3 ms·
I grew up in a very religious (technically a cult) setting. Earlier in my life, I believed some of it. I bristled at the suggestion that what I'd been taught mi
by haswell 5y ago
I grew up in a very religious (technically a cult) setting. Earlier in my life, I believed some of it. I bristled at the suggestion that what I'd been taught might be wrong. I relished in the opportunity to practice "apologetics" and debate non-believers - a concept that appealed to me deeply at the time.
And then, I grew up and left the bubble. I was fortunate enough to get a job working with people who held diverse viewpoints. I still found myself resisting those viewpoints instinctively, but I learned something that surprised me at the time: the people who held those viewpoints were good people! Who'd have thought? I'd been told those people were the enemy. Unbelievers, sinners, "of this world".
As my relationships with those people grew, the cracks in my own belief systems started to grow.
I'm now in my mid 30s, and would describe my mindset as that of a scientist. I'm excited to learn when I'm wrong, because it means I learned something new about the world.
I often think about the people I left behind, many of whom are still deeply in the bubble. I wonder if I got out because I was predisposed to have an open mind, and when given the opportunity I took it, or if I was just exposed to the right combination of things to help me see the light.
All of this to follow up on this:
> Does anyone else find it hard to personally connect with the well-researched claim that people respond with a fight-or-flight response to ideas that challenge their core beliefs?
I can still feel some kind of connection to that early version of myself, or at least I know it was there and now it's not. This history has established within me some empathy for people who still do react poorly to new ideas, and I've found that it helps me better understand (not accept) the viewpoints of others around me that might otherwise seem insane.
Edit: I know it's not great to complain about downvotes, but I'm really puzzled here.
- rvbissell 5y agoI'm not sure why you were net-downvoted; your anecdote was on-topic, relative to the comment you replied to. I have a similar background, and your use of 'of this world' may possibly indicate that we both suffered at the hands of the same cult. Within myself, I have personally experienced both the fight-or-flight reaction to dis-confirming datapoints, and also excitement at learning something new. The former happened more often when I was still in the clutches of the cult. I think it boils down to how psychologically invested you are in your beliefs, at the time of feeling the cognitive dissonance.
- ewzimm 5y agoWhen I think about the earlier version of myself and compare him to who I am now, I don't feel a strong sense of disconnection, because although I may have seen the world differently, I remember being very aware that I was still young and didn't have enough experience to hold a fully-formed view of the world. I expected my perspective to change as I got older. I think he would be surprised that he wasn't able to find satisfying answers from people in his community but open to the ideas I have now. The first thing I remember thinking about is how strange it is to be conscious and unable to fully trust my senses or my mind, wondering what might be beyond my understanding.