6 ms·
I like internet based delivery. Can we get a union based alternative so I don't feel bad about the person turning up to my door being an outsourced slave?
by ZeroGravitas 5y ago
I like internet based delivery. Can we get a union based alternative so I don't feel bad about the person turning up to my door being an outsourced slave?
- ReptileMan 5y agoShort answer is no. Long answer is majority of people discriminate a lot on price, so the only way is make governments mandates about quality of the service and how the people are treated - which comes with all the externalities and side effects of regulation.
- notyourwork 5y ago+1 cheap services are cheap because labor is cheap in some way. Without cheap labor the cost has to be put on someone.
- ReptileMan 5y agoI am not so much worried about price in the case, but about barriers of entry - incumbents love regulation because it converts them into monopoly/oligopoly since they are able to extract economies of scale when complying (and of course lobby about favorable to them regulations). Regulation of Uber class services means we will be stuck with Uber forever. Whether this is good or bad thing is left to the reader to decide.
- throwanem 5y agoWith cheap labor, the cost also has to be put on someone, and labor is that someone.
- jakehop 5y agoIn Denmark, our deliveries are currently not unionized, although there is a large debate around it. Denmark has no minimum wage either. The people doing the deliveries for e.g. Wolt earn at minimum of 120 DKK an hour (~18,5 USD) on a scheduled shift and can often earn more, depending on how much they are willing to work. The last average I read is around 150DKK an hour (~23,30 USD) for delivery personel in that company. The main issue with unionizing in Denmark is that it would require the companies to sign the delivery people to fixed-hour contracts (think nine-to-five), which doesn't work with the business model and isn't what most of the delivery people have expressed their wants about. Most of them enjoy the freedom and many in creative industries (e.g. musicians) use it as a way to supplement their income. I think it is important to recognize what unionization actually means and whether or not that solves the problem, and before that; figure out what the actual problem really is.
- Galaxeblaffer 5y agoAlso foreigners who wants to study and get SU (State Study Support around 900 EUR/month, and yes, you basically get payed to study) use this to get what's called "equal status" which qualifies them for the SU and probably other benefits as well.
- jakehop 5y agoThank you, great point. (Also, I am thankful that you are descripting the SU correctly; one gets paid to be enrolled at a qualifying educational institution - paid to study, not paid to get an education, even though this is luckily what happens most of the time.)
- crooked-v 5y ago> The main issue with unionizing in Denmark is that it would require the companies to sign the delivery people to fixed-hour contracts That seems like a conflation of two entirely different things. Plenty of unions represent people who work intermittently or weird hours, like basically every union related to film production.
- jakehop 5y agoPossibly, but this is the situation we're faced with here in Denmark, as our cartel of unions have divided the market in such a way. I agree that this is not necessarily what "unionization" means specificly, but this is the concrete case here, and thus my caveat as to the importance of the exact definition.
- imgabe 5y agoSure, deliveries will cost $80 per hour with a 4 hour minimum. You can get deliveries between 9am-12pm and 1pm-5pm (mandatory lunch break).
- bo0tzz 5y ago> deliveries will cost $80 per hour with a 4 hour minimum You don't pay per hour to get things delivered? Sure, if delivery workers unionized end customer costs would likely be a bit higher, but is that such a bad thing if it means the people working are not worked to the bone anymore?
- qsort 5y agoIt wouldn't be "a bit" higher, it would be out of the market. A completely analogous situation is how if we manufactured computers using something other than (effectively) slave labor, a macbook would cost $15,000. These problems will go away in the same way similar problems have gone away in the past: with technology advancing to a point where no humans are required to be in the loop any longer.
- MrGilbert 5y ago> a macbook would cost $15,000. Devil's advocate: What's bad about that? Guess we would appreciate the value of the device way more if it would be that expensive. Also, by reducing the margin available to the company, it certainly wouldn't land at 15k. And yes, that would also mean that "shareholders" won't be able to make millions.
- qsort 5y agoThe downside would be that much fewer people would be able to afford it in the first place. Cheap personal computers are a very powerful force for good, this is a very unpalatable but reasonable compromise. Taking the other side of the compromise is of course also reasonable, but pretending it's somehow a free lunch is not realistic.
- 5y ago
- HeyLaughingBoy 5y agoI think that's a bit extreme! But if their pay bothers you, tip them more.