4 ms·
Airships would have greatest utility on long trans-oceanic travel. Virtually all continental travel would be far better suited to rail. But could trains tackl
by dredmorbius 5y ago
Airships would have greatest utility on long trans-oceanic travel. Virtually all continental travel would be far better suited to rail. But could trains tackle the oceans? Maybe. I'm increasingly thinking that an intercontinental rail network would be more viable than trying to resurrect airships.
It's possible to build a continuous rail link from the south of Africa to the British Isles, Siberia, and Malaysia.
Tunelling across the Bering Strait would be within reason for an Asian-American link.
Crossing the Atlantic is appealing as population centres are closer to both coast, though sea distances are greater. One possible answer might be a "floating tunnel", of the type envisioned for use in crossing Norway's fjords. Suspended from buouys and anchored to the seafloor, at a depth of about 30m, muliple bores could carry passenger and freight rail traffic. One possible route might extend from Scotland via Iceland and Greenland to the Labrador coastline.
For the floating tunnel concept, see:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Submerged_floating_tunnel https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Submerged_floating_tunnel
Transit times might range from 15 hours (at about 240 kph / 150 mph) to as little as 2.5 hours in a hyperloop-like evacuated tube at 1600 kph / 1,000 mph. The former is about a quarter the speed of present-day jet airliners, making short day excursions between continents infeasible but allowing for an overnight "hotel train" or working daytime trips. At higher speeds, service is comparable to present aircraft, and at the (admittedly unlikely) extremes, several times faster.
Similar crossings could be reasonably be made to Indonesia and on to Australia, crossing from Singapore, then to West Java and Timor Leste, and across the Timor sea to Darwin. A southern Atlantic crossing between Recife and Monrovia might also be possible.
There are of course formidible costs and risks. But the technology and routes are at least within the realm of possibility.
A north-Atlantic rail crossing was amongst the concepts mooted in a BBC piece some years back:
https://www.bbc.com/news/magazine-23969607 https://www.bbc.com/news/magazine-23969607
A more complete proposal is in this 2004 PopSci article:
https://www.popsci.com/scitech/article/2004-04/trans-atlantic-maglev/ https://www.popsci.com/scitech/article/2004-04/trans-atlanti...
- LargoLasskhyfv 5y agoI like your thinking. Let me explain mine. From a purely logical point of view, maybe something like playing Sim City, Civilization, or other infratructure building Sims this would make sense. In peace time, and if all players were like Spock, or of the same hive mind. Because like the BBC and Popular Science articles you linked this could be much more by co-bundling pipelines of all sorts (DATA!) with it, maybe even part of a global HVDC smart grid. The costs shouldn't really matter, compared to the money the military (No matter which) burns. It could also be the enabler of (environmentally responsible?) aquafarming, seasteading, nodes of wave- and offshore wind energy farming which would branch off from it. You'd need many platforms for security, emergency and maintenance reasons along the way anyways. But it would be very vulnerable and probably protested for all sorts of business and political reasons. Just look at what happens with proposed pipelines, high-speed rails, the bitching about where to put stations, the NIMBYism about where not, and so on. In this case there could be less NIMBYism, because open-seas, but think of the ship builders, and the giant complex of companies operating the built ships. Wouldn't you think they object to that? Just look at what ferry operators did when some tunnel or bridge opened, making them obsolete. So we have them, and their interests, against a potential network of submerged floating tunnels enabling all sorts of nice things, making them almost obsolete, too. Similar for Aerospace. 500kph seems doable without vacuum. Half the speed of air-traffic. 350 to 400 kph even more so, and already IS in operation at 350. Now imagine freight trains running at 250 to 300kph on separate tracks. Which you would want to have anyways, if only as reserve/backup for maintenance reasons. And now imagine a grid of these. Criss-crossing the seven seas, and having transport-hubs/nodes, switching yards, resort cities, free towns, permanent in-situ sensors, whatever, out there. Can't have pirates though, or war. What do you think about that? edit: I'd opt for smelting all the container giants, bulk carriers, and similarly obsolete stuff to build this. With nuclear power, if need be. I don't care. The same for most airplanes, because less noise. Seawards, Ho!
- kwhitefoot 5y agoShades of Harry Harrison's A Transatlantic Tunnel, Hurrah! (aka Tunnel Through the Deeps)
- dredmorbius 5y agoI just ran across a reference to that. Apparently also a 1935 film: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Tunnel_(1935_film) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Tunnel_(1935_film)