4 ms·
Is there any point in saying sorry anymore? One commenter in the thread already described it as a non-apology. For them, there is no '𝘴ₒᵣᵣy' or '...please, I
by rvz 5y ago
Is there any point in saying sorry anymore? One commenter in the thread already described it as a non-apology.
For them, there is no '𝘴ₒᵣᵣy' or '...please, I can explain...' or 'it's not what you think it is'.
Once it has already been admitted, the road already looks like it is heading to no redemption.
- nickff 5y agoThe top comment on the apology is also an accusation of insufficient prostration. I agree that internet culture seems antithetical to forgiveness, and have no idea what can be done about it.
- Arnavion 5y agoWhat the heck are you two talking about? You're making it out as if the two top-level comments are just that OP didn't apologize enough. In reality they're responding specifically to the OP's individual claims and pointing out they're not accurate. You think that "Our projects were moved to GitHub Enterprise to consolidate billing but we never had a bill in the first place." and "You're telling us we don't have copyright over our projects but the contract we signed doesn't say that." is "an accusation of insufficient prostration" ?
- alpaca128 5y agoYou might want to consider that the forced pull request has still not been reverted by this person. So an apology but no intention to undo a mistake? Does not sound very genuine in any way. Also, an apology about a PR isn't this long. This is a wall of text with a few meek words inbetween.
- bingo-bongo 5y agoThe forced PR was reverted shortly after by another maintainer. And I agree, a “sorry my bad” type of comment would have looked nice in the PR, but the attitude and actions in it vs the official apology, sounds like completely different people.
- mechanical_bear 5y agoIt has been reverted.
- sva_ 5y agoForgiveness seems to be a somewhat old tradition that slowly goes out of fashion. I find that very regrettable, as forgiveness is the thing that enables the other one to admit their mistake and then improve upon it, which I think is one of the pillars of our society.
- yifanl 5y agoNot to armchair, but I think it's a reaction to the very liberal interpretation of the phrase "it's easier to ask for forgiveness than permission" that seemingly every entity with authority has used in almost any community. Like me personally, I'm just about out of forgiveness to give, it's too often that the entity in question goes and skips asking permission a second time after they apologize for the first time. Though in this specific case, the infraction seems really so minor that I'd happily live and let live.
- katbyte 5y agoan apology is more than just saying "i'm sorry". Anyone can say "i'm sorry" - not everyone can/will/or does apologize.