6 ms·
Don't even get me started (just take a shufti through my posting history on this very site. You'll see this is a subject that has my attention). > while the ex
by ChrisMarshallNY 5y ago
Don't even get me started (just take a shufti through my posting history on this very site. You'll see this is a subject that has my attention).
> while the experience that comes with age is valued in fields like music, it counts against you in tech.
Yup. The Jurassic-scale disasters that are becoming increasingly common, these days, are evidence of unsteady hands at the wheel.
I'm not saying that older folks are better. In many cases, we can be overconservative and overcautious, but that isn't such a bad thing, when the stakes for a blowout are so high.
I have always felt that tech needs to follow the same model as every other damn industry since the start of history, which is to have experience work with youth. They balance each other out.
I feel that when one of them gets too much power, Bad Things Happen.
In my case, I was finally laid off, after a 27-year run at one of the world's marquee imaging companies (which I think was overbalanced by experience). I started looking around for more work, as I wasn't really up for retirement (which I was quite capable of doing).
I was absolutely shocked at how shabbily I was treated, and fairly quickly gave up the search.
I find it offensive, that companies are so self-destructive; especially smaller companies, where a top-shelf employee could "make or break" the company. I have a fairly unique confluence of skills that would have made a startup very happy (I've been ARCHITECTING and SHIPPING software, since my very first engineering project, in 1987. I am quite used to production engineering. I've been doing it my entire adult life. I've heard that could be useful, to some companies). I was also quite willing to work for a lot less money than most, as my retirement was set, and I was looking for work that interested me.
Instead, I was rather quickly told -in no uncertain terms- "Go away, old man. No one wants you."
I took the hint, and found some non-profit folks that were doing work I find interesting, and started working with them, for free.
They are quite happy with my work.
- Icathian 5y agoYou post this all the time. You did 27 years at one single company, as you point out so proudly and often. After a stint like that, anyone would be unhireable. It isn't your age, as so many others on this chain have pointed out. You didn't build your CV to be attractive to new employers at all, and when eventually that became relevant again, you were out of luck. I read your posts whenever I see them, it's obvious you're quite bright. I really don't understand how you don't see this.
- Dumblydorr 5y agoWhy does doing 27 years at one company make someone unhireable? It's one thing if he used the same old tech for 27 years, but without that assumption, seems like ageism to say 27 years at one company is an obvious ground for disqualification.
- Icathian 5y agoAfter a thousand threads on why tech hiring is hard, I don't think I need to re-hash that getting signal from noise is complex and imperfect. Out of the two signals, "this person was successful at 8 different companies" versus "this person stuck in one place for almost three decades", which do you imagine is going to get hired? It isn't ageism, again go read the rest of this thread. It's the nature of making yourself an attractive candidate. If you don't care to play the game, you can't pout and cry "ageism" when you lose the game.
- tlamponi 5y ago> After a thousand threads on why tech hiring is hard, I don't think I need to re-hash that getting signal from noise is complex and imperfect. Out of the two signals, "this person was successful at 8 different companies" versus "this person stuck in one place for almost three decades", which do you imagine is going to get hired? One can also take this as: "this person jumps jobs often, everything I invest in them will probably have not a good/long ROI" vs. "this person was a loyal employee that was so good he was kept for decades" A few jumps surely do not hurt, are even good to get some different POVs and such, but if we get people that were barely one or two years at a company at max it always rings a few alarm bells. But, either way its generalization, the reasons for why either situation happened are relevant to make a sensible decision. I.e., the answer to "why switch so often?" or "why stuck for so long and why now?" are key.
- honkdaddy 5y ago> I.e., the answer to "why switch so often?" or "why stuck for so long and why now?" are key. This is really the key. As another anecdotal datapoint to add to this thread, I've held three SWE positions over the past four years and will be starting my fourth, at Google, next month. Naturally the recruiters and hiring managers asked about the short stints at each company, but given that my reasons for each departure were reasonable (company acquisition, COVID, and location), they didn't have any objections.
- gwbas1c 5y ago> In my case, I was finally laid off, after a 27-year run at one of the world's marquee imaging companies (which I think was overbalanced by experience). I started looking around for more work, as I wasn't really up for retirement (which I was quite capable of doing). Are you "out of practice" in the job search? This comment (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28758320 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28758320) states: > Delete the first 10 years of your work history and take the date off your CS degree > I started getting significantly more responses to applications and inquiries from recruiters on LinkedIn
- ChrisMarshallNY 5y agoI understand that. I also have gotten advice to dye my hair. I will do neither. That's dishonest. If no one values me for the skills and experience I have, then I have no interest in working with them (not "for," "with." -A big problem, in today's working world, is the attitude that companies are doing people a favor by hiring them. If someone hires me, they don't get me as a servant. I've worked way too long and hard to be treated that way. Another problem, is that asking for simple, basic, human respect, is considered "arrogant"). I am very, very honest. This was actually a big plus, at my last company. It got me a seat at the "inner table" of a highly conservative Japanese corporation; something few Westerners ever experience. I refuse to be dishonest. I won't hide my age, experience, or weaknesses. I also won't exaggerate. People often tell me that I'm exaggerating. Then, they take the time to look at my track record (which is very available -people like to lob insults before actually checking to see if they apply). Things get quiet, after that.
- honkdaddy 5y agoDo you think dying your hair is dishonest? I wear shoes with a bit of a lift because generally, at least in the west, taller men are treated a bit better in the workplace. Sure it's unfair, but it's certainly not going to change in my lifetime, so I happily play the game. I don't see dying your hair as any different from wearing makeup or attractive clothes. Humans are social and visual creatures, we find it easier to trust other humans we like the appearance of.
- jandrewrogers 5y agoThe kind of experience that ages well is operations and organizations i.e. knowing how to run the business, not technology. An advantage of having worked at many companies that can't be overstated is the exposure to many different ways of addressing myriad organizational and operational challenges in different business contexts in practice. My experience with technology 20 years ago is worthless. But my experience working in so many organizations and types of businesses is still extremely relevant -- humans don't change. This is where working at a single company for 27 years works against you, it implies a lack of the kind of experience that makes older individuals uniquely valuable. There is little generally applicable skill around architecting and shipping software; the practical constraints on how those things can be done are often wildly different across companies and industries. Bright and capable people that have spent decades at a single company often struggle to effectively adapt their skills to an entirely different company context. There is practically a meme about Microsoft lifers only being able to work with other Microsoft lifers in Seattle, for example, because empirically it has tended to be true. What you don't have is 27 years of experience applying your technical skills across very different organizational and operational contexts, and that is valuable experience that only years can provide. That isn't to say you can't, just that your experience doesn't provide much evidence of it. Anecdotally, as someone also getting up there in age, it has never been easier for me to find work.
- ChrisMarshallNY 5y agoWhat does "getting up there in age" mean? It has been my experience that the mid-thirties are kind of a "golden window" for senior-level talent. Some people think of it as "older," but not that many. We're old enough to have had the sharp edges worn away, but not yet old enough to make the management uncomfortable. Once we start getting into the 40s (or, heaven forbid, the 50s), attitudes start changing -drastically. It's -sort of- OK to be a manager, but not a critical path engineer. I will say that you seem to be an interesting chap, and I suspect that "the conventional rules" probably don't really apply to your work. Looks like fun. For me, I like to make stuff that people use. I'm not particularly interested in changing the world (although I have, for a particular demographic -long story). I like getting my hands dirty, and Usability/Accessibility/Localization is a big deal. I like to put simple faces on complicated backends, and open tech to as many folks as possible. Most folks hate "computers," so I try to "decomputerize" tech. It's fun; especially when I see people using my work. I consider myself to be more of a "craftsman," than a "scientist." It's a labor of Love; not just for my own satisfaction and work, but also for the users of my work. That's one reason I like working with an NPO. My whole family has been in Service, of one kind or another. My younger brother and I are the "redneck engineers." The rest of the family is a bit more Ivy League. My younger brother used to run group homes for kids that are wards of the state. He burned out on that, and became an engineer. He's worked at his [Fortune 20] company for over 20 years. It's a pretty big deal. He's self-taught, like me. I was reading an article that said that age-compensating plastic surgery is very common in Silicon Valley, and that most patients prefer having the procedure done on a Friday, so they can heal over the weekend, and probably get away with it not being obvious when they get back to work. New York's ageism problem (although many don't believe that it's a "problem," at all) is much more pronounced than SV (especially in Brooklyn). I'm wondering if a reason might be that NY has been a tech hub for a far shorter period of time, and we haven't had a "critical mass" of engineers "age out," yet. I stopped going to (very good, and very energetic) NY meetups, a long time ago. It's abundantly clear that my just being there, is unnerving to a lot of folks. As I walk around the room, a big clear space automatically happens around me; like I'm in the eye of a hurricane. It's pretty obvious that I'm not usually a welcome addition to the milieux. And that's all before I even open my mouth. People don't seem actively hostile; but they avoid me. I don't get dirty looks. In fact, I don't seem to get eye contact at all. Absolutely no one introduces themselves to me. I'm fairly affable, and have no problem reaching out to others. When I do that, we often have a good chat (although some, I can see, are looking for the exits). Surprisingly, I often find that the people who avoid me the most, are the older members of the crowd. That's interesting. I can have some great chats with younger folks. I never try being "down with the kids," and I know better than to do an "OK boomer" thing. I'm a fairly good listener, and ask questions designed to encourage folks to talk about themselves, and their passions. That usually works well with younger folks.