6 ms·
Many of the Apple's customers (including me) see that as a feature and not a problem. I like that I can subscribe to something without having to share my person
by criddell 5y ago
Many of the Apple's customers (including me) see that as a feature and not a problem. I like that I can subscribe to something without having to share my personal information with another company.
I understand that I end up paying more than I would otherwise, but Apple doesn't really compete on price.
Perhaps if I was in the EU I would feel differently because they have better data protections.
- travoc 5y agoI wonder if you would feel differently if the 30% premium you were paying to Apple on every digital purchase were transparently shown on the transaction.
- bradknowles 5y agoBut 30% doesn’t exist anymore, except for the top 1%of earners on the platform. Most sellers on the App Store are now paying 15%, if anything at all. Most apps I’ve seen are using ads to bypass paying anything to Apple. Some of them support IAP to remove ads. But that’s just an option.
- criddell 5y agoI'd be okay with that. I'd also be okay if regulators forced Apple to allow apps to use outside payment services where the price could be 30% less. I just hope that Apple would be allowed to say that if you are going to use outside payment providers, you must allow paying through Apple and the outside price can be no lower than 30% (or whatever Apple's cut is). I don't spend a lot through Apple each year. Maybe $200. If I'm paying 30% more than I would otherwise that means it's costing me something like sixteen cents per day and I'm okay with that. When I was younger, I used to focus a lot more on price. When Zappos came around it clicked for me that paying more can be smart if the service you get is better. I'll pay $0.16 every day if it means a few times per year I avoid a lot of bullshit.
- coz131 5y agoI don't get what do you mean by "you must allow paying through Apple and the price can no lower than 30% or whatever the cut".
- Nasrudith 5y agoEssentially they must allow the user the option of Apple as a payment mechanism to ensure their feature is unbroken. The no lower part is that they can only discount up to whatever Apple's cut would be if they use their own payment mechanism. Related to the first point to prevent "soft disables" like setting Apple pay price at something dramatically worse that few would pay. Charging $13 through Apple and $10 through theirs ensures they get their $10 no matter the customer choice. Or they could call the volume worth the cut and charge $10 for both methods. Setting it worse opens up effectively a "soft disable" like Apple price at $1000 and their price at $1. If they for some reason decided to charge $1 through Apple and $1000 through their own that poor decision is no skin off Apple's nose.
- smoldesu 5y agoThat money isn't being taken from you though, it's being taken from the developer who made that app or service. No matter how you frame it, the developer sets their price and Apple scalps them accordingly. So just because you don't care doesn't mean that the people who are trying to make a living off it shouldn't.
- Jensson 5y agoIt is ~43% premium. 100 / 70 ~= 1.429
- duped 5y agoI agree with you, recently I chose not to purchase things from Etsy because the shops only supported PayPal and wouldn't let me checkout without an account. But that said, those shops should have a right to choose which payment processors are appropriate for their business. Let the market decide what is the best for the market.
- echelon 5y ago> Many of the Apple's customers (including me) see that as a feature and not a problem. This is almost Orwellian. Imagine Standard Oil customers cheering the demise of the corner mom and pop. All of this while Apple collects a dossier on each of you that they'll willingly hand over to the FBI, FSB, or Chinese Ministry of State Surveillance. If none of that convinces you, then do me a favor. A thought experiment. Imagine an alternate history wherein we replace Apple with Microsoft. Imagine that the iPhone lost and became just a footnote or history and that Steve Ballmer's Microsoft ZunePhone Pro 10 won the market. That's what we all have in our pockets now. Would you be happy if Microsoft owned the customer relationship? Would you feel just as happy? Apple is immaterial in this. We don't need companies to be this powerful.
- endisneigh 5y agoIs anyone being forced to use The ZunePhone Pro 10 or the iPhone? Android dominates worldwide with a staggering 70%+ depending on who you ask. I do agree that companies shouldn't be so powerful tho
- hectormalot 5y agoI think that’s okay, I’m in the same position that I trust Apple more in handling this than the apps themselves. Eg I’ve read some interesting stories on how hard it is to cancel a NYTimes subscription. What is - on my opinion - problematic is that apple prohibits alternative payment options. Eg I’d be happy to see (8€ per month with apple [pay now], 7€ per month direct [register on our website], but even that’s prohibited. That is Apple using its position as one of the 2 major phone offerings to prevent competition in a way that I consider monopolistic.
- Andrew_nenakhov 5y agoSo you also trust Apple better than yourself, because if you will ever find yourself needing an app that Apple blocks, well, you'll have to accept that it is in your 'best interests'.
- criddell 5y agoGenerally, it's true. If Apple blocked nothing, how many flashlight apps that also mine bitcoin would be installed?
- emn13 5y agoSo first of all - just because the end-user wants Apple to check for actively malicious programs doesn't mean they assent to all forms of control. Secondly, even on the matter of software deemed malicious by Apple, I think it's questionable how reasonable it is for Apple to entirely remove the end-user from the decision making process. Even on really weakly policed platforms like windows, people still tend to leave virus scanners enabled; and on android similarly most people don't choose to expose themselves to unnecessary risk by sidestepping its store - at least as far as I know. Users regularly do really stupid things, so some level of external control is perhaps not unreasonable, but how much, and for what? And should Apple even get to be involved in that decision?
- Andrew_nenakhov 5y agoDo not forget that in some countries Apple also blocks apps that the current regime deems dangerous for it. Like, apps of the opposition news outlets, etc. Apple is quite content with taking your freedom away: if you needed it, you wouldn't have relinquished controls of YOUR phone for other people to decide what to run on it.
- vanviegen 5y agoThat might make sense for dealing with a company I've never heard of before, from which I'm just installing an app from the App Store. But the way I see it, it doesn't make sense when dealing with companies I have a preexisting relationship with, like my phone provider, energy provider, kids' school, work serices, all kinds of online entertainment providers, etc, etc. I may want to be able to interact with them through my phone, and there shouldn't be any third party controlling and profiting from that interaction.
- Spivak 5y agoAnd they don't. Apple charges 30% on digital goods. None of the things you listed count except entertainment providers in the case where you sign up on the iPhone in which case you didn't have a pre-existing relationship. "Are you using your iPhone app as a digital storefront for digital goods or services to be consumed on your phone? => Apple gets a 30% commission"
- vanviegen 5y agoIn the case of Apple Pay, they are monetizing my preexisting relationship with my bank. But the fact that they get to control all of those relationships in very significant ways is what's really bothering me.
- jsnell 5y agoThat's great! Given so many of Apple's customers prefer that, I'm sure the app makers will continue to accommodate you, and offer the two options at different prices. Since Apple being a middleman is so valuable to y'all, I'm sure you'll be happy to pay the 30% extra for that service.
- r00fus 5y agoThey're free to do so for Android devices.
- Spivak 5y agoI see this argument a lot and it makes zero sense. If your customers are currently paying you $15 for your app why would you suddenly undercut yourself and start charging $10 when you could keep charging $15 and pocket the extra $5? Maaaaybe competition would force you to drop prices but a lot of consumer software isn't fungible and doesn't really compete on price. Taking away Apple's 30% cut shouldn't be talked about as a pro-consumer move because it isn't. There's this pot of money that is either going to go to the app publisher or Apple. That's who the fight is really between.
- jsnell 5y agoWell, criddell's claim is that there are a lot of people who really prefer to use Apple's payment system rather than a third-party one, such that apps that don't support Apple Pay will lose their business. If those people really exist in large quantities (and I can believe they do!), the developer is losing business by not providing Apply Pay as an option. But that'd just lead every single customer to use Apple Pay, which is not what the developer wants. So you need to somehow give the people an incentive to choose your version, unless they really think that going through Apple is giving them a lot of value. Differential pricing seems like the most obvious way of doing that. > Maaaaybe competition would force you to drop prices but a lot of consumer software isn't fungible and doesn't really compete on price. That seems implausible. If you think that software prices don't matter at all, such that lowering prices does not increases sale, it'd follow that raising prices doesn't lower sales either. In that case, why hasn't the developer already raised prices?
- chrisfinazzo 5y agoSeeing all of the ancillary legal fallout from the Epic Games trial is convincing me that the EU learned the wrong lesson from the US' dealings with Microsoft in the 90's. The OEM model (at least for computing platforms) is how the world works. Fragmenting it helps no one, save for perhaps the software freedom crowd. They continue to fight the old war and at some point, it just might come back to bite them.
- chrisfinazzo 5y agoAlas, downvotes. To those who disagree with me, what's the alternative? It just seems like the EU is fundamentally opposed to this model which would mean any company is no longer in charge of their own destiny. "There's no advantage to being a platform owner? Eh, OK, let's just not bother trying then." It's a bad look.
- smoldesu 5y agoApple can still provide all of the OEM features if they really want, the obvious solution here is to give people the option to install third-party things (eg. Please enter your PIN number to confirm a third-party installation) and then boom! You're finished. It's quite obvious that the only reason Apple hasn't added that feature is because they have no intention on losing their stranglehold on the App Store. Without sole propriety of software, Apple's value proposition starts to crumble. So, why should we let them keep it? What do we, as a society, gain from letting Apple be the richest company in the world? The answer is nothing, and eventually some day when they go under we'll come to the realization that it was all a zero-sum game anyways.
- p_j_w 5y ago>I understand that I end up paying more than I would otherwise, but Apple doesn't really compete on price. Don't they have rules that companies aren't allowed to charge a higher price for services on Apple devices than elsewhere? Seems to me they DO try to compete on price here. They want to have their cake and eat it too, and they absolutely should not be allowed to.
- criddell 5y agoThey did have that rule at the start but it was changed some time ago. If you subscribe to Spotify in iOS, it costs more than doing so over the web. I think this is ultimately going to be a huge problem for Apple because they directly compete with Spotfiy.