4 ms·
Another industry in need of carbon taxes. Stuff like bitcoin would be a lot more palatable if its users paid for the externalities they saddle upon everyone els
by asdff 5y ago
Another industry in need of carbon taxes. Stuff like bitcoin would be a lot more palatable if its users paid for the externalities they saddle upon everyone else from their carbon usage.
- paisawalla 5y agoExternalities like that should be priced into the utility bill. In CA, you will see steep overages when you reach the upper tiers of utilization.
- sdenton4 5y agoAh, but with an unregulated decentralized heat-generator, I'm free to look around for the country which doesn't tax the externalities, and thus has the cheapest utility bill. California isn't where most of the crypto mining is happening...
- anonporridge 5y agoBitcoin is just a convenient scapegoat for people to hate on and feel like they have the moral high ground, all while they eat a high meat diet, drive single occupant cars daily, take regular domestic flights and occasional international flights, and live in McMansions with AC 6 months out of the year. Our entire lifestyles in the developed world are horrifically carbon heavy. Beating up on things like bitcoin without addressing the actual problem of oil subsidies and the lack of carbon taxes is a waste of political capital that will set back actual effective climate action by years or decades. We can't afford to waste that time.
- sdenton4 5y agoFWIW, I opted out of children, eat a vegetarian diet, have never had a driver's license, and generally put on a sweater before reaching for the thermostat. And I will happily claim my two inches of my moral high-ground to say f$ck bitcoin.
- asdff 5y agoSo what if other industries are also polluting? That's not a great excuse. Tax it all imo. Once you have a mechanism to quantify and tax carbon usage it wouldn't be hard to expand it to other industries. In the mean time airline tickets will be costly and within a couple of years you will see freight operators laying down electrified double track along their right of ways in order to capture demand for regional passenger transit at a lower price. The market will reshape to capture the most profit it can given the regulatory environment that it resides in. This is the point of these taxes, you force paradigm shifts that ultimately benefit the species as a whole at the cost of perhaps only a few quarters of poor profits for major corporations.
- anonporridge 5y ago> Tax it all imo. That's exactly what I'm saying. Getting tunnel vision on cryptocurrency is totally missing the point. Even if all cryptocurrnecies disappeared tomorrow, nothing would fundamentally change and our civilization would still be hopelessly unsustainable. The solution to carbon pollution has to apply to all forms of our consumption, or it won't actually matter in the long run.
- sdenton4 5y agoLet's throw in a ransomware tax, while we're at it.
- fleddr 5y agoWhilst I'm pro Bitcoin, I think a carbon tax is an excellent idea, and a fair idea. Miners already are self regulating to a degree by increasingly mining using renewables and where possible, stranded renewables (excess remote energy). This isn't really seen by the media as they love to make a story out of a very dirty exception, like an old coal plant. However, it's very hard to get a holistic view of this progress. I recently read a pretty credible article that completely undermines the conclusion of this HN article. It stated that Bitcoin's energy mix is 3 times greener than most other industries. Whom to believe? I don't know. Back on point, a carbon tax makes the green incentive hard, instead an optional moral consideration.