6 ms·
>https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Potato_paradox https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Potato_paradox The Wikipedia link above says: > Fred brings home 100 kg of potatoe
by lotsofpulp 5y ago
>https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Potato_paradox https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Potato_paradox
The Wikipedia link above says:
> Fred brings home 100 kg of potatoes, which (being purely mathematical potatoes) consist of 99% water. He then leaves them outside overnight so that they consist of 98% water. What is their new weight? The surprising answer is 50 kg.
It annoys me when mass is used interchangeably with force (weight), so I went to the Wikipedia source, and the source is accurate in using units of force throughout.
https://web.archive.org/web/20140202214723/http://www.daviddarling.info/encyclopedia/P/potato_paradox.html https://web.archive.org/web/20140202214723/http://www.davidd...
Wonder why the person that wrote the Wikipedia article changed it up when it is supposed to be a direct quote.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- jgtrosh 5y agoIn this situation, the mass and weight are proportional and irrelevant to the problem. Other than proper respect of units, why would it really matter? I would agree that using mass+kg would remain correct and be less unusual, but it doesn't matter a lot.
- lotsofpulp 5y agoIt does not matter, it is just a pet peeve of mine. Might be due psychological trauma from when I was a kid and arguing with an older cousin about how pounds and kilograms are not units of the same thing, and the older cousin "winning" the argument in the eyes of the elders because the cousin was quite a few years older than me and considered to be smart in school.
- version_five 5y agoFrom what I remember from intro physics, we distinguished between pounds and pounds force, the latter having the 32ft/s^2 multiplied in. And wikipedia seems to agree with me, see pound (mass) vs pound (force).
- lotsofpulp 5y agoOh wow, learning a lot today. I was taught in the US that pounds are a measure of force, and that is how it was always used in physics problems.
- tharkun__ 5y agoAs a European I learned in metric. When I first learned pounds, it was as the imperial system's equivalent of grams and a conversion factor was given. Force in physics class was taught in Newtons (kg*m/s^2).
- kergonath 5y agoPounds as a mass unit are perverse enough. Things like pound force and psi (pounds per square inch) were used only to make fun of old mechanics papers and textbooks. Also, btu. It is quite amazing actually that someone would see the SI and think “no, too simple; I’ll keep my pounds, ounces, inches, and feet”. Anyway, yes, the proper unit of force is the Newton.
- version_five 5y agoI think there is some weird dual usage that makes them either mass or weight depending on the context. For example, torque is in ft•lbs or N•m so the pounds there are lbs force. Though checking wikipedia again, it actually specifies that torque is measured in as lbf•ft. I take that to mean that 1 ft•lb is the torque of 1/2 oz (1/32 of an lb) at 1 foot. I expect that's a test question almost everyone would get wrong, myself included. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pound-foot_(torque) https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pound-foot_(torque)
- stan_rogers 5y agoThink like an ordinary person. You know, an ordinary person who would say that they weigh about 80 kilograms. Only science nerds would say that they mass about 80 kilograms, or that they weigh about 785 Newtons. Similarly, anyone who's used to living with US customary (or Imperial) units understands that a pound of force is what a pound of mass weighs and would see no reason, under any circumstances, why anyone would want to divide the gravitational acceleration out of a pound-foot to arrive at a "real" torque value. When the pound value is expressing a weight-equivalent force, that force is the force of a pound under normal gravitational acceleration at or near the surface of the Earth.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Scarblac 5y agoTo me (Netherlands) a pound is simply 0.5kg. Force is expressed in Newton.
- mint2 5y agoI really don’t like that example because it makes no sense. In no logical circumstance could the potatoes dehydrate so quickly when left out over a single night.
- tharkun__ 5y agoAnd they also don't consist of 99% water. That is why they called them "purely mathematical potatoes" and they could've chosen any type of fruit or vegetable. Heck, I'm just waiting for a car analogy now! Brake fluid anyone?
- mint2 5y agoBut that 99% water simplification is needed for the purpose of the exercise. The left out overnight is basically an absurd statement that is intended to confuse and not really related to the actual question. The statement could be “left in a dry environment until” or simply “left to dry a few weeks”
- tharkun__ 5y agoYou definitely could write that but it wouldn't change anything and you could make the same "argument" you are making now. "The left to dry a few weeks is basically an absurd statement that is intended to confuse" and it still wouldn't be true. It's not intended to confuse at all. It's intended to get the point across that you let this imaginary thing dry from 99% to 98%. They could've said "sponge" and let it out to dry any number of minutes. The point isn't to make a 100% accurate example of the drying properties of any actual 'thing'. They just needed something that people intuitively know "has water content" and that "can dry".
- mint2 5y agoWow by the downvotes I learned people react extremely negatively to any critique of math word problems. Spherical cows and 99% water potatoes are fine, those over simplifications are required for the analysis. Saying Leaving the potatoes out overnight to imply they halved in mass, sounds as reasonable as “the potatoes were in the ground for 12 hours and then doubled in amount, what percent of water are they now?” It’s so gratuitous and requires ignoring all other laws of physics, while the goal of the spherical cow type simplification is to only ignore a few key challenging ones.
- syncsynchalt 5y ago> Wonder why the person that wrote the Wikipedia article changed it up when it is supposed to be a direct quote. They likely changed it from lb to kg because that would be more friendly to an international audience, without realizing that lb is a measure of weight and kg is a measure of mass. Therefore they didn't know to change "weight" to "mass".
- lotsofpulp 5y agoOh yes, that would make sense.
- kergonath 5y agoI have been to the US quite regularly, and been living in the UK for a number of years, and I have never seen someone using pounds as a unit of force instead of a unit of mass meaning roughly 500g, give or take. Second meaning was about 1.20€. FWIW, the pound is a proper unit of mass: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pound_(mass) https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pound_(mass) .
- syncsynchalt 5y agoI'm a civil engineer. In statute terms pound is the unit of force and slug is the unit of mass. That might have colored my thinking.
- sbakzbsmx 5y agoThe difference between weight and mass is domain specific to physics. I actually get annoyed at people who are pedantic about these things. Precision is important in some conversations, but just elitist in other. Anyway, the term “weight” to refer to mass outdates its use as a force - its only since Newton that we distinguish the two, after all.
- p1necone 5y agoYou're being overly pedantic (and I would argue actually incorrect). Kilograms and pounds are both referred to as "weight" in general conversation and nobody is going to be confused by this. Go to any supermarket in a country that uses the metric system, potatoes will be sold by the kilogram - it's the natural way to phrase this outside of America. In a physics context the definition of kilogram might be specifically mass, with newtons referring to weight/force. But words can have different meanings outside of technical contexts. If you go to a metric country, and ask someone how much they "weigh", approximately zero people will say "x newtons", they will say "x kilograms" (or "x pounds" still in a lot of commonwealth countries if we're being pedantic).
- p1necone 5y agoAlthough the more I think about this the more I think the difference between technical and colloquial is actually that "weight" in colloquial use refers to mass, because force is not commonly relevant.
- eru 5y agoYes, in colloquial use weight refers to mass _most_ of the time. But can also refer to inertia or mass. Or be used metaphorically.
- jacobolus 5y ago"Weight" historically referred to mass, in common speech dating back forever. It’s the Germanic word which has been used throughout the history of English, whereas "mass" comes from Latin via French, like 5–6 centuries ago. The two words are almost exact synonyms, in historical/colloquial use. Both historically and today, a "pound" (Roman libra) is a unit of mass. People use a pound-force as a unit of force only in somewhat specialized contexts. At some point in the relatively recent past, someone (not sure who) decided that we needed to have 2 separate words for mass vs. force, and we should keep the Latin word for mass and use the Germanic word to mean force. Now pedantic people are constantly insisting that using the standard English word weight to mean mass is "wrong".
- menotyou 5y agoWhen I buy potatoes I am interested to buy 10 kg mass of potatoes, not the amount or potatoes of which has a gravity force of 98,1N. On mars you need to eat 10 kg of potatoes a week, not the amount of which has 98,1N gravity force. The scales in the supermarket on earth automatically convert the weight into mass for my convenience by applying a constant factor of 1/9,81. I am hardly far away enough from earth that the constant changed, so I did not need to distinguish between the two measures so far. When carrying the potatoes home I just use the mass of 10 kg as a proxy for the force I need. And to determine the increased breaking distance of my car, I need to know the mass again.