4 ms·
> In principle, firewalled research could be the solution. Supplement companies could pay to have tests done by independent researchers. Consumers would have a
by michaelt 5y ago
> In principle, firewalled research could be the solution. Supplement companies could pay to have tests done by independent researchers. Consumers would have a quality signal for what products to trust, and the companies that make good stuff would make more money.
The UK tried something like this for building materials - unfortunately, it doesn't seem to work very well.
To achieve certain standards of fire resistance, manufacturers could choose from a range of independent test houses, who would conduct the relevant fire performance tests at the manufacturers' expense.
Except it turns out, manufacturers don't want to go to difficult, argumentative test labs. They choose the friendly test lab, that knows how to treat its paying customers. The lab that will advise them on how to pass the test, that will leave them unsupervised as they add defeat devices to the test rig, and that will remove problematic photos from the test report.
The result? Loads of our tower blocks are clad in flammable insulation and ACM panels - including one where 72 people died in a single fire.
- rocqua 5y agoI think the difference between the testing for materials you describe, and the firewalled research OP wants is an intermediate institution. Here it was the NIH, it should always be an independent organization. The money is committed to the institution before the institution decides who gets the job.