3 ms·
> But corporate interests have succeeded in selling the narrative that pensions are unreliable and inequitable, while 401(k)'s are more reliable and equitable.
by lotsofpulp 5y ago
> But corporate interests have succeeded in selling the narrative that pensions are unreliable and inequitable, while 401(k)'s are more reliable and equitable. In fact pensions are categorically more equitable, and any less reliability (which is a dubious claim, notwithstanding the many high profile pension failures over the years--nobody reports on someone's 401(k) fund vanishing during a recession) is a consequence of lobbyists phenomenal success in killing legislation and enforcement efforts responsive to corporate financial accounting schemes.
Those lobbyists must be doing a terrible job, since the Pension Protection Act of 2006 strengthened the reliability of defined benefit pensions.
The problem is defined benefit pensions are extremely risky for beneficiaries since the existence of an employer decades into the future is a huge risk, as are changes in a world where things change quickly and many people do not stay at the same job for many years.
And they are risky for employers in that expecting every employer to also function as an insurance company selling annuities and survive as long is expensive and ridiculous to execute. That is how you end up with so much corruption and money wasted because so many people have no idea what is going on (and the root cause for taxpayer funded DB pensions being a quagmire since voters have no idea what is going on).
There is zero reason an employer cannot just give the normal cost (the present value of the benefit accrued during the year) to an employee, and the employee put it in VOO rather than the employer doing the same and then having to pay actuaries and fund managers. I am happy I do not need to pay finance people who have been obviated by automation.
- wahern 5y ago> Those lobbyists must be doing a terrible job, since the Pension Protection Act of 2006 strengthened the reliability of defined benefit pensions. Pensions were already dead long before 2006, and inevitable future pension failures baked into the system years and decades earlier. And in any event the PPA heavily favored 401(k)'s, the price extracted by Republicans for creating the Pension Benefit Guaranty Corporation. And the PBGC itself also favored corporations. Nothing about the PPA directly addressed the underlying reasons pensions were failing; the PPA was about creating a soft landing. > The problem is defined benefit pensions are extremely risky for beneficiaries since the existence of an employer decades into the future is a huge risk, as are changes in a world where things change quickly and many people do not stay at the same job for many years. They're not risky at all. A pension is just an annuity, the corporate equivalent of employer-provided health insurance vs open market health insurance. Annuities, like life insurance, are considered some of the most reliable investments possible, precisely because of relatively strict, century-old reform legislation. See my response elsethread regarding fully funding requirements and the difference between employer vs independent management. Again, this notion that pensions are fundamentally risky is a false narrative. To the extent pensions are risky, it's only because the laws don't adequately address what in other insurance markets would be considered systemic accounting fraud.
- sokoloff 5y agoThere are multiple types of risks in financial instruments. Risk of loss of principal is only one of them. Risk of underperforming inflation is better addressed by equities than annuities. If there was one single "best" investment for everyone, everyone who was well-informed would just buy that. For me (and I think many others), an annuity that ends at death is not my primary goal when considering how to arrange my investments.
- wahern 5y agoThe larger debate is fundamentally about how policy should channel people to maximize the public good in which equitable outcomes are a crucial component. To my mind, Social Security, pensions, 401(k)s, and the like can all play a part. My larger point about pensions specifically is that there's nothing inherently less risky in pensions from a purely accounting perspective. Actuarial tables were astonishingly precise 100 years ago, and our ability to diversify and insure risk through private markets has only grown while at the same time U.S. monetary stability has achieved undreamed of heights, even considering asset inflation. The basic dilemmas and moral hazards, meanwhile, have largely stayed the same, albeit sometimes obscured by increasing technical complexity. The biggest part of the puzzle concerns public policy. For some reason we keep returning to tired debates about socialist vs private markets or personal freedom vs authoritarianism, like we're still picking sides in an insurgent communist revolution at the turn of the previous century. (The current debates are astonishingly similar to the ones we've had prior, such as over hourly limits, employment disability insurance, and especially Social Security.) It's ridiculous. We have a decent grasp on which basic tools work better in which contexts and why, partly because the science of economics has improved, and partly because the past century saw a large number of social experiments play out at large scales both domestically and especially globally. The immediate question isn't which singular option to chose, it's about how to mix-and-match instruments and incentives. Interactions and second-order effects are still fuzzy, and political cultures do matter, but there are so many tremendous improvements we could make before we hit that next wall.
- sokoloff 5y ago