53 ms·
The main problem with e-ink is finding a display that doesn't cost 5x what an LCD of the same size would cost. This display was $179 before it became unavailabl
by Animats 5y ago
The main problem with e-ink is finding a display that doesn't cost 5x what an LCD of the same size would cost. This display was $179 before it became unavailable. That's on the low end for such displays bigger than phone-sized.
If the e-ink people ever overcome their cost problem, we'll see many more products.
- ghoomketu 5y agoJust curious but is it the lack of mass production or something sinister like patents / monopoly?
- Maxion 5y agoPatents & monopoly
- rcarmo 5y agoWell, to be fair, large displays tend to be fragile and unwieldy as well. Depends a lot on manufacturer, but in essence short production runs also don’t help lower the price.
- spuz 5y agoApparently, this is not true according to an HN user robinsoh who works in the industry. Check his comment history more info: https://news.ycombinator.com/threads?id=robinsoh https://news.ycombinator.com/threads?id=robinsoh
- eli 5y agoI asked someone from Visionect (eInk maker) what was driving the price for large panels and they said the same thing: just not enough volume yet.
- taf2 5y agoAt least this [1] article seems to indicate the presence of patents [1] https://www.businesswire.com/news/home/20171220005895/en/E-Ink-Successfully-Defends-Patent-Infringement-Case https://www.businesswire.com/news/home/20171220005895/en/E-I...
- mannykoum 5y agoHe doesn't seem to ever provide any evidence for his claims other than a repeated "I work in the display industry"..
- robinsoh 5y agoI think you've misunderstood my comments. I saw this recurring theme on HN that electrophoretic panels were expensive due to patents and evil misdeeds by that most evil corporation called E-Corp. I thought, hey, I work in this bloody display industry myself where everything is about volume, volume and more volume, and I hangout with their guys at conferences and events, and I've never heard such a thing as them using patents to attack other industry players. Are they really attacking people and hurting customers that want to use their technology as alleged? So I asked a simple question each time I saw that claim that E Ink uses patents to attack startups or similar claims. What's the evidence? And guess what. Now it turns back to people like you who ask what is my evidence that there's no evil misdeeds. And to which I just feign shock, oh no, it must be true then, since a lack of evidence for them being innocent of the alllegations must mean they are guilty. So we're left back at square 1. I hope people with a smarter mind than mine can arrive at whatever the correct conclusions are.
- riobard 5y agoCould you please tell a bit more about the volume-side of story? Somehow I feel that E-ink is at this weird point on the cost/volume curve because it is a fundamentally flawed display technology: monochrome or a couple of dull colors at best, very slow refresh rate (with ghosting/leftover on partial refresh). LCD/OLED displays were also very expensive initially, but because they're so much appealing universally, loads of money got poured into the industry to make them better and cheaper (mostly due to volume demand). There's no such amount of money/interest in making E-ink better and cheaper :(
- robinsoh 5y agoPlease search my comment history for what I posted about electrophoresis and physics. I don't think they'll be able to get past the physical limitation. To summarize, you either move ink fast but end up losing bistability, or move ink slow, as it is currently. Most people don't realize electrophoresis has remained at about 700ms for an update over the last decade. Tricks like A2 sure with the Dasung, but nothing substantial. As for the comment about "money/interest", see my comments about why a venture capitalist would have little interest in spending billions trying to create new display tech and fighting hard expensive physics problems when they could get higher rate of return by investing in another software service or ML/AI company. That said, Jeff Bezos spent hundred million or more on trying to get Liquavista working, Qualcomm spent lord knows how much on Mirasol. Great demos, but just couldn't get the process scaled or reliable enough to commercialize. Physics is hard. Physics is expensive.
- tokamak-teapot 5y agoI just used an old eBook reader I had lying around. It shows the weather forecast.
- travisporter 5y agoDid you repurpose the screen or use the e-reader software to point to a data source?
- tokamak-teapot 5y agoI used a kit to ‘root’ it and allow installing software. I then installed some handy utility which basically just shows a web page and refreshes it every so often. I just made a simple weather web app which connects to a free service. This works great. I could have written a little Android app to do the same, but my memory of Android UI is that I never ‘got’ it so this seemed easier.
- ppod 5y agoIs there any kind of projector display might would work for this?
- TaylorAlexander 5y agoSure but e-ink is nice as it doesn’t emit light.
- 0xmarcin 5y agoThe project uses tri-color e-ink display. You can downgrade to two colors (and use e.g. dithering to get shades of gray) and get almost the same functionality for less money. Huh, I see non tri-color version is still available in my country (Poland): https://kamami.pl/en/displays-for-raspberry-pi/577635-1248inch-e-paper-module.html https://kamami.pl/en/displays-for-raspberry-pi/577635-1248in... but forget the "less money" part... This project is really cool, but I would prefer to have "a new picture every morning" in a frame than a calendar. For my purposes the e-ink displays are still a bit too small....