8 ms·
Estimated 216,000 children abused by French Catholic priests, report finds
- drKarl 5y agoAnd that's just in France, think worlwide and think through history...
- webmobdev 5y agoYou don't have to imagine it, it's a fact: 1. Every fourth pedophilia suspect in Poland is a priest, state commission reveals: https://www.rt.com/news/530345-poland-priest-pedophilia-church/ https://www.rt.com/news/530345-poland-priest-pedophilia-chur... 2. Royal commission: Seven per cent of Australian Catholic priests accused of abuse: https://web.archive.org/web/20181212044835/https://catholicherald.co.uk/news/2017/02/06/royal-commission-seven-per-cent-of-australian-catholic-priests-accused-of-abuse/ https://web.archive.org/web/20181212044835/https://catholich... 3. UK Catholic Church sorry for abuse by priests: https://www.thehindu.com/news/international/UK-Catholic-Church-sorry-for-abuse-by-priests/article16371795.ece https://www.thehindu.com/news/international/UK-Catholic-Chur... 4. Irish church and police covered up child sex abuse, says report: https://www.theguardian.com/world/2009/nov/26/ireland-church-sex-abuse https://www.theguardian.com/world/2009/nov/26/ireland-church... 5. The global scale of child sexual abuse in the Catholic Church: https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2021/10/5/awful-truth-child-sex-abuse-in-the-catholic-church https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2021/10/5/awful-truth-child-s...
- javagram 5y agohttps://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/do-the-right-thing/201003/six-myths-about-clergy-sexual-abuse-in-the-catholic-church https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/do-the-right-thing/2... Note also > 4 percent of Catholic priests in the U.S. sexually victimized minors during the past half century. No evidence has been published at this time which states this number is higher than clergy from other religious traditions. The 4 percent figure appears lower than school teachers during the same time frame, and certainly less than offenders in the general population of men. Research states that over 20 percent of American women and about 15 percent of American men were sexually violated by an adult when they were children.
- jliptzin 5y agoWhy anyone would continue to support the Catholic Church -much less bring their children there - is totally astounding to me
- WinstonSmith84 5y agoYep - France doesn't even represent 1% of the worldwide population ...
- webmobdev 5y agoGiven the prolific pedophilia in the Catholic church, revealed in so many countries around the world, I am absolutely convinced that there is an active and thriving pedophilia club in the Catholic church / Vatican. There is no other explanation of why these priests are allowed to continue in service, while churches use coercion and or bribes of thousands to millions of dollars to buy silence from the victims! And yes, I know about the whole concept of forgiveness / acceptance that is ingrained in the catholic belief system that is used to explain why pedophile priests are given a "second" chance. I understand it. But the way it is practiced is flawed - why are pedophile priests allowed to continue in service? Condemn the sin, not the person, forgive them, accept them into the community - but why cover up the crimes and let them continue to be priests? Spirituality and theology apart, at some point the nature of the disease shouldn't be ignored. We don't encourage an alcoholic to become bartender, do we? It is this insistence of the church to allow pedophiles continue as priests that absolutely convinces me that there is a very active lobby of pedophiles in the Catholic church / Vatican, who find comfort in the secretive community they have formed. We have seen how the internet nurtures echo chambers in its social media. It is easy to accept that an actual community or club of paedophiles within the Catholic church would find similar benefits and solidarity from other "understanding" members, and why they would attract such kind. It isn't at all surprising to learn that every fourth pedophilia suspect in Poland is a priest ( https://www.rt.com/news/530345-poland-priest-pedophilia-church/ https://www.rt.com/news/530345-poland-priest-pedophilia-chur... ).
- rich_sasha 5y agoI can see why you're getting downvoted, but sadly (as a Catholic-sort of) I think you're right. It now seems to me that the Catholic Church's hierarchy is catastrophically flawed. I see this as quite separate from lay Catholics, who somehow aren't outraged by all this, but I guess more due to cognitive deficits than actual acceptance. Catholic Church has an intransparent, rigid hierarchy built on secrecy and obedience, and apparently severely lacking in the morals department. It has a lot of trust and a high cross-section for interaction with the general public (in Catholic countries at least), in particular children. Celibacy (a social, not biblical concept), probably doesn't help. In Poland, which you quote, the majority of priests found to be sex offenders against children, were not found to have paedophilic tendencies in subsequent psychiatric evaluations, rather chose children as easy victims. Controlling for all these features, I remain unconvinced that there is something particularly wrong about religion itself in this organisation. Abuse of children and other weaker members of the society has sadly been a hallmark of large organisations (e.g. abuse by Oxfam employees in Haiti), it's just that most organisations lack either the reach, or the rigid structure of CC. As an aside, I wouldn't use Russia Today as a source for anything meaningful, certainly not when it's about Poland; if ever there was an axe to grind, surely it's there.
- funOtter 5y ago> The report found an _estimated_ 216,000 children were victims of sexual violence by French Catholic priests, deacons and other clergy from 1950 to 2020. When lay members of the Church, such as teachers and catechism supervisors, were included, the figure rose to at least 330,000 children sexually abused over 70 years. How did they do this estimation? The article does not say.
- programLyrique 5y agoThey asked Ifop, a polling institute, to do a survey. The survey used a representative sample of 28 000 French people (in French, https://www.lefigaro.fr/actualite-france/les-cinq-chiffres-cles-du-rapport-sauve-sur-les-abus-sexuels-dans-l-eglise-catholique-20211005 https://www.lefigaro.fr/actualite-france/les-cinq-chiffres-c... )
- Jedd 5y agoIt sounds like the 2500 page report has been released to the press, but not yet publicly available. Are you contending that the numbers are unreasonably high or low?
- C19is20 5y agoRemember, this is just france, not a worldwide guesstimate. Fucking sadly.
- cowanon22 5y agoFirst off, I'm not doubting that abuse occurred and it is terrible for the victims involved. What sampling method did they use to arrive at this estimate? What is the error range and 95/99% confidence intervals? I haven't been able to find the original report online. From some articles: The commission found evidence of 2,900 to 3,200 abusers – out of a total of 115,000 priests and other clerics – but said this was probably an underestimation. We would really need to see what the method they used to arrive at the numbers - this smells like major hyperbole. UPDATE: a better article is available in French: https://www.lefigaro.fr/actualite-france/les-cinq-chiffres-cles-du-rapport-sauve-sur-les-abus-sexuels-dans-l-eglise-catholique-20211005 https://www.lefigaro.fr/actualite-france/les-cinq-chiffres-c... The number they gave is cases over 70 years, which is a weird way of reporting it. Annually, it is about 2900-3000 priests per year. The article also mention that the current rate in about 1/4 of the rate in the 1970's, showing that some of the church reforms have actually worked. If you compare the French stats to what is being reported here, the anti-church media bias is flagrantly clear.
- littlestymaar 5y ago> the anti-church media bias is flagrantly clear. Most articles I have read today on that topic (in the French media) were talking about an “historic moment” and praising the church for recognizing the problem, admitting failure and starting such a study. Far from anti-church speech…
- cowanon22 5y agoI'm referring to the US media - they covered it very differently from the French media.
- hnmullany 5y ago5.6% is the estimated historical incidence rate for pedophile priests in the US. 7% of Australian priests have face accusation - so incidence would be a little lower. The pope was reported as saying 2% - but the interview in which this happened was walked back by the Vatican. 2-3% would be on the low end. I'm surprised that you would consider this hyperbole after the endless revelations over the last two decades.
- wolframhempel 5y agoHm - so you're telling me that taking thousands of men, forbidding them from having sex, having them share their lives with young boys in secluded locations, and creating a protective organization around them with its own legal system lead to widespread sexual abuse? Crazy...
- ashtonkem 5y agoYou’re not wrong, but there is some evidence that child abuse is common among Protestant churches too, and those are structured quite differently. https://stopabusecampaign.org/2018/01/08/is-there-more-sexual-abuse-in-the-protestant-churches-than-the-catholic-church/ https://stopabusecampaign.org/2018/01/08/is-there-more-sexua... It’s also worth pointing out that child abuse happens in a lot of non-religious settings too. The Catholic Church has a problem, but in no way should we understand child sexual abuse as a uniquely catholic issue.
- eurasiantiger 5y agoAre we counting humiliation, gaslighting and brainwashing as child abuse? Asking because those are really common in religious families and often seen as normal ways of teaching a child.
- ashtonkem 5y agoI would also consider that a problem, but a distinct one from the discussion of child sexual abuse.
- wolframhempel 5y ago> It’s also worth pointing out that child abuse happens in a lot of non-religious settings too. The Catholic Church has a problem, but in no way should we understand child sexual abuse as a uniquely catholic issue. ...that's of course fair - but the Catholic church is to my knowledge the only one that does it on such a systemic level and gathered so much experience over time in controlling information flows, silencing victims and protecting the abusers.
- sandworm101 5y ago"While the commission found evidence of as many as 3,200 abusers - out of a total of 115,000 priests and other clerics - it said this was probably an underestimation." https://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-58801183 https://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-58801183
- Huffers2 5y ago216,000 sounds like a lot. Does that make French Catholic priests more or less likely historically to be abusers than the average adult male? Can't get outraged until I find out.
- necrotic_comp 5y agoWhat are you trying to say ? It seems like you're making some sideways comment about "the media", but I'd really like you to spell it out.
- Huffers2 5y agoJust that an article saying "group did evil thing X times" doesn't say anything good or bad about the group to me if I don't know how many times you would expect from any other similarly sized sample of people.
- snarf21 5y agoOr you could be outraged regardless of the ratio. Additionally, don't forget the Catholic church purposefully not reporting these incidents to the authorities and actively covering it up; instead moving the priest to a new town to abuse new kids. That seems like it should cause plenty of outrage in us all.
- Huffers2 5y ago> Or you could be outraged regardless of the ratio That's a fair point.
- hotz 5y agoWhen I was 18/19 I was well on my way to entering the seminary. I use to spend a lot of time with priests, I can't recall who it was, maybe my parish priest but I was told "priests don't become pedophiles, pedophiles become priests." That has stuck with me for quite a few years. Life happens, you meet a girl, get married and have a baby. When I look at my 5 year old son, it really screws with my head how anyone could want to harm children. I think as a Catholic I'm just disappointed/disgusted that the Church has failed all these kids for as long as they have. I'd probably kill the person that leaves my child with lifelong trauma. I just wish society had enough balls to take on the Church's leadership. There's no real justice and I doubt we'll ever see anything meaningful done.
- snarf21 5y agoThe Catholic church can't change because they would have to give up the ghost. The Catholic church has always been about emotional and monetary control. You aren't allowed to ask for forgiveness of your sins but someone who went to a special college can ask for you? Umm, okay. I also think you also underestimate your power. Stand outside your local church protesting the molestation every Sunday. It won't be easy or comfortable but you can undermine the system you used to support. Good luck.
- rich_sasha 5y agoCC lacks meaningful tools for protest. You can put up or leave. As far as I can tell, UK and US at least have some non-trivial involvement of lay Catholics in daily running of the institution. But in Poland? You'd be kicked out for asking to see a church's books. Incidentally, leaving is what's happening in Poland. The bastion of Catholicism with unshakable faith. When I was at high schools O(15) years ago, pretty much everyone attended religion classes at school (yes, Catholic religion classes, not some kind of broader religious education). Now most kids are signing out. Churches are emptying and were doing so well before Covid. The institution of CC is very wealthy in Poland and well-connected to politicians (they command a lot of unquestioning votes), so that can perpetuate even after the last Catholic signs out.
- nickthemagicman 5y agoThat sounds like ALOT. That's a whole city of molested kids! What's the math on this? How many French Catholic priests are there? How much time are they spending molesting?
- baud147258 5y agoit's an estimate, counting possible from 1950
- baud147258 5y agoFunny how it's not the same figure as in the French headlines I saw.
- BrandoElFollito 5y agoNot sure where you were looking, but Le Figaro and Le Monde had these figures. I also heard them this morning in France Culture.
- kevmoo1 5y agoFitting: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7Tu8Y5g8pXg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7Tu8Y5g8pXg