11 ms·
The Tech Worker Handbook
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- chrisweekly 5y ago> ... So-called “employee handbooks,” provided to workers at the beginning of employment, are ubiquitous within the tech industry. They are filled with the information an employer wants a worker to know, but are void of the content workers need to protect themselves. The Tech Worker Handbook is not a how-to, set of instructions, checklist, or call to action to whistleblow. Whistleblowing — the act of speaking up in order to improve a situation for others — is an individual decision that should be made after a careful consideration of risks, options, and intended outcomes. My hope, though, is that those who do decide to take great risks in coming forward — for all of us — are better prepared and supported. ^ Excerpt from TFA. IMHO it's a good idea, cool resource. Not everyone has Frances Haugen's gumption and foresight.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- fidesomnes 5y ago> Frances Haugen's gumption and foresight. Yeah if you mean hiring Obama's attorneys and orchestrating a media crush for not censoring people on the internet hard enough, I don't know what else you could mean.
- walshemj 5y ago"Employee hand books" are useful to employees as it defines what various procedures and rights are.
- ethbr0 5y agoAh, so employee handbooks inform their employees of their right to unionize (or refrain from unionizing) without threatening, interrogating, spying on pro-union employees, or promising benefits if employees forget about forming a union? https://www.nlrb.gov/about-nlrb/rights-we-protect/the-law/interfering-with-employee-rights-section-7-8a1 https://www.nlrb.gov/about-nlrb/rights-we-protect/the-law/in...
- _3u10 5y agoWhy would anyone making salary in the 1% (top 0.001% globally) range in the US want to unionize? I don’t get this whole anti tech thing from tech.
- walshemj 5y agoWhy not George Clooney is a member of SAG (actors union) as is Daniel Craig.
- tick_tock_tick 5y agoThat's just an example of an argument people make against unions. No matter what Clooney or Craig thinks they have no choice but to be a member of the SAG.
- ethbr0 5y agoBecause wealth and morality are independent concepts.
- dgb23 5y agoUnions are not “anti-tech”, they are “pro-worker”. Who else is?
- howtoquitwell 5y agoProcedures and policies, yet. Rights, not so much, at least beyond those disclosures and documents they are legally required to share. As an example: it is a legally-protected right in many jurisdictions for employees to share compensation information with each other, or even externally. Many (most?) employers strongly discourage this practice, however, and will usually omit the notice that there are legal restrictions on their response in case employees choose to do so. Ditto labor organizing, many types of guaranteed leave, and most whistleblowing protections. The information asymmetry between most large employers and their employees w.r.t. legal rights is large, and the company's incentives are almost never aligned towards voluntary disclosure.
- walshemj 5y agoYes you have valid points but it does help when you have to take legal action - break your own procedure on grievance / discipline and you tend to lose in court.
- el_ravager 5y agoWhich is why it's sometimes necessary to go above the court and take the information straight to the people.
- walshemj 5y agoWhistleblowing and Employee hand books are two separate things
- tptacek 5y agoThis seems pretty fluffy. I read through the "Legal Handbook" and it doesn't seem as much like a handbook as it does a long article about what it's like to be a whistleblower, along with some very high level stuff about what it's like to engage a lawyer. Like, a really basic thing here is that the legal advice starts by asking people to evaluate whether the misconduct they're thinking about violates laws. But it provides little guidance on what those laws might be. Obviously, they'd say that the first step here is to retain counsel. But that's an expensive and difficult first step, and more workers will need to qualify what they're observing carefully before taking that step. Did anyone else read this more closely and reach a different conclusion? The security stuff seems especially weak. Like, basic things you'd want to see headlined are the types of corpsec measures that large tech companies have deployed to trace leaks, and what they're likely to find if they image all the devices your contract with them allows them to image. A much more fundamental problem I have with this "handbook" is that it seems geared towards getting people to leak things to the press and regulators. But that's not the limit of what tech workers can do to respond; a simple thing that the handbook doesn't talk much about is "when to quit", let alone when and how to engage in concerted action with other team members, and what the risks/benefits of that are.
- elefanten 5y agoLooking around the site, the handbook is by Ifeoma Ozoma, one of the Pinterest "whistleblowers" who went on a raging PR campaign and (seemingly) has now parlayed it into this consulting company. And here's what they're doing. It's utterly unserious content by a grievance-driven person.
- xpe 5y agoSince the title is not particularly informative, I'll share the first paragraph: > The Tech Worker Handbook is a collection of resources for tech workers who are looking to make more informed decisions about whether to speak out on issues that are in the public interest. Aiming to improve working conditions, direct attention to consumer harms, or otherwise address wrongdoing and abuse should not be a solo or poorly resourced endeavor.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- dinkleberg 5y agoYeah I’ve gotta say the naming choice is not very good. It looks like they’ve put quite a bit of effort into this, but I’d never have guessed that it is what it is based on its name.
- ForHackernews 5y agoI don't really understand why we keep being told that these insiders who got rich at surveillance-tech companies are the ones we now have to rely on to fix the monster they've belatedly come to fear. What is there to learn from these so-called "whistleblowers"?
- makeitdouble 5y agoI think their viewpoint is that the battle is already lost and expecting the situation to be fixed by regular means is unrealistic. Whistleblowers become these little Prometheuses bringing out some fire to fight the giants. I deeply disagree but can empathize with the pessimism, given how dire the situation has got.
- Mtinie 5y agoA lot? I personally don’t remember a major whistleblower—in the legal usage of the term—who asked to be the sole savior who can fix the problem they identified. It’s quite easy to lose sight of the whole picture while you are siloed working on a portion of the whole. I commend anyone who makes the public aware of bad corporate or governmental actors, even if it took them a while to come around to making their decision. That they may have profited in the past is immaterial. That’s an ethical dilemma they will need to resolve on their own.
- rsynnott 5y agoI mean, if a company is doing bad things, and particularly if it's breaking the law, it is not usually going to announce the fact to the world. Whistleblowing is very often how the truth gets out; how many more people would have had junk medical results if not for the Theranos whistleblowers, say? Perhaps in an ideal world, the government would have perfect clarity on the bad things that companies were doing through regulatory oversight. But in practice we're not in that world and a nefarious company can quite effectively hide all sorts of wrongdoing for a long time.
- moksly 5y agoRegulating big tech is a democratic issue. It’s not up to the individual tech worker to do so, and I’m not convinced that all these movements aren’t “soft-solutions” organised by big tech to avoid people working on real solutions. Solutions like legal intervention from the EU and whatever government you are under. Poor working conditions are solved by forming unions. In Denmark we have strong unions, and while their power is weaning (in parts thanks to big tech platforms jbecoming the middle men and taking 25-50%) our unions are the sole reason we have some of the best working conditions in the world. Because here’s the secret to good working conditions. If you and everyone else in your line of work stops working, along with anyone working jobs that somehow support your lone of work, things change overnight. Just ask MCD why they pay the now famous $22 and hour (or however much it was) when they initially didn’t want to. It’s because it’s hard to sell burgers when the dock workers refuse to unload your bread and the truckers refuse to deliver it. So I’m all for the ideals behind these things, but they need to think bigger if they want to change anything. We shouldn’t need whistleblowers and bad PR to keep Facebook away from our children, it should simply be illegal with mega business ending consequences. When that happens you can be fairly sure that business will start to actually regulate itself, because if there is one thing enterprise businesses care about it’s actual risk.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- goodpoint 5y ago> It’s not up to the individual tech worker to do so Correct! The handbook puts all focus on the individual and "forgets" to recommend collective action. I wonder why.
- ipaddr 5y agoCurious what is the cost of a big mac meal with fries and a coke?
- nawgz 5y agoProbably the same as anywhere. From [0]: > Menu prices vary from each McDonald’s location, so it’s a little difficult to say exactly how much an American would pay for a Big Mac while visiting Denmark. Anecdotally speaking, we checked menu prices via meal-delivery services (UberEats for the United States and JustEat for Denmark) to see how much this popular burger costs in their respective countries. At a McDonald’s location in Copenhagen, for example, this burger cost 30.00 kr (about $4.73). At a McDonald’s location in Tulsa, Oklahoma, a Big Mac costs $4.82. > This single example lines up with the Big Mac Index, an interactive tool from the Economist that compares Big Mac prices around the world. According to the Big Mac Index, “a Big Mac costs DKr30.00 in Denmark and US$5.66 in the United States.” When adjusted for GDP, the Economist found that “a Big Mac costs 13% less in Denmark (US$4.90) than in the United States (US$5.66) at market exchange rates.” [0]: https://www.snopes.com/fact-check/big-mac-cost-denmark/ https://www.snopes.com/fact-check/big-mac-cost-denmark/
- hikerclimber1 5y agoEverything is subjective. Especially laws.
- throwaway4303 5y agoWhistle-blowing and public pressure does help in improving working conditions for all workers at tech companies. Example Article highlighting lack of benefits for contract workers at Google https://www.nytimes.com/2019/05/28/technology/google-temp-workers.html https://www.nytimes.com/2019/05/28/technology/google-temp-wo... Result- Google instituted new policies for contractors who now get full-time like benefits including healthcare, sick and parental leave https://www.wired.com/story/google-require-suppliers-give-benefits-workers/ https://www.wired.com/story/google-require-suppliers-give-be.... That's 120,000 workers that didn't have benefits now get benefits.
- iammisc 5y agoThat's great, but these benefits shouldn't come from the workplace. > sick As a contractor, you don't need to report time to the company you didn't work due to being sick. If Google is requiring this, they are statutory employees. That is the real problem. Providing 'benefits' to 'contractors' is just a bandaid. Either the benefits ought to be provided through other means, or the contractors are really employees and that needs to be fixed.
- pajamaw 5y agoNot sure if anyone related to the Handbook are here, or posted this, but if you are you is there a way to download material covered in the Handbook? A git repo, torrent, etc. It's good of you to inform users > That said, I do NOT advise accessing this from a company device. Your employer can, and will likely, track visits to a resource like this Handbook. But something even better than that would be facilitating a way to ingest the data or consult it without having to access the site each time.
- kodah 5y agoWhistleblowing seems to be where everyone's faith is these days. Training people on whistleblowing is supposed to be an internal matter. By that I mean companies can have whistleblowing programs to identify problems proactively. This is generally how the US military (and the government more widely) use theirs. This should shield the company from responsibility if they at least attempt to act, not to mention it would probably buy trust from the public. I've worked in big tech for a bit now and I've seen a lot of open door policies, but never a whistleblower program.
- _alex_ 5y agoGoes by other names. You probably have an anonymous ethics line
- PragmaticPulp 5y ago> The Signals Network, the 501(c)(3) non-profit organization that compiled these legal considerations, is one of these actors. The Signals Network enables whistleblowers and international journalists to work seamlessly together to hold powerful interests accountable A word of advice: Don't get your legal advice from the same journalists that want to use your story, and maybe also your name, to further their own career. There's an inherent conflict of interest between someone who wants to use your leak to further their own agenda (be it activism or simply writing a juicy news story) and your own interests as someone with potentially massive legal liability. When the legal wheels start turning, it's not the journalist who is putting their finances and freedom at risk. It's the employee. Leaking company documents or even violating NDAs you signed as part of your employment should not be taken lightly, no matter how friendly sites like this make it sound. Always engage with legal representation that is not affiliated with the journalists who want your story. Never let a friendly journalist talk you into divulging information that could expose you until you've worked through the legal ramifications, no matter how much they encourage you to push forward.
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 5y agoTo be fair, some have said this leaker from Facebook is quite vulnerable to being sued or even prosecuted and are probably wondering why Facebook is not taking legal action against her. The most obvious guess is that she is effectively protected by the press that Facebook is receiving at the moment. Without that publicity, i.e., the help of "conflicted" journalists, her legal arguments for protection seem rather weak.
- laurent92 5y agoThe word of mouth circulating around less technical people, is to assume she’s more a PR coup / a corporate plant. Actual whistleblowers don’t get leniency, exit their hideout at 47 looking 80 with dementia, in a wheelchair, portrayed as the most dangerous liability in the world, with two accusations of rape. Anyone not suicided, presented as friendly by the press, does not represent a risk for corporations.
- ghasm 5y agoThis describes itself as a handbook for tech workers, but it’s just about leaking confidential info and likely losing your job? Huh??
- goodpoint 5y agoAs a side note, this should be a single page or, at least, an epub. Scattering the text across many little articles discourages a comprehensive reading.