3 ms·
One of the core strands of postwar feminism has been examining how much uncompensated domestic labour women are expected to perform, not just for their partner
by pjc50 5y ago
One of the core strands of postwar feminism has been examining how much uncompensated domestic labour women are expected to perform, not just for their partner and their children but also for other family members. Especially in the context of care for the old or sick.
The term "emotional labour" is the more common used one for what you've described as "emotional services".
- zakary 5y agoEmotional Labour is definitely the better term for it. Thank you for giving me the right term to google. I wonder how much of the ‘economy’ (in terms of work done and the dollar figures we put on that) is actually a part of this undocumented category. The GDP-PPP of countries doesn’t take this sort of thing into account as far as I’m aware, but I’d like to know what would happen to those numbers if everyone simply stopped doing unpaid emotional labour. You could get a sense pretty quickly of how much society is undervaluing it.
- jkhdigital 5y agoThe reason that the economy is defined in terms of transactions that involve an exchange of money is that such transactions can be quantified objectively. If no money is exchanged, then assigning a valuation to an activity is pure speculation. Of course, this doesn't stop bureaucratic number-crunchers from attempting to do so anyway (e.g. the inclusion of "owner-occupied implied rent" in CPI calculations) but it's not hard to see the slippery slope it creates. Assigning a name to something ("emotional labour") doesn't mean that it somehow becomes quantifiable in any tractable or objective manner.
- zakary 5y agoAbsolutely agree. Still, it would be cool to see real data about this stuff if it could be objectively collected
- geogra4 5y agoInterestingly enough I believe this is partially why there was a "wages for housework" movement[0] 0:https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wages_for_housework https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wages_for_housework
- bojangleslover 5y agoWhat about the fact that she owns half of all marital assets as they accrue?
- pjc50 5y agoWasn't always true in all jurisdictions, and certainly not in 1972 when the campaign started. Even today there's a distinction between "is theoretically entitled to half the assets by court order on divorce" and practical day to day access to that money.
- WJW 5y agoIt comes up commonly in discussions about how poor GDP is as a measure of societal wealth. For example, if we would strike a bargain to do each others' laundry for a trillion USD per year each, the GDP would "magically" go up by two trillion compared to if we would just do our own laundry. However, no additional value is created compared to the current situation.
- rmah 5y agoGDP is not a measure of economic wealth (much less "social wealth", whatever that is) and never has been. GDP is a measure of economic activity. I.e. transactions, spending. But since one year to the next, the structure of a nation's economy doesn't change dramatically, it can be used as a proxy for changes in wealth. However, the longer time period you look look at between two GDP figures, the less comparable they are. And finally, since different nations have different economic structures, a direct currency translation may be misleading, hence PPP (which is misleading in a different way, but <shrug>).
- SilasX 5y agoEmotional Labor is a horrible term for it, since it has little to do with emotions. “Household” or “domestic” labor would be better. Emotional Labor would be a better term for eg the stresses of maintaining relationships.
- heurisko 5y ago> everyone simply stopped doing unpaid emotional labour. Arguably this is the situation in Europe, compared to America, as there isn't a comparable tipping culture. In Germany, there is a word to describe how this has tipped over into a "Service desert" - "Servicewüste", a complete lack of acceptable customer service. However I think a non-tipping culture is preferable.
- mkr-hn 5y agoWhile this is how the term is misused in some segments of pop feminism, it actually refers to the (usually uncompensated) emotional labor expected of employees in service industries. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Emotional_labor https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Emotional_labor It doesn't really make sense in this context unless you only think of the emotional management homemakers do as labor and not all the other stuff they do. You already provided a perfectly suitable phrase in your post: "uncompensated domestic labour"
- rrrrrrrrrrrryan 5y agoEh, I've mostly heard it used correctly in feminist articles. E.g. "The rise of the gig economy is forcing a lot of men to perform emotional labor for the first time." The most interesting part of emotional labor to me is its connection to tipping culture in America. It's the reason why you usually tip a waiter but not a bus boy, and why you tip the room service person but not the delivery guy. The rule of thumb is: if someone's doing a job where they're expected to put on a smile even if their dog died that morning, they're eligible to get compensated via tips for that additional emotional labor.
- simonh 5y agoI think domestic work does fit into the framework of the article as "Transforming Things". Turning dirty clothes, carpets, dishes, etc into clean things that can be used again; transforming raw ingredients into nice food; shopping is moving things. These are productive activities that increase wealth.