7 ms·
Sales of obscure game consoles vs. non-iPad tablets
- vectorpush 15y agoI didn’t include the iPad’s approximately 30 million units on here because it distorted the graph’s scale too much. Too bad, seems to me like this graph is meaningless otherwise. The comparison is completely arbitrary.
- xilun0 15y agouse your fingers, report 10 millions, times 3.
- vectorpush 15y agoMy point was that the sale of tablets vs "obscure" gaming consoles is a meaningless comparison.
- masklinn 15y agoThe point of the comparison seems pretty clearly made: "Here's a bunch of console you probably never heard about. They flopped. They completely failed. Well these non-ipad tablets have done even worse so far. Enjoy the taste of unadulterated failure."
- vectorpush 15y agoI think the point of the comparison is basically: here's a bunch of console you probably never heard about. They flopped. That's exactly my point. "Here's a bunch of [insert failed consumer electronic] you've never heard of without regard for disparate product life cycles or market environments". The data points are interchangeable so long as they follow the guideline of "consumer electronic that existed at some point in time and didn't sell well"
- masklinn 15y ago> That's exactly my point. No, you said adding the iPad sales to the graph would make it meaningful. What meaning would it mean to the graph? It might change the meaning of the graph to "the iPad sells well, other tablets don't" but then the consoles included are meaningless. The point of the graph is "these tablets don't sell for shit, here, compare to sales of stuff which didn't sell for shit either".
- vectorpush 15y agoI was being sarcastic when I said that adding iPad sales to the graph would make it meaningful since a comparison of 2 to 30 doesn't require a graph for digestion. The point of the graph is "these tablets don't sell for shit, here, compare to sales of stuff which didn't sell for shit either" Yes, a point that remains lost on me considering you could stack this year's tablets up against a myriad of 20 year old devices and make an equally meaningless comparison.
- tptacek 15y agoThey aren't random consumer electronic devices; they're consoles, the market for which has similarities to the "tablet" market in that they're ancillary devices for consumers with winner-take-most developer ecosystems.
- vectorpush 15y agoI don't see the meaning in a graph comparing tablets from 8 months ago to game consoles from 20 years ago.
- tptacek 15y agoThen you don't see the value in comparing comparable markets from the history of computing to a modern market; you don't think history in any way resembles itself. Which is fine, but I think that perspective is a bit of an outlier.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- jannes 15y agoThis graph is meaningless. A lot of the game consoles probably had a lifespan of at least one year (probably more). The Android tablets and the Playbook are at most half a year old. Knowing this it does not seem fair to me to compare their total sales figures.
- mrmaddog 15y agoThe Nintendo Virtual Boy "was released on July 21, 1995 [... and Nintendo] discontinued it the following year" ... so no - it really was a flop that sold more units than the playbook (to date). http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Virtual_Boy http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Virtual_Boy
- acangiano 15y agoIf the iPad was on the chart: http://awesomescreenshot.com/0b2ii1916 http://awesomescreenshot.com/0b2ii1916
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- watmough 15y agoCan you add the Sony PS2 on there too? 150 million units!
- ryanwatkins 15y agoYea, here's a better one. Game consoles, both popular and unpopular, with tablets both popular and less popular : http://www.ryanwatkins.net/images/tablet-gameconsole-sales.png http://www.ryanwatkins.net/images/tablet-gameconsole-sales.p...
- hnsmurf 15y agoIt wasn't that long ago when you could have shown a similar chart with Android phones.
- lukifer 15y agoThe tech may be similar, but they're fundamentally different markets. Almost everybody needs a phone, but tablets are (currently) luxury items; and carriers play a far smaller role in tablets, and often none at all.
- dstein 15y agoA Future Shop representative told me only 5 HP WebOS tablets were sold in all Future Shop stores in Ontario.
- a3camero 15y agoThat seems quite unlikely. If only because of HP's actual business presence in Ontario. Surely some of their Mississauga employees went to Futureshop... http://welcome.hp.com/country/ca/en/contact/office_locs.html http://welcome.hp.com/country/ca/en/contact/office_locs.html
- digikata 15y agoThis data would be more interesting if put into context with the category leaders at the time. The ratio of lead sales console vs "obscure" console would be nice. Even better if you can normalize time (avg monthly ratio) or plot the ratio vs launch month. That would give some idea of the non-lead tablets are on a similar sales trajectory as non-lead consoles.
- masklinn 15y agoSome of them don't really fit in a given generation (the 32X was an addon to the Mega Drive/Genesis released in the later years of the console, the Mega-CD was an other addon released earlier to equip the Mega Drive against the just-released TurboGraphx16-CD, the VirtualBoy did not really fit in any category). * The Jaguar was a 5th gen console, the generation leader was the PlayStation with ~100 million units sold. The Jaguar sold under 250000, or 0.25% of the leader, other major entrants of the generation were the N64 (33m) and the Saturn (10m) * The CD-i was something of a hybrid console/media player (only time I saw it used was a driving school, fwiw), it's nominally part of the 4th generation whose leader was the Super Famicom/Super NES. The CD-i sold ~500k units, the SNES sold 50 million. 1%. The the other major entrant of the generation was the Mega Drive/Genesis with 40m. * The 3DO Interactive was a 5th gen console, sold 2 million, 2% of leader (PS) * The TurboGraphx16, I think calling it a failure is a bit of a stretch: it was a 4th gen console and sold 10m units (~20% of generation leader) while it was pretty much only available in japan, where it performed quite well indeed. Comparatively the Saturn bombed much harder (and the Dreamcast did even worse, compared to its generation leader)
- Apocryphon 15y agoI wish they had added the Atari Lynx, and maybe some of the NeoGeo consoles.
- wmf 15y agoI found these graphs pretty interesting: http://www.asymco.com/2011/07/16/the-frontiers-of-platform-adoption/ http://www.asymco.com/2011/07/16/the-frontiers-of-platform-a...
- aresant 15y agoTo finish the exercise include iPhone / iPod Touch sales vs. the biggest consoles ever released and the point is made. eg: ~100m iPhones (most recent data I could find was through Q4 2010 for aggregate): Then compare to the top gaming platforms ever shipped: PlayStation 154.59 million Nintendo DS 147.86 million Game Boy/Game Boy Color 118.69 million Sony PlayStation 102.49 million By that measuring stick iOS wins big vs. obscure consoles, but it also wins vs. the biggest and best. ref - http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:IPhone_sales_per_quarter.svg http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:IPhone_sales_per_quarter.s... ref - http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_best-selling_game_consoles http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_best-selling_game_conso...
- cwe 15y agoHad to view your source to differentiate the two Playstations you have there. The top one is PlayStation 2, with 154.59 Million.
- jisaacstone 15y agoshould be iPads, not iPhones/iPods, to keep with the spirit of the OP
- vectorpush 15y agoI am confused... the point is made more clear by comparing game consoles to phones? How? Not to mention you're comparing 4 iterations of the iPhone to arbitrary console life cycles. If we're talking about pure numbers here, there are more substantive comparisons to be made. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_best-selling_mobile_phones http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_best-selling_mobile_pho...
- notaddicted 15y agoYou can write games for iPhone, therefore it is a gaming platform. Also AFAIK the four generations of iPhones can all run the same software, which in a way makes it equivalent to a single console lifecycle, since consoles are never forwards compatible.
- martythemaniak 15y agoI wonder if marco reads HN? I'd be down for some action on longbets.com: http://martin.drashkov.com/2011/03/why-android-tablets-will-dominate.html http://martin.drashkov.com/2011/03/why-android-tablets-will-...
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- martythemaniak 15y agoThe current dominant thinking (at least on HN, fed by sites like DaringFireball, Marco or Asymco) is that the iPad super-special and will be the dominant platform because it's everything everyone would ever want. You may have seen the mantra "There is no tablet market, but there is an iPad market" I welcome everyone to put their money where their mouth is, I can always use free money :)
- GHFigs 15y ago"There's an iPad market," said Tim Bajarin, an analyst at Creative Strategies, "and then there's everyone else." Where was this rabid fanboyism printed? The Wall Street Journal, in an article titled "Tablet War is an Apple Rout". http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10001424053111903918104576502170114951168.html http://online.wsj.com/article/SB1000142405311190391810457650...
- ck2 15y agoI see that as market potential, no? Wait 'till 10 inch clone tablets hit $100 for xmas. (ironically hitting the OLPC pricepoint goal)
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- fpgeek 15y agoNot including the Nook Color and other non-Honeycomb Android tablets (roughly estimated around 3 million and 4 million respectively, IIRC) distorts the results substantially, IMO. Especially in a gaming context, my working definition of a tablet is: 1. Does it have a touchscreen? 2. Is it bigger than a smartphone? 3. Can it play Angry Birds? (a) The Nook Color and most other non-Honeycomb Android tablets easily qualify on all 3 points. (a) out-of-the-box with no rooting/hacking/etc
- zmmmmm 15y agoAndroid and other tablets have barely hit the market yet. This seems like a completely pointless comparison at this time.
- floppydisk 15y agoFrom a "units" perspective it's interesting to see the comparison. However, I think the article presents a false comparison between apples and oranges. Gaming consoles appeal to a limited section of the market and will generally ship less units than a mobile device. For instance, in a family of four, you might find four cellphones and only one gaming system. Simple fact. I think a more interesting comparison would be between tablet sales and mobile gaming device sales.
- Apocryphon 15y agoNow I'm tempted to get a TurboGrafx 16.
- MatthewPhillips 15y agoMarco's source for Android sales: Daring Fireball. Another source, reported by BGR, has Android at 20% of tablet market share.[1] [1]http://www.bgr.com/2011/08/12/android-steals-20-of-tablet-market-from-ipad-over-past-year/ http://www.bgr.com/2011/08/12/android-steals-20-of-tablet-ma...
- lukifer 15y agoThere's a difference between units sold to retail, units sold to customers, and units that are actually in use by customers. I'm also curious if they count Nooks, which are not always used as tablets even though they run Android. Don't get me wrong, I'm rooting for non-Apple tablets. But in reality, there don't seem to be that many in the wld yet.
- MatthewPhillips 15y agoI'm not saying the article is credible, I'm saying Daring Fireball isn't. I think it's sad what Marco's rooting interest are here. It's not enough that the iPad succeed. It's competitors have to fail for him to be happy. If the tablet really is the future of personal computing then there will be more than 1 successful platform. If not, then maybe not. Right now Best Buy is betting their business on the former. If you walk into a Best Buy they have a section for tablets equal to their section of laptops (and larger than their 1 row of desktops). Maybe Best Buy is wrong and they'll go back to a big area of laptops again. Or maybe Marco, Gruber, etc. will find a new data point that they can point to as being all-important.
- anigbrowl 15y agoI think Best Buy are making the right call. I have wanted a tablet as my general-purpose computer for years, and had been hugely frustrated at the high price and low uptake of Windows models. When the iPad was announced I immediately hailed it as a game-changer (and am still waiting for another HN reader to make good on his $100 bet that it would go nowhere). I'm thrilled to see worthwhile competitors emerging this summer; last time computers were this interesting was maybe 15 years ago.
- davcro 15y agoLast night I visited my uncle, a 50 year old rancher in Eastern Colorado. He wanted to show me videos of him calf-roping with a rodeo celebrity. I was very surprised when he brought out a Samsung Galaxy Tablet. This man is extremely computer illiterate and prides himself on ignoring modern technology. But wow did he love that tablet. He used it for everything (doesn't own a computer). This incident convinced me that non-iPad tablets have a fighting chance. I'd like to see this exercise done again in one year. I believe non-iPads will gain more traction.
- Pewpewarrows 15y agoSo... a company's line of tablets that's been on the market for 16 months has sold more total units than a company's line of tablets that's been on the market for 6? This is both new and exciting.
- Sniffnoy 15y agoI'm just surprised to learn that the VirtualBoy outsold the 32X and the Jaguar...
- r0s 15y agoFor all it's problems, it's a very immersive, unique experience. Who knows, a few generations more it could have become small and portable. At the time, it looked like the future.
- tensor 15y agoIt's not clear to me why some people seem so keen on seeing a single tablet seller. History has shown numerous times how monopolies are bad and how competition benefits the consumer immensely. The tablet market is new and still mostly luxury. I wouldn't place any bets right now, even considering Apple's head start.