'll have better resources at the ready. https://github.com/ziglang/zig/wiki/Community https://github.com/ziglang/zig/wiki/Community
- dralley 5y agoIt's probably closer to "a more modern, better C" than "an easier Rust". The core features of Rust are the borrow checker, traits, and algebraic data types, and Zig is missing all of those. On the other hand, Zig has a lot of things that C doesn't have, and a few that Rust doesn't have as well - and some people gravitate towards the C-like simplicity of the language.
- pcwalton 5y agoI'd say Zig is a more strictly low-level language than Rust, with less safety (it's not memory-safe) and a less sophisticated type system, but with more emphasis on being low-level (malloc is fallible) and with more metaprogramming capabilities.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Zababa 5y agoIt's not an "easier Rust", as you can't really claim to be Rust without the borrow checker, and you can't really claim to be Zig without the comptime and explicit allocation. They are different language, that took different decisions on how to do things, for different reasons.
- rStar 5y agoas a gnu libc person, i wholeheartedly hope for your failure
- wyldfire 5y agoI'll donate $1000 worth of cryptocoin today (Monero, Nano, Bitcoin etc) if Zig Foundation (or Andy directly) publishes an address.
- exochrono 5y agoShameless self plug - if Zig or Andy doesn't comment here, you can still donate crypto to Zig via their profile on every.org - https://www.every.org/zig-software-foundation-inc https://www.every.org/zig-software-foundation-inc edit: we charge no fees since our ops are supported by our donors - the only fee that gets taken out is that charged by our brokerage for selling the crypto
- wyldfire 5y agoThis looks great but did ZSF opt-in or are you including them here in the hopes they'd take donations from you? Likely the latter? > https://support.every.org/hc/en-us/articles/360059840294-Why-is-my-nonprofit-listed-on-Every-org- https://support.every.org/hc/en-us/articles/360059840294-Why... Also, skimming the terms: > If circumstances make Giver to that particular Nonprofit impossible or inappropriate (such as if the selected Nonprofit ceases operations or loses its tax-exempt status), we will attempt to contact you first for additional preferences on where you would like your Donation to go. If we do not receive your preferences before we must disburse the funds, then we may in our sole discretion select an alternate Nonprofit to receive the Donation. We will do our best to direct your Donation to a Nonprofit in a similar space and/or with similar goals. Except in cases of fraud, we do not issue refunds. If I can get Andy or ZSF representative to say they'll claim it from every.org I'd consider that. I can't find any obvious disclosure about margin/overhead from Every.org but I might still consider it despite that.
- exochrono 5y agoGreat question - we have more info on how we disburse at https://www.every.org/disbursements https://www.every.org/disbursements - but in short, ZSF hasn't claimed their profile and connected a bank account, so we'd disburse via our partner NFG. We treat crypto donations like those made via bank account, meaning we cover the 2.25% fee that NFG charges, so (100% of your crypto donation - broker fee (<=1%)) goes to ZSF.
- jbschirtzs 5y agoBasically, this is just re-discovering the tithe--although libc is probably not a religion.
- wyldfire 5y agoFrom [1]: > However, Zig Software Foundation will never have big tech companies on the board of directors. We are grateful to Pex, for example, for donating $5,000/month, even though they have no board seats. Our goal is to maintain independence by keeping the mix of donations balanced among many parties. Seems relevant given the recent hub-bub over Rust leadership/governance. Another interesting model is LF and Linus Torvalds. (NS)BDFL who has the best interest of the project in mind, but doesn't seem improperly influenced by LF supporter companies. [1] https://ziglang.org/news/jakub-konka-hired-full-time/ https://ziglang.org/news/jakub-konka-hired-full-time/
- loeg 5y agoYeah, it's a choice. The Linux Foundation and Rust Foundation are 501(c)(6)s (i.e., business association) non-profit; the FreeBSD Foundation is a 501(c)(3) (charitable) non-profit. Sounds like ZSF is also a 501(c)(3). There are pros and cons to both approaches. I think a large enough ecosystem (e.g., Linux) might benefit from having both types of non-profit organization around.
- pmdulaney 5y agoThe Computer Science god does not actually require this kind of works righteousness for salvation.
- mro_name 5y ago10% is IMO too much, take care that you first sustain yourself. So as you can continue.