3 ms·
eMMC is literally an "embedded" version of the same storage media as SD cards. If you're worried about your SD card media dying on you then eMMC is strictly wo
by zozbot234 5y ago
eMMC is literally an "embedded" version of the same storage media as SD cards. If you're worried about your SD card media dying on you then eMMC is strictly worse; SD cards are at least socketed so when one dies you can just replace it. With eMMC you'd have to desolder the chip.
- avian 5y agoIn my experience, SD cards and eMMC chips on the Raspberry Pi Compute Modules are night and day in terms of reliability. Brand-name SD cards will fail in 6-12 months of running a typical mostly-idle Linux installation (yes, I've heard it all: power supply quality, improper shutdowns, counterfeit cards, etc. etc. It doesn't matter - SD cards just die all the time) I've yet to see an eMMC chip fail on a Compute Module. I'm aware of one Computer Module that's been running for around 3 years as a CI/build machine, so it's under a pretty write-heavy load all the time. I expected it to last 3 months. It has not died (yet).
- bmicraft 5y agoI've always used Sandisk cards with A1/A2 rating (high iops) since they exist and I've yet to run into a single problem with them. Cards without that rating otoh ...
- fmlp 5y agoI've just ssh'ed a remote rpi with sdcard and logging active (Devuan stable) and it's uptime is almost 2 years. The sdcard in it probably has a year more there.
- jmuguy 5y agoMy understanding is that SD cards have a certain write count before they fail (or require a reformat), and that eMMC doesn't. Or that the number of writes before failure is much higher. Is that not correct? Regardless, I understand that hardware dies. But generally speaking I'd like to be able to deploy a single board system and not have to worry about having to physically maintain it unless it literally fails for some reason.
- zozbot234 5y agoeMMC is flash media, typically with a very minimalist FTL. Of course it's going to have a write count.
- OldHand2018 5y agoYes, exactly: Tesla found this out the hard way.