4 ms·
It's not even half as bizarre as someone buying a GIF of some cartoon cats as a sort of cryptocurrency token.
by kazinator 5y ago
It's not even half as bizarre as someone buying a GIF of some cartoon cats as a sort of cryptocurrency token.
- JadeNB 5y ago> It's not even half as bizarre as someone buying a GIF of some cartoon cats as a sort of cryptocurrency token. I think it is considerably more bizarre. People have always done strange things with their money; NFTs have made it maybe more visible, and have certainly dressed it up in new tech-y buzzwords, but they've hardly introduced the idea of spending money in strange and stupid ways. But I am considerably more upset about whole countries' economies being founded on strange and stupid decisions than I am on individuals making such decisions. (Which is not to say that I could, or know how to, do any better; we're just comparing bizarre-ness, not solutions.)
- panarky 5y ago> I think it is considerably more bizarre It's only bizarre when you believe that money is a concrete, tangible thing with unchanging intrinsic value. When you believe that then of course it seems wrong and unnatural to create new money out of thin air.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- kazinator 5y agoWe can see it as a form of taxation. Isn't the following approximately right: suppose that some country has a net worth of 10B (calculated somehow). The government decides that it needs some cash, so it prints another 10B of that currency and injects it into the system. Well, all it has done is devalue the currency by half, thereby looting half the economy of half its value, transferring that to the government. It's just a ploy to steal 5B by declaring it to be government property, which is possible since every instance of money is a tiny abstract contract which is controlled by the government's treasury/mint. It's like issuing new stock to raise cash, without any increase in the total market valuation, which nothing but a cash grab from the current share holders made possible by controlling the issuance of stock.
- bryanlarsen 5y agoThe coin is used to offset bonds. It's not increasing the money supply. The money supply is increased by government spending. The US economy grows by approximately $700B per year. (23T * 3%). Therefore as a first approximation the money supply needs to grow at approximately $700B per year. If the government deficit is less than that, it acts as a brake on the economy. When the government spends money, it buys stuff with that money. Whether that is inflationary depends on how rivalrous the spending is -- IOW if it's competing with private money for that stuff or it's buying stuff that nobody else would ever want to buy.
- jtbayly 5y agoWe're talking about the government, not some random idiot.
- Y_Y 5y agoYou can't buy a fucking gif! This fiction spread way too easily. All you're buying a token that mentions the gif. This gif itself lives on as if nothing had happened, just like if you bought a star.
- kazinator 5y agoBut in that particular token-buying ecosystem, nobody else can buy that gif. Unless they change a pixel value, or some bit of metadata. Suppose you actually approached the author of the gif, and bought the exclusive copyright to it, conventionally. The gif itself is still not affected any more by that transaction than of the non-fungible token purchase. Exact copies of it exist all over the place, shared by people who don't care about your copyright.
- WalterSear 5y agoAlso in that particular token-buying ecosystem, you can sell yourself the token representation of that gif multiple times, in order to fool people into thinking that there is a genuine market for the token corresponding to that gif.
- karmakaze 5y agoUnless you buy that exact gif on a different blockchain.
- mFixman 5y agoIt's as bizarre as the original Mona Lisa in the Louvre being about a billion dollars more expensive than an identical copy sold on the banks of the Seine.
- ceejayoz 5y agoBarring Star Trek level technology, it's not possible to make an identical copy of the Mona Lisa. That's part of why it's valuable.
- mFixman 5y agoWe can get very close, but even if we had technology to make an indistinguishable copy the original wouldn't fall in value and none of the copies would be near it. The Mona Lisa isn't valuable because it's a nice painting: it's valuable because of its history and meaning to the arts.