3 ms·
>they're literally organisizing and coordinating with police in their own interests, put simply, they use the police like a bunch of private goons. I'm not see
by gruez 5y ago
>they're literally organisizing and coordinating with police in their own interests, put simply, they use the police like a bunch of private goons.
I'm not seeing that in the quoted excerpts. Specifically,
>But records obtained by the Guardian show the company meets daily with police to discuss intelligence gathering and patrols
"company meets daily with police" just means... "company meets daily with police". It doesn't mean the company is ordering the police around. Maybe the pipeline company has knowledge about the local geography and/or protester movements. Is telling that to the police wrong? Moreover, I fail to see where the leverage is coming from. Suppose the company wants the police to illegally beat up protesters. The police chief refuses. What's the pipeline company going to do, fire them? That's not an option because they're forced to pay the police.
>And when Enbridge wants protesters removed, it calls police or sends letters.
Yes, that's how police works. If my house is getting robbed or my neighbor is partying a bit too loud, I call the police to deal with it. I don't wait for the police to show up on their own accord. Me calling up the police doesn't mean I'm using them "like a bunch of private goons".
- klyrs 5y agoCan the tribes call up the police to have them enforce treaty rights that the oil companies are infringing? > Yes, that's how police works. Yes, that's the problem.
- gruez 5y ago>Can the tribes call up the police to have them enforce treaty rights that the oil companies are infringing? Police aren't supposed to be judge, jury, and executioner. A protester trespassing on pipeline company's property is a fairly cut and dry case that the police can act on it. Some treaty dispute between the tribe and the pipeline company is vague enough that they'll need a court ruling before they can act. If the tribes can get a court ruling, they can definitely call up the police to enforce those treaty rights. >> Yes, that's how police works. >Yes, that's the problem. I'm baffled by this. You think that being able to call up a police to report a disturbance/crime, is a problem?
- klyrs 5y agoFunny how the pipeline company's "property" is cut and dry, but a 200 year-old treaty guaranteeing access to that land isn't recognized, is't it? The problem with the police that I'm talking about here is that they readily apply violence to suppress protest on behalf of corporate interests, when the legal situation is actually far more complex. If it's just so simple as "the pipeline companies meet with the police every day," do tribal leaders get the same courtesy?
- gruez 5y ago> Funny how the pipeline company's "property" is cut and dry, but a 200 year-old treaty guaranteeing access to that land isn't recognized, is't it? No. I'm also not surprised that the anti-pipeline activists presented talking points that sound vaguely compelling and garner maximum sympathy from an average layperson. >The problem with the police that I'm talking about here is that they readily apply violence to suppress protest on behalf of corporate interests, when the legal situation is actually far more complex. I agree it's complex, but just because it's complex, doesn't mean that the pipeline is in a legal limbo zone where nobody owns it and everyone can do what they want. I suspect that's happening is that legally speaking, the pipeline company has gotten the necessary permits/approvals/decisions that they can start construction and evict trespassers. There might still be additional appeals on top, but they're not convincing enough for a judge to grant an injunction. You might disagree with this, and say that the justice system should be more obstructionist, but that's more of a problem with the judicial system than the police, and has nothing to do with this article's accusation that the police are being bribed or whatever.
- Barrin92 5y agoI hope you're able to draw a distinction between protests of the public near a state park and through native land against a company and their pipeline which is inherently an issue of public land usage and environmental concerns and some thief rummaging through your garage. It should be very obvious why that is a bad faith comparison. The right of the public to protest and protect their land, in a democracy at least, holds quite some value, and furthermore in a democracy the police answers to the people and citizens it serves, in this case native people, they should not have the oil company CEO on speed dial.
- gruez 5y agoAm I missing something here? Is the pipeline company calling the police in bad faith? ie. they're reporting protesters even though they're not on pipeline company land? Is the legal situation regarding land rights in that area so conflicted that it's impossible to know who owns what? Even if there are appeals going on, there should be some sort of current decision about who can access/use the land.