4 ms·
One recent anti-meme is words that you are not allowed to say even to refer to the word. If you didn't know the word, the phrase "the N-word" is not very enlig
by aidenn0 5y ago
One recent anti-meme is words that you are not allowed to say even to refer to the word. If you didn't know the word, the phrase "the N-word" is not very enlightening, but people have been censured and even fired for using that word just to refer to it as a word[1].
In addition if you search for the actual word (not "n-word") on HN none of the articles are from the past year (there are two submissions from the past year, but the articles are from 1999 and 1971. The submissions have a total of 11 upvotes.
I recently ran into an article that used the phrase "the R-word" and I had to ask my teenage daughter which particular word that referred to. It's now very googleable, but at the time none of the top 5 pages on google indicated what the word might be.
1: One example: a white teacher at a meeting discussing standards for materials used in the classroom. One rule disallowed books with the n-word. The teacher said roughly: "So if there is a book about the black experience, written by a black author, I can't use it in my classroom because it has the word 'n*****' in it?"
- alisonkisk 5y agoRecent??? The tetragrammaton is thousands of years old. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tetragrammaton https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tetragrammaton
- willhinsa 5y agoN, R, and F.
- Y_Y 5y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Euphemism#Euphemism_treadmill https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Euphemism#Euphemism_treadmill For what it's worth, this stuff is culturally relative. The r-word is apparently "retard", and not an unsayable slur within my cultural sphere, to the best of my limited knowledge.
- aidenn0 5y ago> The r-word is apparently "retard", and not an unsayable slur within my cultural sphere, to the best of my limited knowledge. True of my cultural sphere as well, but it's considerably more shocking a word than "fuck" is to my teenage daughter.
- rovolo 5y agoI'd like to disagree with the idea of a "treadmill" because it implies that changing language doesn't anything and leaves us where we started. The wikipedia entry mentions "moron", "imbecile", and "retard" as examples which started as medical diagnoses before becoming insults. It implies that the medical community moved away from these terms because they became insults. However, these are all terms derived from IQ testing and the concept of "mental age". IQ has been de-emphasized as the diagnostic criterion for a couple reasons: people with mental disabilities aren't the same as younger people without mental disabilities; the focus should be on what sort of help people need rather than what they can't do. > In current medical diagnosis, IQ scores alone are not conclusive for a finding of intellectual disability. Recently adopted diagnostic standards place the major emphasis on the adaptive behavior of each individual, with IQ score just being one factor in diagnosis in addition to adaptive behavior scales, and no category of intellectual disability being defined primarily by IQ scores. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IQ_classification#Classification_of_low_IQ https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IQ_classification#Classificati... As for the common use as an insult, you're right that its impact is culturally relative. To me, I would ask why you're using a term which used to be a medical diagnosis as an insult. The wiki section says kids are saying "what are you, 'special'?" in reference to "special needs". Does that mean it's bad to get that medical diagnosis? I'd side-eye someone who says "retard" as an insult because it's not just rude to the insultee.
- speedybird 5y agoFundamentally, impugning somebody's intelligence is an insult. All the side-eyeing and inventive euphemisms in the world won't change this.
- rovolo 5y agoI agree that it's an insult. Some people's actions deserve to be insulted. I'm saying that you may be insulting other people who are not your target.
- speedybird 5y agoI agree that sometimes some people deserve to be insulted; particularly for their own good (for instance they were carelessly doing something risky and need to be reminded to take themselves off autopilot and pay attention to what they're doing.) But I think collateral damage may be unavoidable no matter which word you use for this. Wiktionary tells me that the word 'stupid' comes from the Latin stupidus (“struck senseless, amazed”) So, stupid didn't originate as a medical diagnosis and is ostensibly a 'safe' way to question somebody's intelligence. But I don't think it actually is; when you call somebody 'stupid' you're still framing a lack of intelligence as an undesirable trait. If somebody who earnestly does lack intelligence overhears this, they might be reminded of their own limitation and feel ashamed or inadequate because of it. Any intelligence-impugning insult can have collateral damage, whether or not that word was originally a medical diagnosis. I think the solution to this dilemma is to be aware of who might overhear you. I avoid any intelligence-impugning insult when I'm in a room with people who are actually intellectually disabled. But if nobody like that is in the room to overhear it, then I think any of the common intelligence-impugning insults are fair game if the circumstances justify it.
- dsr_ 5y agoThis is the proper place of a dictionary, and so: https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/N-word https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/N-word https://www.dictionary.com/browse/n-word https://www.dictionary.com/browse/n-word https://www.thefreedictionary.com/n-word https://www.thefreedictionary.com/n-word All tell you precisely what is meant. For some reason, school boards are terrible at the use-mention distinction.
- speedybird 5y ago> For some reason, school boards are terrible at the use-mention distinction. School boards are mostly comprised of average enough people, who are generally quite bad at this distinction. Although with school boards it's a bit worse because school board members can selectively choose not to recognize this distinction as a cudgel against their petty opponents (the lower the stakes, the nastier the fights...)
- exporectomy 5y agoBut I think most people know what those words are so somehow the idea is shared very well. Most taboos are probably like this - they're actually well known but talking about them and doing them is discouraged. I wonder about believing you're wrong about any specific knowledge you have. That's pretty hard. Others can try to communicate it to you but your brain tries to find ways to reject that information.