5 ms·
One network mitigation for Apple devices (e.g iPads) without a cellular baseband is to have a router block all connections to 17.0.0.0/8, except a once a week c
by walterbell 5y ago
One network mitigation for Apple devices (e.g iPads) without a cellular baseband is to have a router block all connections to 17.0.0.0/8, except a once a week check for OS and app updates. This assumes no use of iCloud, which would siphon much more data than described in this article. It's also necessary to disable Siri on-device search (e.g. "Learn from this app") and Spotlight indexing of in-app content (per-app setting for "Show app in Search"), including E2E encrypted messengers like Signal and Wire.
For phones, the only mitigation is a lifestyle change to switch from always-reachable to scheduled availability windows or the always-async workflows of pre-mobile computing. A faraday bag can deny realtime telemetry, even if it's cached for relay when connectivity returns.
- sneak 5y agoYou can't add an IMAP email account (or a gmail email account) to the device's local mail app with 17./8 blocked on iOS. And, of course, you can't install or update any apps. The iPhone depends on Apple services to function even outside of iCloud and updates. I've tried.
- walterbell 5y agoI've added IMAP email accounts with 17./8 unblocked and then accessed those email accounts later with 17./8 blocked. Most apps aren't updated more than once a week, some are not updated for months. There are a few high-quality iOS apps which support NAS (e.g. WebDAV) for local, surveillance-free, cross-device sync.
- derefr 5y agoMaybe not through the device's local Settings UI, but presumably you could insert the mail account binding through an MDM profile, no?
- walterbell 5y agoYes, Apple Configurator can be used to install IMAP accounts, including password. Gmail accounts require password entry on the device, even if the account is installed via Apple Configurator.
- derefr 5y ago> Gmail accounts require password entry on the device, even if the account is installed via Apple Configurator. Is that still true, if the password provided in the profile is an App Password for the account? IIRC those can be used for direct IMAP access to Gmail's servers without those servers complaining; so I would expect them to also work fine for creating a Gmail web-API binding.
- jeroenhd 5y agoWouldn't this kill the phone's ability to receive notifications? I don't think apps can just poll their servers like it's 2010 anymore.
- walterbell 5y agoYes, battery-conserving notification interrupts are part of an always-reachable lifestyle, which requires surrender to behavioral telemetry with the potential long-term consequence of influencing the human's behavior (e.g. via advertising). Regardless of an app's implementation of polling/notifications, most apps will poll servers when first started or network service is restored.
- judge2020 5y agoApple provides a list of IPs used by APNS if you need it but want to block the rest of 17 or 2620:149:: (I believe the other IPv6 prefixes are for non-US use). https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT203609 https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT203609
- walterbell 5y agoSuper useful, thanks. Good that Apple provides this "stable firewall interface".
- nnamtr 5y agoWould a transparent HTTPS proxy be able to intercept traffic (once you install the certificate on the phone), or are the certificates pinned?
- suifbwish 5y agoNot traffic that is being sent via other protocols or on different ports. One way of doing this would be setting up a computer to pass its internet connection via NAT firewall rules to the apple device and behave like an access point. From there you could dump the raw traffic to/from the apple device. Regarding encrypted content, it’s probable that the telemetry and other info being sent is signed with a key that is not available in user space so you wouldn’t be able to add a key to view it. However you would definitey be able to see it being sent and the packet size/frequency ect
- oneplane 5y agoThere is almost no point in buying an ecosystem-dependant device and then trying to cut off the ecosystem dependency. This goes for iOS and Android alike. In some ways, even cellular connectivity itself is problematic or any baseband system that requires some form of out-of-band processing to function (even if it doesn't "call home"). Most people won't know (or care) about any of this anyway, and the disruption trade for some invisible gains that are supposed to come out of unplugging like this isn't likely to attract any reasonable mass of users to do it. It would probably be mostly destructive anyway considering the information flow of civilisation depends on so much of this integration now. Technically we could do without all of this, but practically it would be luddite's errand to try and do any this. I wonder what we could do instead, but considering the min-maxing for profit sets the stage today, I doubt someone can come up with an alternative that yields the same (perceived) benefit from using Google's or Apple's technologies. Considering most new people from the past few years are primarily mobile users and a lot of those never even had access to (or a need for) a desktop-like type computing, there is very little mindshare about what else might be possible in the digital realm.
- lloydgrossman 5y ago> There is almost no point in buying an ecosystem-dependant device and then trying to cut off the ecosystem dependency. ...the only alternative right now is throwing cash at a librem5 and there's still plenty of work until it's feasible for a linux phone as a daily driver.
- walterbell 5y agoThere's also Jolla Sailfish (descendant of Nokia Maemo/Meego, funded by Russia) which works on Sony Xperia 10 II. The free version doesn't support Android apps. The paid version does, but is technically only sold to EU customers. Looking further ahead, Pinephone development is active.
- usr1106 5y agoTo clarify you should say: Nowadays funded by Russia, it hasn't been always like that. The question of course is whether they do anything equally bad as either Google/Apple or the NSA. It looks obvious to me that Russia funds this because they don't want the former inside their devices. Trying to run their own mass surveillance using Sailfish wou be pretty much a waste of resources. There are no masses that use it and the Russian opposition could easily avoid touching such device. However, in typical Stalin/KGB/Putin-style paranoia you would want to eavesdrop your friends to make sure they don't work against you. So that is somewhat worrying. Disclaimer: Typed on a Sailfish device.
- ClumsyPilot 5y ago"The only mitigation is a lifestyle change to switch from always-reachable to scheduled availability windows or the always-async workflows of pre-mobile computing." I always had a call recorder installed on my mobile, it saved my bacon a few times when dealing with scammy companies and various wankers. Then a wakeup call arrives for me - my phone updates to the new version of android, on which google blocked call recording. I installed a landline, and stopped spending money on fancy phones. I can't eacape them, but they will never see me spend more than a bare minimum.
- kaba0 5y agoSince recording laws are illegal in most places without mutual consent..
- ClumsyPilot 5y agoI don't know about most places, it's perfectly legal in UK and Czech republic. Every time you call a firm, they record you, and will use it against you.
- kaba0 5y agoBut afaik they have to notify you of the recording.
- ClumsyPilot 5y agoOkay, I will tell them I am recording, now can I have my record button back Google? What do you mean no? Secondly, its still legal to record without notifying in Uk, you just arent allowed to use it in court
- alpaca128 5y agoI don't find that reason convincing. Recording videos in public is also often illegal in many places, yet all smartphones come with 2-7(?) cameras. The web browser lets you download pirated content from shady sources. You can post illegal text-based content (defamation etc.) in various apps. You could probably even cause some noise complaints with the alarm app. And that's just preinstalled software.
- matheusmoreira 5y ago> For phones, the only mitigation is a lifestyle change I've been considering buying a Linux phone. Does anyone here own one?
- bigiain 5y agoMy PinePhone turned up this week. It, ummmm, very rough around the edges, software wise. So far I have only used the default Manjaro distribution it came with. Im both looking forward to, and dreading, working my way through a dozen or so alternative distros to find the least worst collection of brokenness and bugs. But I 100% knew what I was buying into when I paid for it, and am very happy I have it.
- matheusmoreira 5y agoI found the pinephone in my research. It seemed nice but the hardware specifications were really underwhelming. I'm used to buying flagship phones with the best hardware available and using them for years and years. > It, ummmm, very rough around the edges, software wise. I can imagine. How's the driver situation? Lots of proprietary blobs? What about the device itself? Build quality? I see it has hardware switches for RF and sensors, I really like that. > So far I have only used the default Manjaro distribution it came with. I wonder why Manjaro and not stock Arch Linux.
- blendergeek 5y ago> How's the driver situation? Lots of proprietary blobs? Interestingly enough, no, the drivers are all open source and mainlined. There is even a work-in-progress driver for hardware video decoding. There are a couple proprietary firmware blobs that have to be loaded at boot time but that is just like on a laptop.
- matheusmoreira 5y ago> Interestingly enough, no, the drivers are all open source and mainlined. There is even a work-in-progress driver for hardware video decoding. That's amazing. So unlike Android phones I can actually use a stock kernel. I think I'm gonna buy one. > There are a couple proprietary firmware blobs that have to be loaded at boot time but that is just like on a laptop. So the kernel itself is not tainted? I'm fine with that.