4 ms·
Sorry, this patent is invalid, but your prior art covers a different invention. Page 19 shows a singly-linked list. Page 20 shows nested lists (a list where s
by dpark 15y ago
Sorry, this patent is invalid, but your prior art covers a different invention. Page 19 shows a singly-linked list. Page 20 shows nested lists (a list where some elements are also lists). I don't see anything in this document that covers the same type of multiply-linked lists that the patent claims.
- nitrogen 15y agoAs I vaguely alluded to in another response to one of your comments, the argument could go like this: 1. The linked list was described in 1957 or earlier. 2. The cited mention of the linked list also considers more complex permutations of lists. 3. This patent effectively describes adding a single set of items to multiple lists (I haven't read the patent, so I may be glossing over details). 4. #2 demonstrates that such a permutation of the concept of a list would be obvious to anyone skilled in the art. 5. Therefore, the patent is invalid.
- dpark 15y agoAside from it being obvious, I'm pretty sure there's prior art for specifically what this patent describes. One of the times this was posted to Reddit someone posted a link to a book that describes pretty much exactly what's in this patent, with a diagram no less. http://my.reddit.com/r/programming/comments/1bbb3/congratulations_mingjen_wang_on_patenting_the/c1bc13 http://my.reddit.com/r/programming/comments/1bbb3/congratula...