3 ms·
I didn’t see any disinformation, just initial reports that it was DNS which were later explained to be caused by BGP.
by colechristensen 5y ago
I didn’t see any disinformation, just initial reports that it was DNS which were later explained to be caused by BGP.
- paxys 5y ago- It was government intervention - Facebook was hacked - They did it on purpose to bury the whistleblower story - No one could access Facebook offices - They had to cut open servers with angle grinders - Disgruntled employees changed DNS records - Lots of made up numbers for how much money Facebook/the rest of the economy was losing (or gaining) They probably rushed out this blog post just to dispel some of these rumors.
- guerrilla 5y agoMost of these started out as speculation and jokes. Maybe we have a stupidity (i.e. critical thinking) problem rather than a misinformation problem. Only two of these (angle grinders and access to the offices) can really be considered lies or mistakes by an otherwise reputable source (the NYT) and one of those doesn't seem to have been refuted or retracted yet.
- paganel 5y agoIt looks like they retracted/corrected the angle grinder thing but they didn't use a retraction yet for the "access to office" info, maybe that means that was correct? (for a section of the FB workforce, of course).
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- colechristensen 5y agoI entirely believed that the badge readers on doors were broken, I have set systems like that up and they’re network connected. It is not the least bit surprising that BGP chaos would break that. That doesn’t mean people literally couldn’t get in the building, more like security was really annoyed and confused all day.
- Thorrez 5y agoA New York Times reporter said employees had trouble getting in, and I don't see a retraction. So I believe that is true: https://twitter.com/sheeraf/status/1445099150316503057 https://twitter.com/sheeraf/status/1445099150316503057
- switch007 5y agoDo we hold journalists posting on Twitter to the same standards as writing in newspapers and their websites? Genuine question
- phire 5y agoThough, I assume by "had trouble getting in" means something boring like "was delayed by a few min until someone already inside pressed the exit button" And they probably "fixed it" by putting someone near the door to let people in.
- implements 5y agoI briefly worked on access control a long time ago - aren’t they supposed to cache credentials locally so that individual doors still function autonomously during a fire / loss of power and comms?
- colechristensen 5y agoEh I would assume that would only be necessary if the lock mechanism kept people in, the only place I’ve been that did that was a defense contractor, and even then there were alarmed emergency doors. Everywhere else had either no exit control or trivially bypassed exit control.
- kumarvvr 5y ago> - It was government intervention There was an Indian opposition Member of Parliament blaming the current government that it blocked FB due to some protests being held in the Capital.
- albert_e 5y agoNot to defend politicians looking to gain political mileage from everything, this is not a far-fetched claim. Current Indian government has blocked websites and shutdown internet access wholesale to towns and even whole states citing many reasons, and multiple times in recent past. Latest was internet shutdown in multiple Rajasthan towns apparently to prevent exam takers from cheating on a test.
- carabiner 5y agoThe angle grinders stuff was confirmed by NYTimes. Everything else was rank speculation by people who admitted as such. No one was passing off a hostile attack as fact.
- amarshall 5y agoAnd then retracted by NYT: > Correction: Oct. 4, 2021. An earlier version of this article misstated a Facebook team’s means of getting access to server computers at a data center in Santa Clara, Calif. The team did not have to cut through a cage using an industrial angle grinder.
- colechristensen 5y agoEven if it wasn't true, drilling out locks or cutting them with tools is a pretty standard way of dealing with a lock you can't open. In an emergency where lots of things were broken it would be a perfectly reasonable thing to do. Also a news source with a nontechnical reporter might say the wrong thing that would indicate somebody was opening a server chassis with a powertool.
- notacoward 5y agoI think you mean repeated uncritically by NYT. It doesn't even make sense, as reported. Yes, maybe to get into the cage in a shared DC, but not individual servers, and it turns out neither was necessary. That's a rehash of an old Google story. Another bit of misreporting (e.g. The Verge) is that this was "one of its main US data centers in California" when there's no such thing. The seriously big heaps of hardware are elsewhere and they're not shared, so there are no cages to force entry into. I've been in one; no cages in sight. I know which facility they're talking about, and its only distinguishing characteristic is that it's close to where relevant people live.
- pmlnr 5y agoYou do know the meaning or jokes and/or ironic comments, right?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- pantulis 5y agoJust for the sake of completeness I saw a Twitter from some conspiracy website stating that it was some kind of menace from outer space.
- can16358p 5y agoIt could still be any/some of these. Unlikely, but possible. Taking down BGP would just be a cover-up of something bigger. If this was a more honest company I'd call myself a tinfoiler, but since we're dealing with Facebook... ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
- datavirtue 5y ago"They had to cut open servers with angle grinders" I want to believe.
- unethical_ban 5y agoYou say "believed as fact" where I say "speculated because we had nothing to go on". Sure, my friends and I wondered if it was a malicious insider. It takes surprisingly few people in an organization to cause chaos. Knowing IoT, it isn't unbelievable that badge readers could be offline. Knowing division of duties, it isn't hard to believe that the network engineers, domain admins and datacenter ops people may have hustled to a DC to get things back online. Never did I see a large number of people take anything as fact that didn't seem to be substantiated.