3 ms·
> Just do what most American cities do with other natural monopolies like utilities: use careful price controls to cap margins and slow rate increases. Nothing
by AnthonyMouse 5y ago
> Just do what most American cities do with other natural monopolies like utilities: use careful price controls to cap margins and slow rate increases.
Nothing Apple does is a natural monopoly.
Artificial monopolies can be maintained through vertical integration. If you don't like their app store, use another one. If all they provide is the app store, that's easy, and every platform would have half a dozen or more.
But if using a different app store requires you to develop your own operating system, and convince millions of third party developers to make applications for it even before it has any users, and make your own hardware, on and on, well then it's infeasible to make a competing app store and you get an uncompetitive and abusive market.
The solution there isn't to regulate it like a utility, it's to break up the company so that the operating system isn't made by the same company as the app store and has no reason to restrict the users to only the one. Then you have competition again and don't need any regulation other than the constraint on vertical integration.
- atdrummond 5y agoWhat is relevant is that the App Store is a natural monopoly within the iOS ecosystem. As long as Apple has such significant market power (including a substantial market share, especially as a percentage of revenue, not just units sold) their natural monopoly on the iOS platform will extend to them being a willing participant in an oligopoly. Said state of affairs is the expected outcome of Apple having a natural monopoly and there being only one other substantial mobile OS market participant, who just so happens to also operate a natural monopoly for app sales - albeit a much, much more tenuous one.
- shakna 5y ago> What is relevant is that the App Store is a natural monopoly within the iOS ecosystem. That's very much not a natural monopoly, but a constraint that is forced onto the ecosystem by Apple. There is no technical reason for it existing, but it exists by design.