4 ms·
"Shouldn’t we focus on making those services accessible and affordable? " This. If calls and international calls were acessible, whatsapp wouldnt exist
by ClumsyPilot 5y ago
"Shouldn’t we focus on making those services accessible and affordable? "
This. If calls and international calls were acessible, whatsapp wouldnt exist
- Denvercoder9 5y ago> This. If calls and international calls were acessible, whatsapp wouldnt exist Whatsapp offers a whole lot more: read receipts, group chats, images and video, voice notes, location sharing, a web client (albeit a quite limited one), and it has a generally pretty good UX/UI (much better than Androids stock messaging app). Regardless of the economics, on a technical level calling/texting isn't competitive with Whatsapp.
- dvtrn 5y agoWhat ever became of RCS? Wasn’t that supposed to support a good number of these features?
- throw0101a 5y agoIt requires news infrastructure on the telco side as well as client-side support: * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rich_Communication_Services https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rich_Communication_Services There seems to be only lukewarm support for it from all parties involved. (Apple isn't even bothering to do much/anything, so that's a huge installed base where nothing is happening.)
- wyldfire 5y agoRCS tries to offer the feature set of WA and iMessage while engaging the mobile operator. WhatsApp and iMessage are "over the top" services that "only" leverage mobile data / TCP etc. RCS was an awful compromise in order to pander to the telcos. Being a simple data service avoids a lot of the problems introduced by cellular infrastructure. We can expect all of the same functionality/robustness/compatibility issues of SMS/MMS.
- tg180 5y agoRCS "engaging with mobile operators" means that it will enable spam and marketing. Assuming an increase in the adoption of the technology, users will still mainly use OTT services. WhatsApp Business is a saint in comparison to the Wild West of telcos.
- perryizgr8 5y agoWhatsapp also provides a very nice payment feature in India. I use it very often.
- ClumsyPilot 5y ago"at the technical level calling/texting isn't competitive with Whatsapp." This does not seem to an a comment informed about how the network works VoLTE is better quality audio than what's app, it gracefully works in large crowds and countryside instead of degrading into individual sylabiles the way whats app does. Latency is 10x lower. There is no central server that cam fail like it did last week. Calling is an intrinsic, optimised part of the mobile network, replacing it at a higher layer will always be inferior. Its the economics that moves the needly, my mom would have neber installed an app to get all the other fluff like read reciepts
- Denvercoder9 5y agoWith "technical" here I mean the featureset that's delivered to the user. Maybe your mom doesn't care about the "fluff", but your mom isn't the person in society that sets the standard for apps that intrinsically require a network effect, and the people that do set such a standard, do care about what you dismiss as fluff.
- ClumsyPilot 5y ago"people that do set such a standard, do care about what you dismiss as fluff" Quick poll among my friends, 15% care about read reciepts but 100% care about money. My mom is about the median age of a what's app user, who are these magical people that set the standard more than she does? Based on what evidence do you believe their preferences are different to her's?
- Johnny555 5y agoWhat is "accessible"? I can call anywhere in the USA for free, and its $0.01/minute to call an overseas relative, yet I almost never call.
- lotsofpulp 5y agoAccessible would be the mobile networks allowing people to call overseas for $0.01 per minute. I would not dare try to call an international number via ATT/Verizon/T-Mobile outside of Canada/Mexico, because I would expect to pay at least $10 for the call if not more. I do not know where one would get $0.01 per minute international calls from the US, but it is most likely not as easy as an app on your smartphone.
- selimthegrim 5y agoT-Mobile used to have some kind of international roaming deal...
- Wowfunhappy 5y agoHonestly, is there a good reason this hasn't happened yet? If people use WhatsApp, the mobile networks get $0, so they ought to be offering at least somewhat competitive prices...
- lotsofpulp 5y agoWhy and how would the telephone networks compete with $0.00? As far as I understand, the whole telephone protocol is decades old and involves various networks paying each other based on who knows what per years old contracts at years old prices.
- vxNsr 5y agoVOIP from tmo/vz/att is still 100x better quality than voip from WhatsApp or zoom, I’ll choose tmo calling if it’s cheap or free over WhatsApp every time.
- 5y ago