3 ms·
Why do we even let corporations own things that we consider "utilities"? Seems like a case of people being perfectly happy with using a free service until it br
by smoldesu 5y ago
Why do we even let corporations own things that we consider "utilities"? Seems like a case of people being perfectly happy with using a free service until it breaks, then it's all a shitstorm. If WhatsApp's mere existence is enough to warrant deregulation, what does that mean for platforms like iMessage, which fundamentally fill the same role?
- krapp 5y agoIt's not a utility, and it shouldn't be considered one.
- mandmandam 5y agoIt's more of a utility, and to more people, than rotary phones were.
- igetspam 5y agoWhich also were not a utility... Rotary phones are an interface to a utility. But let's be realistic, the copper required to connect homes to each other required a massive public works effort. Facebook turned on a server and ran some PHP to stalk college women. Big difference.
- mandmandam 5y agoAh right so. Well if we're being pedantic like that, I guess my oven is just an interface to the gas line, and my lights are just an interface to the leccy lines. Guess I don't need to pay my utility bills, which is great news because they're gone through the roof.
- jkelleyrtp 5y agoThe government doesn’t make ovens or light bulbs, but does maintain the infrastructure. I think there’s a distinction to be made there.
- perl4ever 5y ago>Rotary phones are an interface to a utility. I'm not old enough to remember firsthand, but I believe rotary phones (in the US) are generally from the era when the phone company was a monopoly and strictly controlled what was plugged into their lines. So I think it may be technically correct to call them a (part of a) utility and not just an interface.
- fragmede 5y agoYes. The telephone in your house belonged to AT&T, and you had to rent it from them. It took a lawsuit for them to allow other devices to connect to the phone network. Today's vendor lock-in is no different.
- fennecfoxen 5y agoIt’s not a utility, and shouldn’t be considered one, and the extent to which it is used as if it were a utility anyway is very unfortunate, pointing to substantial underinvestment in general purpose messaging and information management systems.
- sva_ 5y agoI'm not confident in government to do a better job at keeping it up, tbh. I also wouldn't use a messaging app by my gov, if that's what you meant. Too many dystopian ways for that to go wrong. I have several messaging apps on my phone, and maybe that's just how it is for now.
- smoldesu 5y agoIf you have "several messaging apps" on your phone, I'd wager that you are using a messaging app by the government. Unless you have SMS disabled and talk to Grandma in her Matrix server, I doubt anyone is truly "safe" from government surveillance.
- unethical_ban 5y agoI think it would be awesome of the USPS offered email and Matrix services for free to people. I could even see it being useful as an official government communication mechanism. And every post-office would be an in-person help-desk for getting locked out or requesting any access help. Also, free 100kbps wifi, completely open. Along with banking and check-cashing, making the USPS into the generic hub of "dealing with money and communications with the goal of public service, not profit" would be amazing.