4 ms·
> which combines proportional representation in a 1st round No it doesn't. The french parliament is elected in 577 single member constituencies by a 2 round s
by cabalamat 5y ago
> which combines proportional representation in a 1st round
No it doesn't.
The french parliament is elected in 577 single member constituencies by a 2 round system: in the 1st round, voters vote for any candidate.
If no candidate wins >50% of all the votes in that constituency, a 2nd round is held, where candidates that came 1st or 2nd or got >12.5% of the vote, in the 1st round, can run.
Thus the French 2 round system is similar to Instant Runoff Voting, except that it isn't instant.
As an example of how the French system isn't proportional, En Marche got 32% of 1st-round votes but 61% of seats.
> for the powerful presidency
Presidential elections, like any other election that elects 1 candidate cannot in principle be proportional, because each party must either win 100% or 0% of the candidates elected.
> When it became clear that the far-right would be the largest single party
No, the National Front only got 13.2% of 1st round votes (and only ended up winning 8 seats, 1.4% of the total). They were nowhere near being the biggest party.
- dragonwriter 5y ago> Presidential elections, like any other election that elects 1 candidate cannot in principle be proportional Sure they can, and any system in which a majority of first-preferences guarantees a win is proportional for a one-seat body. Proportionality doesn't say a whole lot for a single-seat election, though.