4 ms·
While it's not an inherent property of defined benefit pensions, they also tended to be structured in a way that tended to primarily benefit long tenure in an o
by ghaff 5y ago
While it's not an inherent property of defined benefit pensions, they also tended to be structured in a way that tended to primarily benefit long tenure in an organization--US military being one of the most obvious traditional examples.
Switch jobs every few years? You probably weren't going to collect much in the way of a pension.
I'm not sure how much the switch has been about "corporate interests." As people became more mobile (for good reasons and bad), the idea of your retirement savings being tied up with a specific (usually large) company became less attractive to employees as well.
- wahern 5y agoThe answer to that shift in employee tenure is simple: shift away from employer managed pensions to independent management, same as for health insurance. That shift was incomplete because corporate focus shifted to draining pensions and centering compensation packages around mechanisms that favored management and especially executives (401(k)'s, stock options, etc), not adapting pensions to employment trends.
- ghaff 5y agoBut, now, if you have a widespread defined benefit pension that's largely independent of employment, don't you now have effectively a shadow version of Social Security?
- wahern 5y agoYes, except it has less systemic moral hazard since the insurer can't [directly] print money and/or issue endless amounts of debt.[1] I'm not a Social Security cynic; I believe it serves a crucial but limited role in providing economic security. [1] Not per se a horrible thing, but that ability is better preserved for infrastructure and other discretionary investments rather than retirement.