4 ms·
IMO Material only became good around Android 7. When Android 5 was still around, the boilerplate components were all way too big and the information density was
by jeroenhd 5y ago
IMO Material only became good around Android 7. When Android 5 was still around, the boilerplate components were all way too big and the information density was incredibly low compared to Holo. Apps were tweaked and around Android 7 did I find them to be actually usable again.
Google Calendar had this issue the worst if I recall. There were these gaudy, colourful images everywhere with cards sliding around and big, friendly buttons all over the place. The design looked pretty great during a quick presentation, but in practice I found it very hard to use the "stream" view calendar properly when I could see two or three events at most without scrolling.
- Andrew_nenakhov 5y agoSure, they did have a shortage of components, but the existing components were simple, clear, attractive. No ugly oval floating buttons or chiseled navbars hugging the FAB. Currently, the notes app is a good example of such uglyfication: what was previously a simple attractive app now sports a horrendous navbar with ugly squarerounded plus button of unclear color. Phew.