5 ms·
Commonwealth Fusion expects to start commercialization in 2025. They say it will put power onto the grid.
by 2OEH8eoCRo0 5y ago
Commonwealth Fusion expects to start commercialization in 2025. They say it will put power onto the grid.
- hamburglar 5y agoWhat I’ve heard is that they will have a demonstration of “net energy” by 2025. This is still a long way from solving the engineering problem of putting energy on the grid. And if that “net energy” definitions is actually Q-plasma as this video claims, it’s a lot farther still.
- hobscoop 5y agoSPARC is aiming for Q_plasma of about 10 in 2025, but not to generate energy at all: it doesn't have any of the required 'blanket' system for breeding tritium. SPARC is a physics test, to make sure our theories of burning plasma are correct and to test the stability of these high field tokamaks. ITER is (among other things) supposed to be a physics test, but won't come until 2035. So SPARC's goal is to 'leapfrog' that by 10 years. You're right that there's a lot of work to be done between Q_plasma = 10 and generating energy. A lot of this work on the materials side, to engineer materials that can last for years in a fusion reactor environment.
- dr_orpheus 5y ago"This HTS magnet technology will next be used in SPARC, which is under construction in Devens, Massachusetts and on track to demonstrate net energy from fusion by 2025. SPARC will pave the way for the first commercially viable fusion power plant called ARC." [0] But this does not say that they are going to put power on the grid in 2025. They say net energy from fusion by 2025 which may just mean Q-plasma > 1, it does not say (which kind of proves the point of the article). They don't have any estimates of an on the grid fusion plant. https://cfs.energy/news-and-media/cfs-commercial-fusion-power-with-hts-magnet https://cfs.energy/news-and-media/cfs-commercial-fusion-powe...
- gene-h 5y agoSPARC will not generate electricity[0]. It's intended to show that the ARC concept, which should be able to generate net electricity[1], is viable. If SPARC works, ARC might be built as early as 2030. 'As early as' being the keywords here. Showing that the difficult physics work is important to do before moving on to the difficult engineering. [0]https://www.psfc.mit.edu/sparc/faq https://www.psfc.mit.edu/sparc/faq [1]https://arxiv.org/pdf/1409.3540.pdf https://arxiv.org/pdf/1409.3540.pdf
- tuatoru 5y agoTheranos Fusion. Edit: There has been Edison, and there has been Musk. If you're not either of them, and you claim other people are doing their engineering wrong ... consider that you might be mistaken. Make a big song and dance about it, you look like a charlatan.
- vjaswal 5y agoI think this take is too skeptical to apply to all the startups. For all the talks from CFS I've seen, they've been very measured and sober about the viability of near-term fusion. The game changer here is not very new reactor designs, but cheap high performance high-temperature superconductors that enable very high field and therefore much smaller size. Other fusion work, like ICF or the LLNL laser fusion or Lockheed or General Fusion all seem to be built on designs that are far less understood and less Q performance so far.
- pfdietz 5y agoThe high-Tc superconductors are nice, but they are not a panacea. They move fusion from "absurdly" to just "desperately" uncompetitive.
- vjaswal 5y agoI've seen various youtube videos from their employees and CEO. From what I remember, Dennis Whyte (head of the fusion lab at MIT and CFS cofounder) says you need about Q>5 at least, to make fusion economically viable. So that must mean Qplasma > 5. SPARC is working towards that by 2025. And so far, the company, CFS, has been achieving their milestones for the performance of their magnets. The HTS magnets and coils is the main ingredient that the startup is optimizing for. Sometime in the last year, they implied that their Qplasma was much better than they minimally hoped for. I think they achieved Qplasma > 10, but Dennis was keeping the details proprietary. From all the talks I remember, they are targeting power on the grid with the ARC reactor by 2035. Edit: This is the best recent video I've seen, about SPARC and ARC. Jumped to 2:25 for Dennis Whyte. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bHJyoqDO0zw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bHJyoqDO0zw It's targeted to MechE students and gives a lot of details about other aspects of a potential ARC reactor design, e.g. how to get the heat out.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 5y agoYes. They start commercialization. Not that a commercial reactor will be ready in 2025 but where they work to commercialize SPARC -> ARC. https://cfs.energy/technology https://cfs.energy/technology
- vjaswal 5y agoAh, yes, I understand what you meant with your wording. Proof-of-concept by 2025, and commercialization after that.
- pfdietz 5y agoThey plan in 2025 to be where fission was in 1942. Only a small matter of engineering after that that can't take very long, right?
- vjaswal 5y agoI added a link above to a good talk from Dennis Whyte. I think it will help address your question about the additional engineering issues in a commercial reactor based on ARC. In short, from my basic understanding, there are quite a few additional major challenges involved with fusion power generation. e.g. After creating net-positive fusion, the heat must be efficiently extracted without stopping the reaction. Also tritium must be continually extracted from the FLiBe (fluorine-lithium-beryllium) bath that stops and collects neutrons and extracts the heat. Since I'm a total novice in all this, I don't know if these require incremental innovations or major advances. But from the video, the problems mentioned seem to be more tractable than achieving fusion ignition or Q>10.
- knodi123 5y agoFusion as a power source has been several years away for several decades.