5 ms·
I wish laptops would've standardised on the 20V barrel jack (maybe with slightly different sizes to denote current capability), like they almost did before USB-
by userbinator 5y ago
I wish laptops would've standardised on the 20V barrel jack (maybe with slightly different sizes to denote current capability), like they almost did before USB-C came along.
- nikau 5y agoWhat's the advantage of that over usb-pd chargers that also deliver 20V?
- dijit 5y agoThat there aren't as many 5-12v ones that you can accidentally use in place of it? That there aren't a bunch of cables which _might_ work, not to be confused with the same cables that carry data.
- nikau 5y agoYeah but usb-c is safe - if its not the right protocol it just defaults to 5v and nothing gets damaged. Barrel connectors of wrong voltage and/or polarity will let out the magic smoke.
- userbinator 5y agoA much simpler and more robust interface.
- izacus 5y agoWith USB-C charger, I can charge my: - ANC Headphones - Laptop - Tablet - Phone - Portable in-ear headphones and bunch of other stuff I carry around while traveling. All of those with a single 100W laptop charger. I can't do that with a barrel connector. It's a huge improvement despite "confusion" everyone on this site loves harping on.
- dijit 5y agoI'd be very cool with a charging standard that included the needed info. 20v/140w :: 12v/80w etc; and a different connector for _data_ with similar markings for 40G/20G/10G/5G/480Mb
- izacus 5y agoYeah, IMO the issue is really information - ports, cables and chargers should have a clear information about how much power and which data can be delivered.
- ClumsyPilot 5y ago"maybe with slightly different sizes to denote current capability" That's what we had - 10 invonpatiable barrel-jack charging connectors. At a friend's place and want to use his charge? Tough luck. Congratulations. Why do you need supplies with different current to be incompatiable?
- sokoloff 5y agoIn a 20V DC barrel jack case, so you don’t plug in a device with 4 ohms of resistance to a $2.99 charger spec’d (and only capable) to only deliver 20W of power. (Realistically, not every one of those chargers will have a current limiting supply inside.)
- ClumsyPilot 5y agoI think you've rebutted your own point there, laptops cost hunders or thousands, whats with $2.99 power supply? You spill coffee on the laptop and the power brick burns your house down? I shorted many laptop power supplies while using them to test LED's strips, all of them seemed to have current limiting.
- sokoloff 5y agoI don't think that the only (or even most common) source of power supplies in people's houses are from the OEMs of laptops. In an alternative timeline where DC barrel jacks were the standard form factor, you'd have just as many sellers of the cheapest possible power supply in that form factor as you do in the USB-A form factor today. Engineering choices have to take into account the reasonably foreseeable uses and misuses of a design. In this case, having current relating to the barrel diameter seems reasonable. (A phone might prioritize thin-ness and doesn't need a lot of power. A 100W piece of desktop/benchtop gear or a laptop can better afford the increased diameter of the higher current supply. Not to mention that it gives a somewhat intuitive sense to non-engineers.)
- ClumsyPilot 5y ago