6 ms·
It's not a popularity content. Nobel prizes are typically not given until several years after the work is complete and enough time has passed to fully apprecia
by refurb 5y ago
It's not a popularity content. Nobel prizes are typically not given until several years after the work is complete and enough time has passed to fully appreciate the significance of it.
I'd say it's a bit early for mRNA vaccines.
- bacro 5y agoFunnily enough, Egas Moniz was given the nobel prize in medicine for the lobotomy procedure. He claimed it helped the mentally ill. How scientific was that? XD
- ethanbond 5y agoLobotomy is still used and it is still “scientific”… We luckily have better treatments available for almost every scenario, but it’s definitely still a tool in the toolbox. Same with electroshock therapy. We can be thankful for advancements without being dismissive of some of the less ideal steps along the way.
- bacro 5y agoSaying that lobotomy was good for mentally-ill people seems not very good science to me. Some people agree that he should be de-Nobelized (which I agree): https://www.theguardian.com/education/2004/aug/02/highereducation.comment https://www.theguardian.com/education/2004/aug/02/highereduc... Disclaimer: I am portuguese.
- siva7 5y agoThere is a great quote from Norbert Wiener about the procedure: "[P]refrontal lobotomy ... has recently been having a certain vogue, probably not unconnected with the fact that it makes the custodial care of many patients easier. Let me remark in passing that killing them makes their custodial care still easier." I've studied medicine but i'm not aware that it is still taught as a "tool in the toolbox" in the modern medical community.
- ethanbond 5y agoYeah, I think we can agree that it should not be used the way that it was historically.
- Tomte 5y agoThat's the current practice, but siva7 is right in regards to timing and Nobel's will: "to be distributed annually as prizes to those who, during the preceding year, have conferred the greatest benefit to humankind." (https://www.nobelprize.org/alfred-nobel/full-text-of-alfred-nobels-will-2/ https://www.nobelprize.org/alfred-nobel/full-text-of-alfred-...)
- refurb 5y agoIf you look back it’s usually a decade or more before a discovery gets a Nobel prize. Which makes sense, since it’s relevance isn’t usually immediately apparent.
- dustintrex 5y agoYes, but you'd be hard put to argue that there was an invention that got more benefit for humanity than mRNA vaccines in 2021.
- refurb 5y agoConsidering we’re about half way through an epidemic with new variants on the horizon I’d argue it’s a little early to start patting ourselves on the back?
- dustintrex 5y agoIt's not a silver bullet, but there are millions of people who are not dead now because they got vaccinated.
- Cthulhu_ 5y agoOn the one side, you are correct and it's only last year / this year that mRNA vaccines have seen widespread adoption. On the other, mRNA research goes back to the 80's, and mRNA vaccine research goes back twenty years; these facts are often overlooked by the "it was developed too fast" crowds. That said, > It's not a popularity content. And yet, they gave Obama the Nobel Peace Prize the year he was elected, without any merit or achievements to back it up. That decision was politically motivated. Same with giving it to Al Gore for his climate activism. They even tried to nominate Hitler in 1939, albeit in jest.
- dahfizz 5y agoThe Nobel Peace Prize has been nothing but a meme for a while. The science prizes are still respected, and if they want them to stay that way then they should continue to award them based on science and not politics.
- dcgudeman 5y agoThe Nobel Peace prize has always had political motivations that have reduced it's credibility. Last year it was awarded to the "World Food Programme" and in 2001 it was awarded to the “United Nations”. It’s best view the peace prize separately.
- bacro 5y ago>On the other, mRNA research goes back to the 80's, and mRNA vaccine research goes back twenty years; these facts are often overlooked by the "it was developed too fast" crowds. I am on that camp, that it was developed too fast and I do not think people should be mistreated because they think that. After all, there has been some adverse effects for some of the people who took it (like the auto-immune disease for the Janssen vaccine or thrombosis that caused some deaths in women who were taking the pill at the same time). I am not against vaccines in general, I am just worried that, as there is clearly an economic interest in rushing things up, that some bugs may still be on these vaccines that will need to be fixed. We have no idea of the long-term effects these vaccines have, unless someone has invented a time-machine and gone to the future. When concrete, well-made studies have been made that these vaccines are safe long-term and effective, I do not see why should someone not take it. Until then, I will wait at the comfort of my home. After all, even if I took the vaccine, I would also continue to spread the virus just as someone who did not take it. Another point is: How deadly is this vaccine to someone who is healthy? Is that value so big that we should rush to take not fully tested vaccines? I would get that criticism if there was a rate of 20, 30% of guaranteed death to someone who contracted the virus. At these current values? I think I will take my chances.
- ramraj07 5y agoWhat exactly have this years Nobel research been significant for? Like in real terms?
- cinntaile 5y agoCheck out the image in their scientific motivation to see where this has played a role. https://www.nobelprize.org/uploads/2021/10/press-medicine2021-figure4.jpg https://www.nobelprize.org/uploads/2021/10/press-medicine202...
- ramraj07 5y agoYou can write lists like that for pretty much half the genes in the genome. If you ask a pharma company to rank order genes they would like to get exclusively as targets these would be ranked in 4 digits if not 3. There’s a reason no lab bothered to discover it for so long. Sydney Brenner said in the 60s that they already discovered all there is to molecular biology and leave the details to the “Americans” (1). These are the details. This work would have been pedestrian back in the 60s, it’s downright boring at this point. When people ask why science sucks today this is a great example. Not that this research was performed, of course someone had to at some point. But that people have been led to believe this is worth of celebration at this level. [1] https://www.hobertlab.org/how-the-worm-got-started/ https://www.hobertlab.org/how-the-worm-got-started/ and https://www.genetics.org/content/165/4/1633 https://www.genetics.org/content/165/4/1633
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]