3 ms·
> This is why I am trying to get the VR/AR industry to care about the changes going on with Apple Music and its investments in 3D music. Really? Spatial audio
by smoldesu 5y ago
> This is why I am trying to get the VR/AR industry to care about the changes going on with Apple Music and its investments in 3D music.
Really? Spatial audio has been solved here for years, the last thing we need is Another Competing Standard that isn't open and relies on specialized hardware.
> If you have an Android phone, good for you. It doesn’t sound as good as Apple’s ecosystem.
If you have an Android phone, there's a pretty good chance it has an internal DAC, which puts it's objective audio quality above the latest iPhone. Sorry to all the psychoacoustic nerds out there, but AAC is still not lossless. And lines like...
> Yes, if you aren’t on Apple Music you are an idiot.
...don't do a whole lot to reinforce their argument.
If you're going to be objective, be objective. If you're writing an opinion piece, be opinionated. Crossing the two leads to head-scratching rhetoric like this, which makes me wonder if it's written by a fanboy or someone who genuinely does not understand hi-fi and spatial audio. I'd like to believe it's neither, but little in the article substantiates that.
- p2t2p 5y agoYou seem to be unaware that with a flip of a toggle Apple Music serves lossless to you.
- smoldesu 5y agoGreat lot of good that does you when you're listening with Airpods or anything wireless. You're locked in 320kbps AAC no matter what, and everything goes through Apple's psychoacoustic treatment. Even if you are one of the ~5% of Mac users who's got their DAC plugged in to their high-impedance headphones, you could be getting the same experience or better on pretty much all of your other (non-DirectSound) hardware.
- threeseed 5y agoSo few things wrong here: a) Bit rate has improved from 256kbps to 320kbps. b) It's a lossless path all the way to your Mac which encodes and streams AAC to your Airpod. There is no psychoacoustic treatment since obviously you use Airpods for tasks other than music which it would interfere with. For me personally I have noticed a significant improvement with using lossless audio with my Airpods.
- DiabloD3 5y agoI agree with this analysis. A lot of this article is just typical audiophile wank. I actually own rather high end gear, not because I "am an audiophile", but because I enjoy objective measurements. I bought objectively well measuring equipment, and the equipment is beyond the most golden of ears. The only thing Apple has done right, audio-wise, in years is their iTunes Plus AAC encoder (one of two encoders that do to AAC what LAME does to MP3), and their cheap USB-C dongle (of the <$50 audio dongles, it beats the rest, although a bit quiet on lower efficiency headphones; ironically, their Lightning one, same tiny circuit board, isn't as good). Anything with speakers is just overpriced mediocre garbage. Apple has lossless now, but most of their library isn't in lossless, and they aren't even the largest lossless music streamer. The experience of their app has an awful UX on all platforms (including iOS/OSX tbh), but to be absolutely fair, the "winner" in this space is Spotify, and they aren't winning any awards either (and they don't have lossless yet). Anyone who is into music just owns their favorite music in lossless, in a format they dictate, in software they dictate.
- moogly 5y ago> Anyone who is into music just owns their favorite music in lossless, in a format they dictate, in software they dictate. This is me. I don't use Spotify nor Apple Music or any of those subscription services. I use self-hosted Subsonic for streaming and buy all new stuff on Bandcamp or HDtracks.
- threeseed 5y ago> Anyone who is into music just owns their favorite music in lossless Apple has access to the 24-bit masters [1] so when they are encoding they have access to far more dynamic range than if you are ripping from a CD in lossless format. For me being into music I want the best quality so will be sticking with Apple. [1] https://www.apple.com/apple-music/apple-digital-masters/docs/apple-digital-masters.pdf https://www.apple.com/apple-music/apple-digital-masters/docs...