10 ms·
I am pretty sure I read something similar before. Probably from Benedict Evans or somewhere else. I think the most important issue from these email isn't the l
by ksec 5y ago
I am pretty sure I read something similar before. Probably from Benedict Evans or somewhere else.
I think the most important issue from these email isn't the lack of Alternative App Store, IAP, or 70/30 split. It is that Apple Execs has Zero understanding of how other business works especially with respect to Internet or Software Services. They continue to think Netflix as a physical product ( As they often like to compare Physical Software distribution before App Store ) that is being continuously sold with recurring revenue like staples or other commodities.
Not to mention Netflix knew Apple were doing AppleTV+. Directly competing with them. I love how Apple complains about testing IAP as not OK as in we deserve our 15%.
So Reed made the decision to stop IAP. And reading all the emails from Apple execs, Eddy Cue often seems to be the culprit.
Steve From D5
>You know, because Woz and I started the company based on doing the whole banana, we weren’t so good at partnering with people. And, you know, acatually, the funny thing is, Microsoft’s one of the few companies we were able to partner with that actually worked for both companies. And we weren’t so good at that, where Bill and Microsoft were really good at it because they didn’t make the whole thing in the early days and they learned how to partner with people really well.
And I think if Apple could have had a little more of that in its DNA, it would have served it extremely well. And I don’t think Apple learned that until, you know, a few decades later.
- clusterfish 5y ago> They continue to think Netflix as a physical product ( As they often like to compare Physical Software distribution before App Store ) Framing the relationship this way gives Apple more power and control, so that's what they're doing, no surprise. They're too smart to be merely misunderstanding such things.
- jobu 5y agoThat's interesting. As a developer I've often felt outright hostility coming from Apple developer relations, and maybe it's this lack of a partnership mentality. They generally treat end users really well, but it's like they see external developers as some sort of parasite feeding on their products. In my experience it's difficult to get actual technical help unless you personally know someone internal to Apple.
- tornato7 5y agoFrom Apple's perspective, developers are either creating competing products or products that Apple will eventually compete with. Either way they would rather not help.
- mhh__ 5y agoDon't forget products they just ban
- asdff 5y agoMy tinfoil hat theory is they allow the jailbreaking scene to persist instead of shoring up holes within a second of each jailbreak's release because they poach tweak ideas. When looking at the overlap between popular early jailbreak tweaks and features that were added to iOS over the years, this really doesn't seem farfetched.
- saagarjha 5y agoThe Apple of today does fix holes as soon as they can. But they don't really need to steal jailbreak tweaks anymore to figure out that people want to be able to change their homescreens…
- asdff 5y agoThere was a lot more than that which was copied, honestly. Notification center. Control center. Widgets. Low power mode. Notifications where you can reply in line. Probably hundreds more tiny quality of life things too that have made their way into iOS over the years that were first seen on cydia. Here's a list of 60 of them at least (2018): https://ios.gadgethacks.com/how-to/60-ios-features-apple-stole-from-jailbreakers-0188093/ https://ios.gadgethacks.com/how-to/60-ios-features-apple-sto...
- saagarjha 5y agoOh, I 100% agree, I'm just saying Apple may not see it that way anymore.
- croshan 5y agoI love that quote. To get where you want to be, it may be helpful to build the skills you want, before you need them. At this point, an organization like Apple is too cemented to easily change. I think you can't learn _everything_ on the job, because some things you'll learn too late. Now, it's more than "a few decades later," and have they really learned how to partner?
- 5faulker 5y agoIf they do some major restructuring that is.
- ksec 5y agoI think Steve Jobs did learn how to partner with people and being very very careful which battle to pick after he came back from NeXT. Qualcomm Modem and Patents agreement, Gorilla Glass on Original iPhone. Both likely pissed off Apple's Operation because of their huge increase in BOM. As Disney's ex CEO Bob Iger said, if Steve was alive they would probably have bought or partnered with Disney on streaming. Now Apple is in the content business competing directly with Netflix and Disney. As shown in Qualcomm, IMG case. Tim Cook's Apple just aren't very good at partnering.
- gowld 5y agoWoz never seemed bad at teamwork. "Whole banana" was the results of jobs obession with dictatorial control, not the cause of it. Woz tried to add expansion ports to the Apple computer, but Jobs refused. Jobs seems to be throwing Woz under the bus (as usual) to deflect from his own flaws.
- musicale 5y ago> Woz tried to add expansion ports to the Apple computer Like the expansion slots in the [Apple II, Apple ///, Mac II, IIgs, Power Mac, Mac Pro, etc.] or the [SCSI, ADB, USB, FireWire, PC/Express/SD card, Thunderbolt, etc.] expansion ports on various Apple computers?
- fsckboy 5y agoyes. Here's wikipedia on the Apple II: "During the design stage, Jobs argued that the Apple II should have two expansion slots, while Wozniak wanted eight. After a heated argument, during which Wozniak threatened that Jobs should "go get himself another computer", they decided to go with eight slots." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Steve_Wozniak https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Steve_Wozniak
- tablespoon 5y agoWhat does IAP stand for in this context?
- 8ytecoder 5y agoIn-App Purchase
- jjtheblunt 5y agoin-app purchase, i believe
- jacurtis 5y agoFor comparison Netflix spends about $1.2 Billion dollars per year on AWS (Amazon Web Services). Their total revenue last year was 27.5B. So that means that AWS fees account for 4.3% of Netflix's revenue. AWS is streaming video, operating hundreds of edge location CDN locations, and everything else running on expensive server infrastructure. AWS has real serious costs with offering that service, to the point that Netflix has yet to determine that it is better to build it themselves. Apple by comparison demands 15% which is 3.5x as much of a cut. Apple provides credit card processing, and approval into the App Store (plus according to a comment in this email, it sounds like they keep Netflix in the App Store promotion rotation as "free" ad-space). This isn't anywhere near the value that AWS provides, despite demanding a much higher premium. Of course this is the "generous" 15% IAP cut, instead of the normal 30% which is even more atrocious. Apple seems to maintain the expectation that they deserve 30% of revenue from massive corporations like Netflix, Amazon, etc.. Even the "generous" 15% fee is quite atrocious, especially considering the fact that Apple provides next to no value for Netflix, if anything they are a pain in their side or a necessary evil for Netflix. Apple is wildly delusional on the value that they provide. It is absolutely no surprise to me that Netflix would consider not allowing IAP subscriptions at all. They already have the marketing power to force people to subscribe at their website. I am surprised Netflix is honestly being as understanding on this issue as they seem to be.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- garblegarble 5y ago>AWS is streaming video, operating hundreds of edge location CDN locations, and everything else running on expensive server infrastructure. AWS has real serious costs with offering that service, to the point that Netflix has yet to determine that it is better to build it themselves. Somewhat off the core topic, but netflix run their own CDN (I also don't see any evidence for that 1.2 billion AWS bill figure, can you provide a link? Their latest SEC filing doesn't separate cloud service costs from the running of their Open Connect CDN)
- PoignardAzur 5y ago