42 ms·
> All these comments seem to live in a fantastical world where money doesn't corrupt or influence behavior. Police were paid to do a job and did it to the benef
by gruez 5y ago
> All these comments seem to live in a fantastical world where money doesn't corrupt or influence behavior. Police were paid to do a job and did it to the benefit of an oil company. You can't pay a detective to investigate a family murder or sexual assault and shouldn't have to. Ostensibly that's what taxes for and what most people actually want them to do anyways.
But as another commenter mentioned[1], the pipeline company isn't doing this voluntarily, they're doing it because the utility commission forced them to. If that's the case, what's the difference between the pipeline company paying the police, and the pipeline company paying taxes, which goes to the town, which pays the police?
[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28776698 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28776698
- Barrin92 5y agoFor starters according to the article: "Enbridge told the Guardian an independent account manager allocates the funds, and police decide when protesters are breaking the law. But records obtained by the Guardian show the company meets daily with police to discuss intelligence gathering and patrols. And when Enbridge wants protesters removed, it calls police or sends letters. “Our police are beholden to a foreign company,” Tara Houska, founder of the Indigenous frontline group Giniw Collective, told the Guardian. “They are working hand in hand with big oil. They are actively working for a company. Their duty is owed to the state of Minnesota and to the tribal citizens of Minnesota.”" The company does much more than just funding the police comparable to tax revenue, they're literally organisizing and coordinating with police in their own interests, put simply, they use the police like a bunch of private goons.
- avs733 5y agounderfunding public institutions in ways that drive them towards other sources of funding and outside influence by those with power and capital is not accidental, it is intentional. You can effectively force this type of corruption by cutting apportionment without cutting responsibilities. C.f.... * IRS unable to investigate rich tax cheats due to lack of agents * the FDA example used elsewhere * America's public universities * This
- gruez 5y ago> underfunding public institutions in ways that drive them towards other sources of funding and outside influence by those with power and capital is not accidental, it is intentional. You fail to address the question in my earlier comment: what's the difference between: 1. a company being forced to pay taxes to the local government, and the local government using that to fund the police 2. a company being forced to pay the police
- verall 5y agoIt adds a layer of indirection which helps prevent moral hazard. If the company pays taxes to the local government, and the local government pays the police department, AND the company is not allowed to pay the police department directly, there is less possibility for the company to incentivize particular behaviors. The police budget should be set by the local government, breaking protestor lines should not come with rewards provided by a private company, that investigating regular public crimes would not have.
- gruez 5y ago> It adds a layer of indirection which helps prevent moral hazard. If the company pays taxes to the local government, and the local government pays the police department, AND the company is not allowed to pay the police department directly, there is less possibility for the company to incentivize particular behaviors. According to the article there's already a layer of indirection. "independent account manager allocates the funds" What's the difference between "independent account manager" and "local government" in this case? Moreover, what can either party do to influence the police's behavior? Does having "evil pipeline co." on the check make the police chief more willing to beat up protesters or something? >The police budget should be set by the local government Considering that the payment is being forced by the utility commission, I doubt the local government is able to spend the money as they see fit (ie. spend it on schools rather than police). For all intents and purposes their budget-setting ability is fairly limited. >breaking protestor lines should not come with rewards provided by a private company, that investigating regular public crimes would not have. Is there any indication that's the case? As far as I understand it the utility commission is forcing the pipeline company to give the police a given amount, and the pipeline is complying with that requirement. Is the pipline company setting a bounty per protester beaten up or something?
- gruez 5y ago>they're literally organisizing and coordinating with police in their own interests, put simply, they use the police like a bunch of private goons. I'm not seeing that in the quoted excerpts. Specifically, >But records obtained by the Guardian show the company meets daily with police to discuss intelligence gathering and patrols "company meets daily with police" just means... "company meets daily with police". It doesn't mean the company is ordering the police around. Maybe the pipeline company has knowledge about the local geography and/or protester movements. Is telling that to the police wrong? Moreover, I fail to see where the leverage is coming from. Suppose the company wants the police to illegally beat up protesters. The police chief refuses. What's the pipeline company going to do, fire them? That's not an option because they're forced to pay the police. >And when Enbridge wants protesters removed, it calls police or sends letters. Yes, that's how police works. If my house is getting robbed or my neighbor is partying a bit too loud, I call the police to deal with it. I don't wait for the police to show up on their own accord. Me calling up the police doesn't mean I'm using them "like a bunch of private goons".
- klyrs 5y agoCan the tribes call up the police to have them enforce treaty rights that the oil companies are infringing? > Yes, that's how police works. Yes, that's the problem.
- gruez 5y ago>Can the tribes call up the police to have them enforce treaty rights that the oil companies are infringing? Police aren't supposed to be judge, jury, and executioner. A protester trespassing on pipeline company's property is a fairly cut and dry case that the police can act on it. Some treaty dispute between the tribe and the pipeline company is vague enough that they'll need a court ruling before they can act. If the tribes can get a court ruling, they can definitely call up the police to enforce those treaty rights. >> Yes, that's how police works. >Yes, that's the problem. I'm baffled by this. You think that being able to call up a police to report a disturbance/crime, is a problem?
- 5y ago