6 ms·
At least at big corporations it should be about all the corporate double talk and broken policies/promises. Edit: why downvote? This has been my experience. If
by giantg2 5y ago
At least at big corporations it should be about all the corporate double talk and broken policies/promises.
Edit: why downvote? This has been my experience. If we dont talk about it, then it will never be fixed.
- neogodless 5y agoFrom the site guidelines, please don't talk about downvotes in comments. It never does any good, and it's boring. You can expand upon your original comment without that part, and let the votes fall where they do.
- hashkb 5y agoScrew the site guidelines - drive-by downvoting this comment is highly suspicious, and cowardly.
- pc86 5y agoI can't even begin to imagine the bubble you must live in to ascribe words like suspicion and cowardice to someone clicking a button on a forum even most software developers in the world have never even heard of.
- hashkb 5y agoYou could try. I'd assume it was downvoted by folks who perpetuate said double-talk. If there was a defense, they'd have articulated it. But, since anonymous downvoting is easier and less risky, that's what happens. Silencing the discussion about downvotes is a meta downvote that we shouldn't accept just because it's in the guidelines.
- neogodless 5y agoThat may be, but the guidelines have a point. The original comment was interesting. Now it's just a distracting side conversation about downvotes.
- giantg2 5y agoThat's only because you broke the guidelines and commented to create a generic tangent. My edit to ask about why I was being downvoted is based on curiosity - a key pillar of this site. If people have a divergent opinion strong enough to downvote, then I would like to read it to understand more. Furthermore, my comment was not about comment voting, but about identifying and understanding that opposing position. I out, since it seems you're just trolling on a tangent instead of commenting on the pertainate topic.
- neogodless 5y agoI'm not trolling. I'm trying to improve discourse. Doesn't mean I'm right (as my own comment downvotes indicate) but that was my intention.
- hashkb 5y agoI'm trying to improve discourse by fighting against the downvote. It's my opinion it harms discourse significantly. It's low signal, and not constructive. It has an obvious chilling effect on dissent. Nothing upholds echo chambers more than the downvote.
- giantg2 5y agoI think the site also encourages discussion. I don't ask about downvotes if people have a comment response. If they are downvoting without any comment replies, this seems to undermine the spirit of the site.
- dahart 5y agoNo idea about the downvotes, but I could humbly offer a bystander’s constructive suggestions about how to improve the original comment. I’m not sure what you mean about corporate double talk and broken policies and promises, and the first sentence didn’t make clear it was your experience. It could help to elaborate with some examples of what needs to be fixed. It could help to work through why and how discussing it with your manager would help, since fixing it requires that they discuss it with their manager and with the whole team. It seems like an assumption that all big corporations have this problem - I assume you haven’t worked for all of them, right? Personally I’m working for a large corporation and I don’t see a lot of double-talk or broken policies or broken promises. I have seen some amount of double-talk in the past with a different large corporation, but it was related to very high level business decisions, and not really enough that it affected my day-to-day, and maybe more importantly was something that talking to my manager about would never have fixed. So anyway, all I’m trying to say is that there’s a lot of clarification you could add to your comment that would help explain where you’re coming from, what the problems really are that you’re experiencing, and how opening them up for discussion might open the door to fixing them.
- giantg2 5y agoThank you for the comment. "Personally I’m working for a large corporation and I don’t see a lot of double-talk or broken policies or broken promises." That's good, but I know there are people at my company that would say the same thing. A lot of it depends on the individual's experience. Is it possible that you are getting good reviews or your manager likes you, while someone else is getting poor reviews based on a made up reason? As for some personal examples, I have seen multiple company policies violated. I have also seen the company try to sell us an idea that's junk while telling us it's the best thing since sliced bread. The company says that an average rating should be based against defined standards and not be competitive. I know of departments that will require managers to 'pick' someone on their team for a below average rating if they picked someone for an above average rating to "balance it out". They will also fo point counting in some departments eventhough HR says they aren't allowed to (the rating process is secretive wo you'd have to throw a manager friend under the bus to prove anything). There are also some additional part-time roles (security champion) that are supposed to be evaluated as part of your core job responsibilities, yet most departments view them as extracurricular. The company says the standard working hours are 7.5 hours per day unless the position specifically says otherwise. Now, I know that stuff like elevations, pre support, or critical deadlines can mean occasional extra hours - that's fine. I was told that all I needed to do to get to a senior level was stay until 5pm. Ok, so I work 8-4 and you want me to work 9-5? Nope, they want me to work 8.5 hours every day. So why should I take a rate cut for a position with more responsibilities? I work for a financial company that's always saying they want IT to have more financial acumen. Yet they can't explain to me why I should increase my working hours by about 13% for a 7% raise, meaning I will be paid less per hour. This is an even better deal for the company since a large expense for them are the benefits not related to pay, like health insurance. They changed the promotion structure so there are more levels. They tried to sell this as a good thing. But to get to the same level of compensation, you require more promotions. The typical path was 3 10% promotions. Now it's 4 7% promotions to get similar base pay, but you would need a 5th promotion to reach a similar overall compensation due to the profit sharing structure. Now this might sound similar enough, but it doesnt account for time. That 5th promotion is pretty rare, and the 4th takes a long time to get to. The earlier you are saving money, the more it compounds. So when you hit each level under the old structure you could hit it at the same time as you could under the new structure but the raise is almost 50% higher. Now you also have to wait longer to hit the highest level, further delaying that "extra" income and it's compounding effect. The reason they made this change was because they were losing too many people to earlier retirements. Yet they sell this negative change as a positive. The bug plug in the interview was that they don't outsource and they never layoff. They do both now. I lost my specialty to outsourcing. I had a manger tell me he was going to give me the highest rating but I "slacked off" in the last month. I was on PTO for 2.5 weeks for my wedding and honeymoon and put in extra hours for the prior 2 weeks to get things done or turned over. So much for that policy that PTO won't be held against you...
- chatoyance 5y agoManagers need to be no nonsense and direct in order to be respected. PS: I think voting needs to be disambiguated orthogonal to agreeing/disagreeing (because it vital to community health rather than quietly-silenced) but split into dimensions of insight, on-/off-topic, and seriousness-hilarity-or-pointless for sorting based on personal preferences (hide humor, hide off-topic).