7 ms·
I feel like we need to start differentiating between "public" personal information and more sensitive personal information (like social security numbers or othe
by hn_throwaway_99 5y ago
I feel like we need to start differentiating between "public" personal information and more sensitive personal information (like social security numbers or other government ID numbers). The breach lists this info:
Name
Email
Location
Gender
Phone number
User ID
So basically, everything I used to be able to get in a phone book. Honestly, at this point all of that information should just be considered public, because it obviously is.
If anything I think people are grappling with the fact that the Internet just makes data scraping and processing possible on a scale previously unimaginable, and that's really what people have an issue with, but I don't think there's a great answer to that. I mean, it's one thing to say the front of my house is public info because anyone can come by and take a picture, but it sure feels different when a high resolution photo (or heck, video feed) can be posted online that is instantly available to billions of people.
- spansoa 5y ago> and more sensitive personal information (like social security numbers) Well I consider SSNs public knowledge at this stage. You can reliably dox anyone in the US now and find out their SSNs. Also: I used to have a sticker on my laptop that had my SSN on it, and brought it to conferences, as a PR stunt for my consultancy.
- throwaway78981 5y agoThis isn't true. The phonebook we had had only Name, Phone number and very broad location. Also those days, phone number was just that - a phone number. Nowadays it's a unique identifier for lots and lots of things including government stuff. Some government stuff even uses it for authentication/authorization. Also I guess user ID means it gives access to their fb profile page I guess? From there one can scrape pics etc (public ones).
- micromacrofoot 5y agothe 1.5B number leads me to believe that these aren't all public accounts though, so it's a bit broader than the phone book comparison also at this point there have been enough large leaks that cross-referencing the data can probably paint a very complete picture of many people
- imglorp 5y agoStrong disagree. > Name Email Location Gender Phone number User ID It's never about one item of information released: it's about the aggregation and linking potential. Name/location/phone together form a pretty decent unique identifier. FB obviously gives you friends, interests, hangouts, and most importantly, photographs; none of which you had before. Ater aggregating with other databases is when the harm comes.
- dataflow 5y ago> So basically, everything I used to be able to get in a phone book. Your phone books had your login usernames and emails?
- dragonwriter 5y ago> So basically, everything I used to be able to get in a phone book. Even if people didn't have unlisted numbers, phone books would allow listing only last name and first initial of one person in the household, without any location data beyond the phone book service area (you could provide more if you wanted to be found), and didn’t include gender.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- gizdan 5y ago> So basically, everything I used to be able to get in a phone book. Honestly, at this point all of that information should just be considered public, because it obviously is. With a phonebook (at least back in the day), you didn't risk having your account exposed and sold for a few dollars. Nor did that risk someone getting access to thousands, if not more, bank accounts or whatever through automation. In addition, a phonebook is easy to opt out of making things public. Facebook gives you the illusion that you can opt out of this data being public. Edit: opt of -> opt out of
- chillee 5y ago> Facebook gives you the illusion that you can opt of this data being public. What makes you think that that isn't the case here? It sounds like they just scraped all the public profiles they could find. It's not a database "leak" or something like that.
- gizdan 5y agoRight, that's what I mean with "Facebook gives you the illusion that you can opt out of this data being public". I recall when I still had Facebook, many people would randomly add you and pretend to be random people, sometimes famous, sometimes they "just want to be friends". I know most people have some settings along the lines of "no one except friends can see all this data". This is an issue, because people will add these "friends" and forget about these permissions. These "friends" can easily be attackers like these that suddenly have access to all your data. Hence the "illusion". With a phonebook on the other hand, when you opt out, you've opted out.
- skinnymuch 5y agoMany people added you like that? Just asked a few people. No one gets many FB rando requests that aren’t super obviously fake. It isn’t that common. I’ve had FB since 2007. Don’t recall there ever being a surge.
- 5y ago
- azta6521 5y agoTrue, but my last paper phone book did not have 1,500,000,000 entries.
- hn_throwaway_99 5y agoYes, that's literally my exact point in my last paragraph.
- mankyd 5y ago> If anything I think people are grappling with the fact that the Internet just makes data scraping and processing possible on a scale previously unimaginable, Agreed. I remember way back when FB first launched the "feed". Folks on Slashdot (yes, that long ago) had great outcry about how much of a violation of privacy it was. I countered that all it was doing was collating all the posts that people were making on their "walls". Nothing new was necessarily being exposed. People still didn't like it. Someone argued that the extra steps necessary to visit each "friends" wall was a valuable impediment. Obviously, that's a weak position to take, but it reinforces your point: data scraping is easier than anyone seems to be willing to acknowledge. Anything you write in any "semi-public" space should simply be considered entirely public.
- _moof 5y ago> everything I used to be able to get in a phone book Fair, although you could opt out of the phone book. (And I don't think they had location/address, though it's been so long now that I can't remember for sure.) > I think people are grappling with the fact that the Internet just makes data scraping and processing possible on a scale previously unimaginable This is it right here. The scale and ease of access are terrifying. It's true that in the olden days, someone could follow me around and write down everywhere I went, everyone I talked to, what stores I went to, my hobbies, and so on. But someone would actually have to do that, and they would have to single me out, and even then the information they collected would be in a notebook, not distributed to virtually every human on the planet. Now we are all being followed, all the time, and all of that information is available to anyone with almost no cost or effort. This is a sea change, and personally I find it horrifying. There are very, very few people I would trust with that much information. I definitely don't trust the whole world with it.
- tiernano 5y ago> Fair, although you could opt out of the phone book. (And I don't think they had location/address, though it's been so long now that I can't remember for sure.) you can opt out of Facebook too... and Irish phone books had addresses...
- _moof 5y agoIt's not just Facebook. Your phone is tattling on you 24/7. ALPRs are recording where you drive. Browser fingerprinting is creating a profile on you even if you block ads and trackers. Short of never using a computer, there is no opt out anymore.
- mitchitized 5y ago"Ooh, lookit that funny car over there!" - points phone almost at your face, takes picture - uploads picture to Facebook You'd literally have to have the kind of Momma that would dig a hole and hide you in it at birth to really be "off the grid" at this point.
- 5y ago
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- pelotox 5y agoThis happens in data regulatory contexts. There are varying degrees of PII (Personally Identifiable Information) and different rules around securing it.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- moolcool 5y agoI think that information increased in sensitivity because technology that gives us instant access to it also allows it to be exploited in different new ways. Like there's no machine that can take a paper phonebook and call everyone in it with customized spam messages, but you can trivially do that with a CSV file and 20 lines of python.
- lmilcin 5y ago> So basically, everything I used to be able to get in a phone book. Honestly, at this point all of that information should just be considered public, because it obviously is. I am honestly shocked at your proposal. In a real paper book you had a choice not to get your number published. Have you put any thought about people who are maybe running from abusive spouse or any other people who have reason not to have their location data to be broadcasted to entire world?
- twobitshifter 5y agoWith a land line phone number from a phonebook, criminals can’t do much. With a smartphone number they can hack phones, potentially steal bank accounts, track their location and on and on.
- StringyBob 5y agoAs an example, my parents have been bombarded with calls from a scammer who it seems only has their phone number and email address, but that’s enough to give away their full names and the name of the ISP, so the scammer is using it to call and pretend to be the ISP support trying to trick them into giving up 2FA codes from password reset attempts they do at the same time while calling that phone. You don’t need much info to go a long way!
- paulpauper 5y agoCouldn't a social security number be easily bruteforced anyway
- jeffbee 5y agoYes. SSNs are distributed by year in blocks that are granted to hospitals. If you know a person's year and place of birth you can brute force them. For example if you wanted to generate plausible identities you could just use a common Jewish last name and get the SSN block from a major hospital in NYC for a high birth year. Say, 1955. The odds that you will be able to guess the SSN for Abraham Goldstein born in Manhattan in 1955 are going to be pretty good, especially if you have some oracle that will let you guess several times.
- robbedpeter 5y ago10,000 is probably going to be the largest number of guesses needed, and if you have prior knowledge, like a distributed set of ssns from the same year and location, you can reduce the practical effective number of guesses to a few dozen. The freely available databases of pii in the wild can be used to infer anything missing from releases like this, and that stuff can be used to inform probabilistic password guesses, and so on. It's only a matter of time before deep learning models make most common password based security measures completely transparent and obsolete.
- robbyking 5y agoAbsolutely. Most engineers who work with sensitive data already know that there are tiers of data sensitivity (Public, Personal, Private), and that info like SSN and CCN are more private than, say, gender or marital status.
- themdonuts 5y agoThe comment is good, but your username is excellent.
- sabellito 5y agoPerhaps this insanity you're describing is true for the US. It doesn't necessarily account for the remaining... 1.2B people who had their info leaked.
- loudmax 5y ago> more sensitive personal information (like social security numbers or other government ID numbers) I tend to think that there should be a publicly accessible, unique, and more or less immutable ID number for every citizen or resident. This ID would have pointers to our name, birth date and a few other identifiers that shouldn't really be considered secret. My concern is that the absence of such a unique ID leads to a mess of overlapping systems in which only large organizations with the resources to track everyone will be able to uniquely identify people. So we'll have a degree of anonymity from random other individuals, not not from banks, tech corporations or the government. Computing power is becoming too cheap and ubiquitous to effectively hide information that isn't explicitly confidential. That is, as a society we need to adjust to a paradigm in which it is more expensive to keep information confidential than to allow it to be public. Especially keeping information private from those with deep pockets.
- Aerroon 5y agoAnd why exactly would everyone being easier to track be helpful to the actual people themselves? I don't want Facebook to have that information. I'm even less interested in some random small business having it.
- specialist 5y agoAgree on importance of correlating records across heterogenous systems. AND: All PII field level data must be encrypted at rest. UUIDs unlock both the record linking and privacy achievements. The book Translucent Databases shows how. Hide sensitive data with salt + hash, just like with proper password files. Use UUIDs as opaque pointers for linking.
- intricatedetail 5y agoProblem is user id link. From there you can get much more info. Facebook should be legally forced to reindex users and void all current user ids.
- ramblenode 5y agoIn the past "public" did not mean a single, all-encompassing global village of information that anyone on earth with a computer could get access to. People then operated within local shells of information, extending outward from the neighborhood block to the city to the country and maybe finally to the world. What time you walk your dog each day would be neighborhood level public info. Phone numbers would be city level. For greater reach than that you usually had to put the info out there yourself or be someone of media prominence. Nowadays the time you walk your dog is out on the internet because it was leaked from some Amazon S3 bucket collecting pings from your dog's smart collar. And what more it's been joined with your name, phone number, and other personal info to create an automated profile of you by interested groups. That's a whole different ball game, and not one that many people expect despite living their lives (in their minds) the same way as before.
- DebtDeflation 5y ago>I feel like we need to start differentiating between "public" personal information and more sensitive personal information (like social security numbers or other government ID numbers). The flipside of this is that we need to make it such that simply knowing someone's Name, Address, DOB, and SSN is not adequate to fraudulently assume their financial identity and incur debts in their name.
- barbazoo 5y agoSounds a bit like moving the goal posts to me. You were able to opt out of phone books and they also didn't contain email and gender.
- ChainOfFools 5y agoalso, older FB accounts (and maybe even some recently created ones?) could easily use handles instead of real names or even real initials. this leak can therefore establish or confirm a mapping between someone's online and offline identities, which wasn't a risk associated with phone book listings.
- LeifCarrotson 5y ago> If anything I think people are grappling with the fact that the Internet just makes data scraping and processing possible on a scale previously unimaginable, and that's really what people have an issue with, but I don't think there's a great answer to that. I mean, it's one thing to say the front of my house is public info because anyone can come by and take a picture, but it sure feels different when a high resolution photo (or heck, video feed) can be posted online that is instantly available to billions of people. From your example, it's another thing to have a high resolution photo or video feed of everyone's houses and to, say, send them ads for painting services if the trim looks out of shape. I think the important thing to get in the public consciousness is that scale alone is sufficient to make information processing fundamentally different than a human interacting with a single data point. Looking up one person in the phone book and calling them or sending them a letter is different than scanning the entire book, robocalling everyone in it, and sending junk mail to all of them. The fact that the former is accepted and that the later is merely the former repeated a million times does not make the latter permissible. The former was accepted because the way the world worked meant that it was simply intractable - an economic nonstarter, a physical and logical impossibility, humanly infeasible - to abuse it into spamming a million people. For another example, license plates are public, required to be visible on your vehicle on public roads. Prior to license plate scanning technology, a cop could have tailed a suspect and radioed their vehicle description and license plate to have other detectives and officers disperse to intersections and track a vehicle through a city, and depending on the nature of the problem, they could spend a few hundred dollars to dispatch a helicopter to chase it across the freeway. They could conceivably tail a non-suspect, but that wouldn't make any sense, they were constrained by limited resources to only use this ability for a select few vehicles. That was how the world worked. Later, automated license plate readers were developed. With cameras deployed across every intersection in a city, it would be feasible to track all motions of every vehicle at all times; it would likely be cheaper and easier to do so than one year's expenses of deploying personnel to do so manually. That information should be considered public, because it obviously is, but what a person is allowed to do with public information should not be limited only by what they're able to do with it.
- normaler 5y agoMy neighbour who is 87 years old has all the phone books from tbe Lage 50s-mid 60s. I checked my grandfather and it listed bis adress, phone and occupation.
- asdff 5y agoWait until HN readers find out what these faceless companies that appear around election time and mail me junk are able to gleam from public voting registration data.
- salawat 5y agoDon't forget LexisNexis.
- slyrus 5y agoThe new phone books are here!!
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 5y ago"So basically everything I used to be able to get in a phone book." Assuming you had phone books from every city/region in every country. Thats a lot of phone books so you must have had a large warehouse to store them all. Then there is the fact that phone books did not list number for every individual. Multiple persons routinely shared the same number. The comparison sounds apt in theory but in practice it isn't. Try looking these Facebook users up in the phone books of their respective locales, via the telcos' online phone books or directory assistance. Then, using what you find, tell me their email address, gender and Facebook user ID. Good luck. The problem with this argument, "all email addresses are public", which I see regularly on HN, is that information does not become "public" and lose its "private" designation if it is published without consent or lawful purpose. If someone steals secrets and publishes them, they are still secrets. Whether this information from Facebook is truly "private" I cannot say but I do think it is possible to have email addresses that are not made public. The recent NSO iMessage story was interesting because the exploit seemed to rely on NSO getting lists of mobile phone numbers for the targets. Not email addresses. Yet iMessage will work without a phone number, with no SIM inserted. Perhaps the targets chose to use phone numbers for iMessage, not email addresses. Consider what happens if someone creates a Gmail address but never uses it to send mail, and never shares the address with anyone, except Facebook. If this person does not make their Facebook profile public, how is this address public information. Google does not publish a list of every Gmail address. According to the logic of the parent comment, they might just as well. Email addresses are "public", right. Because some HN commenters think they are. What happened when someone scraped Apple's servers to obtain the email addresses of Apple iPad users. Did federal prosecutors think the information was "public" or "private". The media called the incident "theft of e-mail addresses".^1 1. http://www.nbcnews.com/id/41196595 http://www.nbcnews.com/id/41196595
- specialist 5y ago> we need to start differentiating between No, we don't. PII is PII. These large scale breaches harm everyone's privacy (anonymity). Even people who are not included. Because with enough data you can deanon people, eg thru process of elimination.