5 ms·
"Let me tell you from personal experience, these people are doing more harm to their children than good." The problem is that the science clearly says the oppo
by Alex3917 15y ago
"Let me tell you from personal experience, these people are doing more harm to their children than good."
The problem is that the science clearly says the opposite:
"At the end of 14 months, core ADHD symptoms were reduced more in the children treated with stimulants than with behavioral therapy. However, at the end of three years, 'medication use was a significant marker not of beneficial outcome, but of deterioration. That is, participants using medication in the 24-to-36 month period actually showed increased symptomatology during that interval relative to those not taking medication.'"
http://www.madinamerica.com/madinamerica.com/Children_files/3-year%20followup%20of%20the%20NIMH%20MTA%20Study.PDF http://www.madinamerica.com/madinamerica.com/Children_files/...
"At the end of six years, medication use was 'associated with worse hyperactivity-impulsivity and oppositional defiant disorder symptoms,' and with greater 'overall functional impairment.'"
http://www.madinamerica.com/madinamerica.com/Children_files/Mta%20at%208%20years.PDF http://www.madinamerica.com/madinamerica.com/Children_files/...
"Within 21 months, 11 percent of children treated with a stimulant for ADHD developed 'psychotic symptoms.'"
http://www.madinamerica.com/madinamerica.com/Children_files/Psychotic%20side%20effects%20of%20stimulants.pdf http://www.madinamerica.com/madinamerica.com/Children_files/...
"Two-thirds of the adolescent patients hospitalized for mania at the University of Cincinnati Medical Center had been on stimulants 'prior to the onset of an affective episode.' Stimulants, the researchers concluded, may 'precipitate depression and/or mania in children who would not have otherwise developed bipolar disorder.'"
http://www.madinamerica.com/madinamerica.com/Children_files/Prior%20stimulant%20treatment%20in%20adolescents%20with%20bipolar%20disorder_%20association%20with%20age%20at%20onset.pdf http://www.madinamerica.com/madinamerica.com/Children_files/...
via http://www.madinamerica.com/madinamerica.com/Children.html http://www.madinamerica.com/madinamerica.com/Children.html
- tomlin 15y agoIf we're getting into a debate of whether medications can have other effects than intended, I cannot argue that. ADHD and ADD should be treated in completely different ways. People diagnosed with ADHD have a much higher chance of psychotic symptoms than those who are only of the inattentive type. Then there is the old saying, "if you've seen one child with ADHD, you've seen one child with ADHD." In my experience, and for many others, it has provided a world untold, halted depression, increased motivation and enjoyment in life. Stimulants aren't perfect, but we're throwing the baby out with the bath water when we ignore their usefulness.
- Alex3917 15y agoWhat you're experiencing now is called the honeymoon period. You can go Google for what people on r/drugs have written about their experiences with this, or you can just wait to find out on your own. edit: http://www.reddit.com/r/Drugs/comments/excne/advice_needed_how_do_doctors_typically_deal_with/ http://www.reddit.com/r/Drugs/comments/excne/advice_needed_h...
- tomlin 15y agoIt may be my honeymoon period, but plenty of others who are well past their honeymoon period and still enjoying the benefits of stimulants. Again, it's not a perfect drug, but it works if you use it as a tool and not as a silver bullet.
- Rexatron 15y agoYour experience is yours. How long have you been on medication? What medication specifically? I've heard that some new meds are not stimulant. They might be good. But the old Ritalin/Adderall stimulants have quite possibly caused the psychotic symptoms you are talking about. That's what they do. Are you familiar with street meth? Ritlain/Adderall are pharma grade long duration forms of that. They have made me crazy before. And they don't "Halt Depression" they get you so busy you that you won't reflect on yourself. Artificial increases in motivation are silly. If you aren't inspired on your own to do something, you probably should be doing something else. Stimulants are much less than perfect and throwing out a pharma grade street drug with the bath water is fine with me. It's drugs or it's not. There are ways to handle ADD/ADHD without drugs. Change the environment. Forcing kids to take meth is just wrong.
- true_religion 15y agoIf you're willing to throw out a "pharma grade street drug" then wouldn't you be willing to throw out any pharma-grade drugs that are used directly on the street such as codeine, morphine, Valium, Vicodin, and any other broad spectrum pain reliever.
- true_religion 15y agoI don't have time for a full rebuttal, and it may well be true that medication is a worse approach to ADHD treatment than behavioral therapy. However, I want to point out by example that science is not true that "science clearly says" this. --- 1. "At the end of 14 months, core ADHD symptoms were reduced more in the children treated with stimulants than with behavioral therapy. However, at the end of three years, 'medication use was a significant marker not of beneficial outcome, but of deterioration. That is, participants using medication in the 24-to-36 month period actually showed increased symptomatology during that interval relative to those not taking medication.'" If you actually look at the data, it shows that all participants (behavioral, combined therapy, medication only) showed marked improvement at the end of 14 months, then deterioration from the 14 month improvement at 36 months. In conclusion, all participants showed improvement at 36 months versus their scores at the start of the study. Additionally, they found that a number of participants who begun in the the medication group stopped using their medication after 14 months (down from 90% at 14 months to 70% at 24-36 months). Whilst, on the converse members from even the behavioral and community care group begun to use medication through out the study (up to 40% in the behavioral group. 60% in the CC group). Their conclusion says it best: "It would be incorrect to conclude from these results that treatment makes no difference or is not worth pursuing.... medication management-may only make a persistent long term difference if it is continued with the same intensity as during the MTA's initial 14 month period". ---- 2. "At the end of six years, medication use was 'associated with worse hyperactivity-impulsivity and oppositional defiant disorder symptoms,' and with greater 'overall functional impairment.'" As compared to whom? -------- 3. "Within 21 months, 11 percent of children treated with a stimulant for ADHD developed 'psychotic symptoms.'" ADHD is usually treated at the same age when psychosis is first diagnosed. It could be that ADHD symptoms are positively correlated with psychosis. A close reading of the paper might actually provide that data. Even if the side-effect does exist to some degree that does not mean that it is "clear" that the drug isn't beneficial especially considering the 89% of children that didn't experience this side effect. Traditionally, what is done is more work into identifying those who could suffer from damaging side effects early and shunting them out of a medication program. ---- That's about all I can do now, but essentially there is no indication that stimulant medication is wholly poor performing and that early studies indicating efficacy were flawed. What there is is evidence that side-effects exist, and preliminary investigation into the degree and distribution of those side-effects. Additionally there is strong evidence that medication use is variable amongst participants versus other drugs for chronic conditions where drug use is sustained.
- roel_v 15y ago"via http://www.madinamerica.com/madinamerica.com/Children.html http://www.madinamerica.com/madinamerica.com/Children.html Please, a few cherry-picked quotes from the site of a journalist with no medical qualifications whatsoever who has made a career out of crusading against psychology in general. I have a couple of links to sites that will prove how smoking is in no way or form related to lung cancer, or how God will punish all us sinners who don't support executing gays, would you like to read them too?
- RandalMolek 15y agoI'll address just one part of this. It may seem a bit counter-intuitive, but stimulant therapy actually reduces problems with substance abuse for those diagnosed with ADHD. This is because people with ADHD are already at great risk for developing comorbid substance use disorder. http://pediatrics.aappublications.org/content/111/1/179.full?SEARCHID=1041880066942_4290&hits=10&VOLUME=111&ISSUE=1&gca=111%252F1%252F179&gca=111%252F1%252F97&FIRSTINDEX=0&FULLTEXT=stimulant&sendit=Get+All+Checked+Abstract(s)& http://pediatrics.aappublications.org/content/111/1/179.full...; Any time you expose a person to stimulants there is a risk that they can develop mania, addiction, etc. However people with ADHD are already doomed in this regard, and avoiding treatment for this reason is foolish. Also, I should disclose my bias, I'm diagnosed ADHD-pi, and a stimulant non-responder.